 |
EngLit Seminar extension for the students in English Literature at CUNBM
|
| Subiectul anterior :: Subiectul urmator |
| Autor |
Mesaj |
Alexandra Marchis Dunker

Data inscrierii: 11/Noi/2009 Mesaje: 12
|
Trimis: 01/05/2012 12:24 Titlul subiectului: The Floating Opera John Barth |
|
|
The Floating Opera chronicles one day of Todd Andrews life. In this day Todd Andrews answers himself a very important question: is there any reason to die?. Todd Andrews is a man with a heart disease and more important, with several existential difficulties. Knowing he will not have much time to live he is thinking of the idea of committing suicide. In fact, Todd's disease is more psychological one rather than physical. This disease comes from his family history. First of all his mother died, his father treated him badly; and as this it was not enough he found his father hung. Very much of his "rationality" is due to this childhood traumas;and because of these traumas he is not capable of regaining his equilibrium. Todd sees life as an absurd thing that does not worth living and the only way to escape this is to commit suicide. All his life he is trying to explain himself the absurd suicide of his father and the fact that he does not talk about this is clearly a form of denial.The truth is that he lacks the love and the support of his family, thing that made him reflect too much on his dark past. He rejects rationality.He writes an Inquiry in which he tries to explain the cause of his father death and dialogues he had. This methodology is part of the solution he search,moving the emphasis from the psychological, sentimental to something physic. But this can easily be an excuse not to commit suicide.
As a consequence of these existential issues, Todd follows several wrong paths. Firstly, he does not really believe in marriage. He sees his wife only as an alternative to the real family. More, he enters a love triangle, letting his wife sleep another man.
He is not able to control his life, and he recognizes this as a cause of what he experienced. Secondly,he finds sexuality hilarious. His first intercourse was full of ridiculous and no romance at all. At first, he had an heroic image about himself but when he gets to the moment of seeing himself in the mirror he only sees an animal. In fact, in his opinion all humans are animals bare of rational basis for human values and action.
In my opinion i think that Todd would have develop a more positive view of life if he did not have part of his father suicide.
What i find interesting in this book is the fact that you do not get all narrative.You only get bits of it. Still, you don't have to struggle to reproduce it because the author is offering you the interpretation. He doesn't want us to decrypt it but to take it exactly how it is given. Because he believes in the idea of writing for enjoyment and not for interpretation, the author gives you any bit of interpretation you might come up with to send critics away.
Todd has an obsession with names. This is because his name means death in German. He thinks that because of the name he is doomed to a life of misery and death.
One element of plotting is the question: do you want to know what happened that day? This is a very good substitute for plot because you will only find out the answer at the end of the book. The narrative keeps you wonder why is he alive. Was something inside him or was it external?
In the end we see that the arguments of living (is there any reason to die?No.) are the arguments of dying; because reasons fail at most crucial moments and rationality does not always provide solution. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
izabellstrimb Plunger

Data inscrierii: 17/Mar/2011 Mesaje: 35
|
Trimis: 01/05/2012 20:20 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
It is written in the first person, and the story takes place during one single day in Todd's life. The firs observation is about his name. He says that:
"Todd Andrews is my name. You can spell it with one or two d's; I get letters addresedeither way. I almost warned you against the single -d spelling, for fear you'd say, 'Tod is German for death..."
This observation is important because it is a kind of anticipation of the end of the book, and it also showes that he is obsesed by death, which he compares to a boat.
What is unique is the fact that the author is offering to every symbolism the answer and their possible signification. By this he points out the riguros signification or interpretation and does not allow any extra meanings given by the reader nor the critiques. But before he he highlights the fact that what he's about to say is very important. If we are asked to indentify postmodern themes in the "Floating Opera" we could say the following:
- not allowing any interpretations by giving the right signification
- the failure of reason
- the author speaks as an outsider, and tells his readers that he is not a professional writter, to understand this thing, and that he just wants to tell the story. There are a few chapters in which he highlights the fact that he does not want to overdo himself, he just want to tell us the things the way they are, nothing extra. He also highlights the fact that dealing with one's memory is not a simple task, and that we should be patient. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
izabellstrimb Plunger

