 |
EngLit Seminar extension for the students in English Literature at CUNBM
|
| Subiectul anterior :: Subiectul urmator |
| Autor |
Mesaj |
iusco anuta Rookie

Data inscrierii: 19/Noi/2012 Mesaje: 7 Localitate: baia mare
|
Trimis: 12/02/2015 15:00 Titlul subiectului: To the Lighthouse Virginia Woolf |
|
|
1. Chapter two: "No going to the lighthouse James", he said, as trying in deference to Mrs. Ramsay to soften his voice into same semblance of geniality at least. Odious little man, thought Mrs. Ramsay, why go on saying that?
Considering you have read only this chapter, can you form an opinion about Mr. and Mrs. Ramsay? Why do you think this chapter is so short?
2. In this novel time passes very slow sometimes, and other times ( like in Part Two) time just speeds by. What is the effect of the passage of time? discuss the use of brackets in Part Two.
3. What is the function of "to" in the title in your opinion? Why isn't the title just "The Lighthouse?
4. Why do you think Mrs. Ramsay can't or won't tell her husband that she loves him? Does this say something about the Victorian marriage? _________________ iusco |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
gabriela Dunker

Data inscrierii: 20/Ian/2013 Mesaje: 11 Localitate: Viseu de Sus
|
Trimis: 12/02/2015 21:42 Titlul subiectului: To the Lighthouse /1 |
|
|
At first sight,I may think that the Ramsey family is a family that argues alot,that have differences about her own point of view..The family apears like that: a mother that is a kind one and a severe father,that has in the family always the last word...the mother does not have courage to say it ,only apearing with his toughts("odious little man")...Those two characters apear in contradiction and startig the chapter with a negative response to James may the readers think that Mr.Ramsay is ,in opposision with Mrs.Ramsay ,a man that makes the decisions in the house,a man that doesn t know communicate with his family and also seams to be a little cruel...
" ....as trying in deference to Mrs.Ramsay to soften his voice into same semblance of geniality at least"-These words reflects a man that is imposing in his family,that everybody seams to listening him and also denotes a man that askes respect and loyality.
This chapter is so short because I think that suggest the entire semnification of this book,the motiv "The Lighthouse",is a simbol of the ireversible time,and this is one of most disscused..Virginia Woolf,I think that keept this chapter short for us to reflect of the condision of the family,the differences of opinion,the toughts (we find in the book many toughts,that also can mean lack of courage). |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
gabriela Dunker

Data inscrierii: 20/Ian/2013 Mesaje: 11 Localitate: Viseu de Sus
|
Trimis: 12/02/2015 23:10 Titlul subiectului: To the Lighthouse /2 |
|
|
In Part One,we see a Virginia Woolf that gives minute details of a single afternoon and evening,and in Part Two we see an entire decade passing very fast, in barely twenty pages.I think that the Part One(The Window) reflects a time that barely passes because the narrator wants us to stop for a whild and reflect on each character,his manner of beinging,his ambisions,....this part is full of realistic facts,of emotions and fears that are detailed by the narrator (we have entire pages of description).Part Two comes with the complish of Mr.Ramsay fear that "there is little hope for human immortality",the death of his wife,the death of Prue,along with the impact of the World War I to the entire world...Virginia Wolf doesn t uses pages of description,but is offering to the readers the vision of the time that was cruel and cannot be stoped...
The passages like:
[Prue Ramsay, leaning on her father’s arm, was given in marriage. What, people said, could have been more fitting? And, they added, how beautiful she looked!]
[Mr. Ramsay, stumbling along a passage one dark morning, stretched his arms out, but Mrs. Ramsay having died rather suddenly the night before, his arms, though stretched out, remained empty.]
..reflects images of death( I want to say that in the Victorian Age,death receives an entire ritual,starting with Quinn Victoria/the death of Prince Albert/ that entire <doliu national> for the whole country ,starting with keeping the dead person in the house 3 days and also taking pictures of the dead person with the family),I sad images of death because Virginia presents them like pictures,we can fotografie how they stand and also the image of the beauty Prue...
The other brackets:
[A shell exploded. Twenty or thirty young men were blown up in France, among them Andrew Ramsay, whose death, mercifully, was instantaneous.]
[Mr. Carmichael brought out a volume of poems that spring, which had an unexpected success. The war, people said, had revived their interest in poetry.]
....shown us the cruel war,the World War I and his effect on the human being..
Ultima modificare efectuata de catre gabriela la 12/02/2015 23:58, modificat de 1 data in total |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
gabriela Dunker

Data inscrierii: 20/Ian/2013 Mesaje: 11 Localitate: Viseu de Sus
|
Trimis: 12/02/2015 23:20 Titlul subiectului: To the Lighthouse /3 |
|
|
| I think that the title represents a purpose,a meaning, a whole sense of the novel...The function of the preposition to ,in my opinion,is very important because it reflects the entire porpose ,we need to reach something,we need to acomplish something...The title sends us to think that will be a journey. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
gabriela Dunker