Data inscrierii: 17/Mar/2011 Mesaje: 35
|
Trimis: 01/05/2012 20:36 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
By wanting to find out more about his fathers death , he ends up puting adânc questions about life and death, is it all worth it, what's the meaning of life, what's his role in life, what should he accomplish in life ect. I confess that I read the book in my second year, but in romanian, but the situation is the same eighter way you read it: You could very simply identify yourself in this part. Everyone has a certain point in his life when he asks himself the same questions, and just dying to get an answer.
" Is there any reason to die? No"
He ends up with the answer that the same reason or arguments for living are the same for dying. This philosophical thinking is trigered by his crucial points he wisited in the past:
- war - of cours that those memories haunt him, all those lifes he took.
- his father's suicide
He mentions at one point that even though the celler was full of dust, his father's boddy was perfectly clean. I think this is his way of avoiding reality and shock. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Adelinne Diver

Data inscrierii: 11/Noi/2009 Mesaje: 62
|
Trimis: 02/05/2012 20:36 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
I have to say I really enjoyed reading this book. I loved the breaking of the rules..actually there are no rules in this text. What once was forbidden now is permitted: the narrator offers the reader a whole invitation to the Floating Opera, he, at some point, writes the text on two columns, he does what he wants, he says what he wants, he has no constraints in expressing his thoughts. He doesn’t leave us the chance to interpret his words, but he gives us everything on the plate. He even advertise us about the spelling of his name
| Citat: | | So. Todd Andrews is my name. You can spell it with one or two d's: I get letters addressed either way. I almost warned you against the single-d spelling, for fear you'd say. "Tod is German for death: perhaps the name is symbolic. "I myself use two d's, partly in order to avoid that symbolism. But you see, I ended by not warning you at all, anf that's because it just occurred to me that the double-d Todd is symbolic, too, and accurately so. Tod is death, and this book hasn't much to do with death; Todd is almost Tod - - almost death - - and this book, if it gets written, has very much to do with almost-death. |
He annihilates all the mystery which characterizes a book and tells us each and every detail. He even tells us what this book will be about; paradoxically he anticipates the reader’s thoughts
| Citat: | | And that's how this book will work, I'm sure. It's a floating opera, friend, fraught with curiosities, melodrama, spectacle, instruction, and entertainment, but it floats willy-nilly on the tide of my vagrant prose: you'll catch sight of it, lose it, spy it again; and it may require the best efforts of your attention and imagination - - together with some patience, if you're an average fellow - - to keep track of the plot as it sails in and out of view. |
The death of his father had a very strong impact on his life as it determined him to do the same act. Also, he tried to explain to himself his father’s act, he tried to put himself into his father’s shoes and justify his act.
Another aspect that I found interesting was his conception about love. He doesn’t have an answer to the question: What is love? But he has several variants for the definition of this feeling
| Citat: | | I'd never understood personally what love is and feels like. are the differences between, say, one's love for his wife, his mistress, his parents, his cats, his nation, his hobby, his species, his books, and his natural environment differences in kind, or merely in degree? If in kind, are the kinds definable to the point of intelligibility? If in degree, is the necessarily general definition which can cover them all so general as to be meaningless? Is this thing a fact of nature, like thirst, or purely a human and civilized invention? If he is in love who simply decides to say, "I'm in love", then love I'd never known, for often as I'd said "I am in love," I'd said it always to women who expected to hear it, never to myself. As for copulation, whether between humans or other sorts of animals, it makes me smile. |
I found interesting and courageous the comparison he makes between humans and animals, a very strong idea which could not be changed by anyone and remained in his thoughts
| Citat: | | It is one thing to agree intellectually to the proposition that man is a species of animal; quite another to realize, thoroughly and for good, your personal animality, to the extent that you are actually never able to oppose the terms man and animal, even in casual speech; never abla to regard your fellow creatures except as more or less intelligent, more or less healthy, more or less dangerous, more or less adequate fauna; never able to regard their accomplishments except as the tricks of more or less well-trained beasts. In my case this has been true since that night, and no one - - not my father, nor Jane, nor myself - - have I been able even for a clipă to regard differently. |
Another interesting philosophy is the one of “Nothing is valuable in itself”
| Citat: | | Nothing is valuable in itself. Not even truth; not even his truth. I am not a philosopher, except after the fact; but I am a mean rationalizer, and once the world has forced me into a new position, I can philosophize (or rationalize) like two Kants, like seven Philadelphia lawyers. Beginning with my new conclusions, I can work out first-rate premises. | and | Citat: | On this particular evening, to be sure, their progress would cease, for the notes I took then I intended to be my last.
I. Nothing has intrinsic value.
II. The reasons for which people attribute value to things are always ultimately irrational.
III. there is, therefore, no ultimate "reason" for valuing anything. |
He undresses himself of his word clothes and offers his true personality and the masks that existed in his life. He accepts in front of everyone a reality that only he was aware of. The masks that hid the things he wanted to remain hidden or revealed, according to the case. I think we all have a mask.. we behave different when we are in certain circumstances and when we are all by ourselves we are simply us.. or we can wear masks when we are alone and, as in the case of Todd, hiding, in this way, things from our mind or from our soul
| Citat: | | My heart, reader! My heart! You must comprehend quickly, if you are to comprehend at all that those masks were not assumed to hide my face, but to hide my heart from my mind, and my mind from my heart. Understand it now, because I may not live to end this chapter! To be sure, each mask hid other things as well, as falseface hides identity and personality as well as nose and mouth; but it was to hide my enigmatic heart that I became a rake, a saint, and then a cynic. For when one mask no longer served its purpose of disguise, another had perforce to take its place at once |
|
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Persida-Mara Dunker

Data inscrierii: 26/Noi/2009 Mesaje: 19 Localitate: MM
|
Trimis: 14/05/2012 15:08 Titlul subiectului: The Floating Opera John Barth |
|
|
| Todd is for me like an experiment, like a guinea pig that researchers choose to operate him, but here Barth is the researcher, and he made the character Todd that is obsessed especially in his name that means death but after all we all die one day.I believe that Barth know very well tastes of the reader, he know that we like obsessions, not only because maybe is a shame for us to reveal our obsession, but the fact that all of us have one. The fact that I find in the book a triangle make my reading to raise, and even the fact that he wanted to suicide creates me a big interests, but know when I'm thinking I realize that the suicide, and the love affair if we can say like that(because Jane's husband knows about this) are two heavy sins that many people care nowadays. If the suicide is only thinking the affair is made. We can discuss here even about the losing of the faith because his father was find hung, his name means death,Todd is like a man that lost all he had more grant: his parents(maybe). |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
larisapop Plunger

Data inscrierii: 09/Noi/2009 Mesaje: 36 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 25/05/2012 19:11 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
Usually one sais a good book is the one that gives you answers to life questions. This book sends some questions to the reader but doesn't provide clear answers. Somethimes this is the best situation for one to find a story very interesting. We were asked to read this book at one romanian class last year, but I didn't read it. People said it was a boring book, but despite this, when we were asked to read it this semester, I actually did. My point was to see whether it really is a boring book or not. If people consider their lives as being boring, then probably this book is boring. But what I've seen in this book was the story of a regular man and what he had to say about himself, did not seem boring to me. Actually, the fact that he told us from the beginning that he wanted to kill himself, was the start to a very interesting action. Some of the questions of life he pronounces never receive an answer in this book, but probably this is what makes some regular answers become the best. This story really has the power to keep the reader's attention awake untill the end of it. What is really nice to see in this book is the way the narrator addresses to the reader: "Now, reader, you must be wondering...". By saying this he makes the reader be more involved in his intimate life, thing that always made people interested. The way he tells everything makes you want to write, giving you the feeling that you would be able to describe just as good as he does. But once started we would realize that our words are not good enough and not well arranged as to provide so much interest in the audience. The situation with the love triangle seems at first a bit like it is an image taken from these days transposed in a world 50 years ago. This is one of the things that would keep the interest of readers because it seems to be very actual and still a bit taboo. And people like to hear and see what they shouldn't. _________________ You don't write because you want to say something, you write because you've got something to say. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Razvan517 Plunger