Data inscrierii: 20/Ian/2013 Mesaje: 11 Localitate: Viseu de Sus
|
Trimis: 12/02/2015 23:38 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
In the Victorian Age,model for all the womens were Quinn Victoria,that were (surprising for those times married with Prince Albert by love) a women that loved much her husband...I think Mrs. Ramsay won t tell her husband that she loves him,keeping a mark of secret of herself,is not a mark of insensibility but is the way that he is,more profound ....
| Citat: | | Ea nu putea spune .... Aşa cum ea se uită la el a început să zâmbeasca, pentru ca deşi ea nu spusese un cuvânt, el ştia, desigur, el ştia, că ea îl iubea. El nu putea nega aceasta. |
|
|
| Sus |
|
 |
iusco anuta Rookie

Data inscrierii: 19/Noi/2012 Mesaje: 7 Localitate: baia mare
|
Trimis: 13/02/2015 00:48 Titlul subiectului: To the Lighthouse Virginia Woolf |
|
|
1. To complete Gabriela's answer I would say that this chapter not only enhances the differences of opinion between Mr and Mrs. Ramsay but also tells us something about their relationship with James. We can guess that James has expressed his desire to visit the lighthouse several times , and each time Mr. Ramsay didn't agree. This means that their relationship is not too close. On the other hand Mrs. Ramsay seems to sympathize with James but doesn't really stand for him, keeping her thoughts to herself. Now we may be tempted to ask ourselves why doesn't she say that she wants James to go to the lighthouse, and why doesn't she confront her husband? One answer could be that the parents shouldn't contradict themselves in front of their child, because this can undermine one parent's authority and also confuses the child. But I doubt that Mr. and Mrs. Ramsay have read a parenting book in that era, and the reason why Mrs. Ramsay prefers to keep quiet has nothing to do with parenting rules. _________________ iusco |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
iusco anuta Rookie

Data inscrierii: 19/Noi/2012 Mesaje: 7 Localitate: baia mare
|
Trimis: 13/02/2015 02:20 Titlul subiectului: To the Lighthouse Virginia Woolf |
|
|
2. At first, I thought it was a little odd how important things like the death of Mrs. Ramsay and the effects of the war are told in just a few lines. It is true that images like death and cruelties are not nice, but I would have liked to know a bit more about what had happened, mostly because the first part of the novel focuses on Mrs. Ramsay.
But after a closer analysis , I came to the conclusion that comprising a decade in a few pages and using brackets to inform us about important events gives the novel unity and continuity. The continuity is expressed by Lily's consciousness which is tied up to Mrs. Ramsay. This way Mrs. Ramsay continues to live through Lily's thoughts. Time can't be measured through the lenses of consciousness, because, for instance, you can take a moment from life and make it permanent through your memories, or you can live a full life and have nothing worth to value or remember. _________________ iusco |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
iusco anuta Rookie

Data inscrierii: 19/Noi/2012 Mesaje: 7 Localitate: baia mare
|
Trimis: 13/02/2015 03:04 Titlul subiectului: To the Lighthouse Virginia Woolf |
|
|
3. I agree that "to the lighthouse" means a journey. But the question is what kind of a journey? So let's analyze this!
In the first part James is so willing to go to the lighthouse but his father digs his heels in against it. On the other hand, in the third part, Mr. Ramsay insists that they "must" go. All this makes me wonder what exactly the lighthouse represents?
If we get into symbols and imagery, we will find out that the lighthouse represents family, especially paternal authority. That's why James wants to go so badly , because he is rebelling against his father.
Mr. Ramsay persuades his children, in the third part of the novel, to go to the lighthouse because he wants to reinforce his place as the head of the family, this giving him power.
"To" is important because the novel is about individuals and their strive for a place in a broken family. The children want to find ways of dealing with their father and the authority that he represents.
If the title had been just "The Lighthouse" then we wouldn't talk about a journey, but about a setting. This means that there would be no struggle against any kind of authority but about the acceptance of it. _________________ iusco |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
iusco anuta Rookie

Data inscrierii: 19/Noi/2012 Mesaje: 7 Localitate: baia mare
|
Trimis: 13/02/2015 04:05 Titlul subiectului: To the Lighthouse Virginia Woolf |
|
|
4. Queen Victoria might have been in live with Prince Albert , but in that era marriage was more about a contract between a man and a woman than a union between two lovers. Marriage could give a man or a woman a good social position, or all kind of other advantages. Men had all the privileges, they had access to education, they could have a job, entertain themselves and spend money, whereas women usually managed the household and carried children. the wife had to obey her husband , not to love him.
we know from the novel that Mr. Ramsay was a philosopher : | Citat: | | He had made a definite contribution to philosophy in one little book when he was only five and twenty. | [/code]Virginia Woolf :To the Lighthousewhile Mrs. Ramsay was a simple wife and mother: | Citat: | | She would have liked always to have a baby. she was happiest carrying one in her arms. |
Considering this I think that Mrs. Ramsay looked at her husband as being superior to her, and therefore even if she did love him, and even if he longed for a sign of love, she didn't tell him. I fotografie that this was because admitting her love for him would make him even more superior to her, and too far to reach afterwards. This way she denied herself the plăcere to find out that he loved her back, and settled to keep the distance. | Citat: | | So that is marriage, Lily thought, a man and a woman looking at a girl throwing a ball. |
_________________ iusco |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
gabriela Dunker