Data inscrierii: 07/Noi/2009 Mesaje: 28 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 27/05/2012 15:40 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| izabellstrimb a scris: | It is written in the first person, and the story takes place during one single day in Todd's life. The firs observation is about his name. He says that:
"Todd Andrews is my name. You can spell it with one or two d's; I get letters addresedeither way. I almost warned you against the single -d spelling, for fear you'd say, 'Tod is German for death..."
This observation is important because it is a kind of anticipation of the end of the book, and it also showes that he is obsesed by death, which he compares to a boat. |
I don't think he is obsessed with death, even though it may appear to be so since we have death in the whole book, I think we have here like Alexandra Marchis said:
| Citat: | | What i find interesting in this book is the fact that you do not get all narrative.You only get bits of it. Still, you don't have to struggle to imită it because the author is offering you the interpretation. He doesn't want us to decrypt it but to take it exactly how it is given. Because he believes in the idea of writing for enjoyment and not for interpretation, the author gives you any bit of interpretation you might come up with to send critics away. |
So this could still be a way to send critics or readers away from the meaning of death. Even though he philosophizes about death so much in the book, I still do not think he is obsessed with it. When you have a terminal disease, cancer, heart problems etc., you see life from a totally different point of view. Your eyes open and you start thinking, you start living life differently because you know that you don't have much to live. Great people seize this opportunity and spend their final moments to the fullest, others that don't have enough will power just surrender and want to leave this world faster. This might be what Todd thought when answering the question 'is there any reason to die?'. Even though he gave the simplest of answers 'no', the answer itself is much more complex. _________________ If you find a typo you're allowed to keep it!  |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
ana.bilan Dunker

Data inscrierii: 11/Noi/2009 Mesaje: 21
|
Trimis: 11/06/2012 14:25 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
Tells the retrospective story of middle-aged lawyer Todd Andrews from his decision to commit suicide- life being plotless and pointless- to his equal absurdist decisionn not to, since “there is then no ‘reason’ for living (or suicide).
It is very interesting how the characters introduces himself at tha beginning of the book:
"Todd Andrews is my name. You can spell it with one or two d`s; I get letters addresed either way. I almost warned you against the single -d spelling, for fear you`d say, 'Tod is German for death: perhaps the name is symbolic'. I myself use two d`s, partly in order to avoid that symbolism. But you see, I ended by not warning at all, and that`s because it just ocurred to me that the dublu -d Todd is symbolic, too, and accurately so. Tod is death, and this book hasn`t much to do with death; Todd is almost Tod- that is, almost death- and this book, if it gets written, has much to do with almost-death."
I think that the strange title refers to a floating theatre which finally stops at the end of the book for a sort of show in Maryland town, where we can see all the characters. As we can notice, nothing spectacular is happening: an actor is reciting some excerpts from Shakespeare, but he is insulted by the audience and finally he leaves the stage. In his place came another actor who was prefered by the public and who started to imitate some sounds, made by nature and machineries.Todd, the protagonist of the book seems to like the first actor, but this thing didn't stop him to throw different things in him because "sometimes it feels good to punish a martyr even if you admire him".
But Todd, clearly specifies that what the book deals with is almost-death and not death.
there is no ultimate 'reason' for valuing anything" (223) and therefore "no final reason for living" (228)
The ending depends on the version you read. Barth was to become an endless reviser of his own texts
Perhaps Barth’s origins in absurdist existentialism, where the world seems only a parody itself. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Sergiu Mihis Dunker

Data inscrierii: 11/Noi/2009 Mesaje: 12
|
Trimis: 12/06/2012 19:26 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Todd is feeling guilty for the fact that his father committed suicide and in a way he wants to end up his misery by committing suicide. He changed his mind because in his mind he didn't want to die because he still thought that he still has something to prove to other people and to himself that he is not a looser and he can do much more better than that. He is a good attorney despite his personal problems. The way that John Todd is narrating the story is sometimes quite boring but the plot of the novel is quite interesting from my point of view. Todd didn't commit suicide and in this way he proved that he is not a coward we all know that there are some moments in our life when we are confused and disorientated and we need to have the strength to move on like Todd did. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Salageanu Adela Dunker

Data inscrierii: 13/Noi/2009 Mesaje: 23 Localitate: Satu Mare
|
Trimis: 13/06/2012 18:02 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
This book can be seen by some people as a depressing one, because it reflects one day from the life of the character, Todd Andrews, who is a man obsessed about death, and his name, Tod which in German means death. I consider that by committing suicide people make a big sin; because we received our life from God and we do not have the right to decide in His place what shall we do with our lives. I consider that Todd Andrews, although he wanted badly to commit suicide, in the end he realized that what he wanted to do was a bad decision. The fact that he was obsessed by death is not reason for suicide, thing that he realizes in the end.
John Barth was influenced by the French existentialism, thing that we can see in this book. As Alexandra Marchis mentioned, the book doesn’t give all the narrative, we have to imită the text. It is fragmentized, a feature of postmodernism, we only get pieces of the novel, thing that makes us think about what will happen after, or what does this or that want to signify. We can draw our own ideas about the things that happen in the book.
I think that irony, another feature of postmodernism, is also present in this book, when we regard the triangle. All in all, this book was an interesting one to read, but also a challenging one because we have to pay attention to the meaning of the words. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Adyna Plunger

Data inscrierii: 10/Dec/2009 Mesaje: 28
|
Trimis: 15/06/2012 22:11 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
When we find ourselves trembling in the balance (having a disease, like that of Todd), as Razvan said, we see life from a different point of view. And this depends on each individual. Todd, at first, considered it will be better for him to commit suicide and not to fight anymore with his healthy problems. Others get more ambitious, like Ben Tyler from “One week” (a great movie which I recommend for all of you) who was diagnosed with cancer. And he decided that he wants to spend his final days in a special way –by travelling.
But I think that Todd’s decision of ‘almost’ committing suicide was influenced by his child trauma (his mother dies and his father commits suicide) that turned into psychosis. This is an expressionist element used by Barth. There are also many other expressionist features that Barth used. Like my colleagues said, the interpretation that is giving from the beginning: it is about almost death-meaning that he won’t commit suicide in the end. He uses self-reflerentiality: he introduces himself in his writing and he speaks about the process of writing. The author is unprofessional and he admits his position, he also uses many digressions.
And I want to edit what Alexandra said: something about Todd's wife. She was in fact his best friend's wife with whom Todd had an affair. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
corjuc-romina Rookie

Data inscrierii: 13/Iun/2011 Mesaje: 8 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 17/06/2012 12:15 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
The Floating Opera consists of reconstruction in the manner of Joyce a major day of the narrator Todd Andrews, year 1937- 21 or 22 day when he realizes that there is no reason to live, and so the answer to all questions is death.
Description of that day 21 or 22 June 1937 is the pretext that triggers the story. Novel follows:
-arbitrary nature of existence
-absurd existence
-human experience
Nevertheless concludes that there is no reason to live or suicide. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
corjuc-romina Rookie

Data inscrierii: 13/Iun/2011 Mesaje: 8 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 17/06/2012 12:17 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| If Todd's father had not commited suicide, is it likely that Todd would have developed a more positive view of life? |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
anastasia Plunger

Data inscrierii: 17/Noi/2009 Mesaje: 27
|
Trimis: 20/06/2012 19:47 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
At the beginning I didn’t like this text, because is clumsy, there are absurd images, the main character - a loser, detailing his boring existence, a variety of diseases. But I decided to finish reading. It was hard to read. Plots didn’t have continuity. The story attempts a first-person narrative.
I think, first of all, it is a philosophical story, because it raises the theme about suicide, about human being. In the book there are lots of tiny moments, conversation that make you think and think. You have to go through the uninteresting details, bring together rough language and repetitive descriptions, and maybe you will find the mystery behind it.
Also, I think it is and a love story, a little banal and unusual, without jealousy, without possession. It is a true story, where everybody is honest.
It seems to be the same philosophical ideas, but a different emotional view with Rebreanu's Ciuleandra. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
|
|
Nu puteti crea un subiect nou in acest forum Nu puteti raspunde in subiectele acestui forum Nu puteti modifica mesajele proprii din acest forum Nu puteti sterge mesajele proprii din acest forum Nu puteti vota in chestionarele din acest forum
|
|