Data inscrierii: 20/Ian/2013 Mesaje: 11 Localitate: Viseu de Sus
|
Trimis: 13/02/2015 21:04 Titlul subiectului: To the Lighthouse /4 |
|
|
Anuta,I want to add something to your response at the question "4. Why do you think Mrs. Ramsay can't or won't tell her husband that she loves him? Does this say something about the Victorian marriage?"...Yes,endeed,you are right saying that the women in that era were inferior to men(the head of the familly was the man)..and this thing happend because the woman didnt have rights equal with the man,she didnt have job,she stays behind the man for various reasons specific of that era...I want to say that Virginia Woolf was one of fiew writters that wanted the emancipation of woman and writtes a short essay called " A room for each one"(I dont know if I translated well,"O camera pentru fiecare") were he shows how much wanted to change this stereotypes,I could say...
„ | Citat: | | Femeile au fost întotdeauna sărace şi asta, nu numai de două sute de ani încoace. Nevestele au avut mai puţină libertate chiar şi decât copiii sclavilor atenieni. Soțiile nu au avut prin urmare ocazia de a scrie poeme. Iată de ce insist asupra banilor şi asupra dreptului de a avea o «camera» a lor” | .
In "To the Lighthouse" ,Msr.Ramsay don t tell her husband that she loves him,not for not beeing inlove with him but I think that women of that time were more..to herself with feelings,and this fact was for living in this way entire generation of womens,so I think that she didnt think that Mr.Ramsay loocked at her more superior if she confes his fellings..I think that the way how they(the womens) were rised in their own familly it marks her destiny and made them so could...(if we will try to say allways at our daughters that is wrong experssing your feelings they will rice knowing that is wrong )..
Anuta,can you express your opinnion about what Virginia says about women,I am refering to the words about freedom and slavery..
| Citat: | | Femeile au avut mai puţină libertate chiar şi decât copiii sclavilor atenieni. |
Why Woolf compares the life of women with those of slaves?It s a little bit rough don t you think? |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Tirean Magdalena Dunker

Data inscrierii: 04/Oct/2012 Mesaje: 11 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 13/02/2015 21:50 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| I agree that women were seen as weak, fragile creatures but I think that it's a little bit too much to compare the life of a victorian women with a slave.They characterized women by lack of desire for knowledge but they olso saw them as being angelic.I think that victorian men refused to provide power to women fearing that they could succed better than themselves if women have the opportunity to have control. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
iusco anuta Rookie

Data inscrierii: 19/Noi/2012 Mesaje: 7 Localitate: baia mare
|
Trimis: 13/02/2015 23:05 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
What Virginia Woolf says about women is like an eternal truth. Men always have been and always will be superior to women because of the circumstances the women face in their way to progress. What I want to say is that women are not stupider or less talented than men, but it's pretty near impossible for them to do good work, artistic or otherwise, when a husband or some children keep bugging them around. Even nowadays discrimination between men and women does exist. There are employers who prefer men over women. Lets just think about how many women won Nobel Prizes along the history. The answer is 12. How comes that? Are men more intelligent? Maybe. Well, women usually have to choose between family life and career, because they can't manage both of them extraordinarily. Men, on the other hand, even I they have a family they can also dedicate themselves to a career, because they don't have to cook, to clean the house, or to get up in middle of the night to feed the baby. Even if we live in a modern society the discrimination exists. Is it fair? Of course not. So, I think that Virginia Woolf didn't exaggerate when she compared women to Athenian slave 's children. _________________ iusco |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
gabriela Dunker

Data inscrierii: 20/Ian/2013 Mesaje: 11 Localitate: Viseu de Sus
|
Trimis: 13/02/2015 23:43 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
I'm starting to like writting
So,I agree with Magda about the women beeing an angelic one.Yes,the women were seen like a kind,angelic and never interfiering in men's bussines:)...I also liked very much what Anuta are saying about how wimen during the history time were never let to express them selves...It's truth that women always(this is how is created) have to make all of the work,take care of the children and also beeing good at their job...In the Victorian time he was the preety face of the familly,without courage,with his mind only at the familly,without rights and surprinsingly manage to live their lives in that way....In our days,I want to ad that women are more powerfull,and surpringly they manage to take care of the familly and also having jobs(and others also making the studies in the same time ) )so...I think that man also helps ,in our time ,the women and for this reason I think that the discrimination with time to time will vanish...  |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
|
|
Nu puteti crea un subiect nou in acest forum Nu puteti raspunde in subiectele acestui forum Nu puteti modifica mesajele proprii din acest forum Nu puteti sterge mesajele proprii din acest forum Nu puteti vota in chestionarele din acest forum
|
|