Pagina de start a forumului EngLit EngLit
Seminar extension for the students in English Literature at CUNBM
 
 FAQFAQ   CautareCautare   MembriMembri   GrupuriGrupuri   InregistrareInregistrare 
 ProfilProfil   Mesaje privateMesaje private   AutentificareAutentificare 

The Floating Opera by John Barth

 
Acest forum este inchis, nu se pot scrie, crea, raspunde sau modifica subiecte   Acest subiect este inchis, nu se pot crea sau raspunde la mesaje    Pagina de start a forumului EngLit -> ARCHIVE: 3.3 Postmodernism (Spring 2018)
Subiectul anterior :: Subiectul urmator  
Autor Mesaj
Butean Dana
Plunger
Plunger


Data inscrierii: 27/Oct/2015
Mesaje: 49
Localitate: Lapus

MesajTrimis: 29/03/2018 15:42    Titlul subiectului: The Floating Opera by John Barth Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1. Advantages of a non professional writer
2. Anticallophile (Patul lui Procust de Camil Petrescu)
3. Explain the metaphor in the book, the meaning of the floating opera
4. The writer is mixing different types of text, which are them?
5. Is a philosophical book, in which moments the writer speaks about this philosophical themes (the death)
6. Love can be serious or fun, what makes the difference?
7. In this book exist 3 moments: the past, the ocazie in which he writes the book and the day in which he wanted to commit suicide
8. What are the ideas and the theories of the writer?
9. Exist in the book irational thinking?
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Selena Acqui
Plunger
Plunger


Data inscrierii: 08/Noi/2016
Mesaje: 33

MesajTrimis: 02/06/2018 10:00    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1. Perhaps the major advantage of a nonprofessional writer is the presence of spontaneity. Todd Andrews is not a philology man with a vast knowledge about how one should write a novel, a book, a story or an article. Even when he reads, he has his own system of choosing his books. While reading, he realizes how some authors have a certain approach in their literary works and ask too much from their readers:

To carry the "meandering stream" conceit a bit further, if I may: it has always seemed to me, in the novels that I've read now and then, that those authors are asking a great deal of their readers who start their stories furiously, in the middle of things, rather than backing or sidling slowly into them. Such a plunge into someone else's life and world, like a plunge into the Choptank River in mid-March, has, it seems to me, little of plăcere in it. No, come along with me, reader, and don't fear for your weak heart; I've one myself, and know the value of inserting first a toe, then a foot, next a leg, very slowly your hips and stomach, and finally your whole self into my story, and taking a good long time to do it. This is, after all, a pleasure-dip I'm inviting you to, not a baptism.

He does not let the story flow by itself before introducing what he is about to do:

For example, I've got this book started now, and though we're probably a good way from the story yet, at least we're headed toward it, and I for one have learned to content myself with that. Perhaps when I've finished describing that particular day I mentioned before -- I believe it was about June 21, 1937 -- perhaps when I reach the bedtime of that day, if ever, I'll come back and destroy these pages of piano-tuning. Or perhaps not: I intend directly to introduce myself, caution you against certain possible interpretations of my name, explain the significance of this book's title, and do several other gracious things for you, like a host fussing over a guest, to make you as comfortable as possible and to dunk you gently into the meandering stream of my story -- useful activities better preserved than scrapped.

What lures the readers’ attention on him is the way he self-declares himself a nonprofessional writer. The Floating Opera is not even a novel, it is an Inquiry. Todd Andrews is not even a writer, he is an investigator of self.

As for me, I see already that storytelling isn't my cup of tea: every new sentence I set down is full of figures and implications that I'd love nothing better than to chase to their dens with you, but such chasing would involve new figures and new chases, so that I'm sure we'd never get the story started, much less ended, if I let my inclinations run unleashed.

The fact that Todd Andrews repeats that he is not a professional writer convinces his readers about this. This is also an advantage of the book (and an advantage in Postmodern Literature). The author writes the book in a way in which readers – part of any category of readers – may read the story and enjoy it. One can look for the profound meaning of things in it and try to make an inquiry of the novel, but on the other side, they can also just enjoy the story.

2. We can associate John Barth to this anti-dogmatic approach in art through the authenticity he provides with Todd Andrews’ description of what he has lived. The author cares about the essence of it, ignoring the idea of rendering the perfectly composed scheme of ideas. The Romanian author, Camil Petrescu, explains in a literary work how this narrative device actually works: the monkey throws away the kernel of the nut and swallows the shell. (Dicționar de termeni literari, p. 64, 1976). That is, the author interested in providing a beautifully written text will only făurite a superficial text, a dogmatic and academic literary work, that allows no way towards essence or originality. The author interested in recreating the cannon will choose the option of a groundbreaking approach in order to reach not only the essence of the text, but also the essence of the readers by offering through his or her literary work, a real and genuine experience.

3. The meaning of The Floating Opera is minutely explained by Todd in several instances in the novel. This is the first ocazie when he tries to explain to his reader why he chose the name of The Floating Opera:

Why The Floating Opera? I could explain until Judgment Day, and still not explain completely. I think that to understand any one thing entirely, no matter how minute, requires the understanding of every other thing in the world. That's why I throw up my hands sometimes at the simplest things; it's also why I don't mind spending a lifetime getting ready to begin my Inquiry. Well, The Floating Opera. That's part of the name of a showboat that used to travel around the Virginia and Maryland tidewater areas: Adonis Autentic & Unparalleled Floating Opera; Jacob R. Adam, owner and captain; admissions 20, 35, and 50 cents. The Floating Opera was tied up at Long Wharf on the day I changed my mind, in 1937, and some of this book happens aboard it. That's reason enough to use it as a title. But there's a better reason. It always seemed a fine idea to me to build a showboat with just one big flat open deck on it, and to keep a play going continuously. The boat wouldn't be moored, but would drift up and down the river on the tide, and the audience would sit along both banks. They could catch whatever part of the plot happened to unfold as the boat floated past, and then they'd have to wait until the tide ran back again to catch another snatch of it, if they still happened to be sitting there. To fill in the gaps they'd have to use their imaginations, or ask more attentive neighbors, or hear the word passed along from upriver or downriver. Most times they wouldn't understand what was going on at all, or they'd think they knew, when actually they didn't. Lots of times they'd be able to see the actors, but not hear them. I needn't explain that that's how much of life works: our friends float past; we become involved with them; they float on, and we must rely on hearsay or lose track of them completely; they float back again, and we either renew our friendship -- catch up to date -- or find that they and we don't comprehend each other any more. And that's how this book will work, I'm sure. It's a floating opera, friend, fraught with curiosities, melodrama, spectacle, instruction, and entertainment, but it floats willy-nilly on the tide of my vagrant prose: you'll catch sight of it, lose it, spy it again; and it may require the best efforts of your attention and imagination -- together with some patience, if you're an average fellow -- to keep track of the plot as it sails in and out of view.

Could The Floating Opera also be a metaphor sometimes for the writer himself? Todd Andrews might be The Floating Opera simply through the way he approaches life in connection with everything surrounding him. The boat wouldn't be moored, but would drift up and down the river on the tide, and the audience would sit along both banks. While moving towards a certain destination, Todd feels how people watch him, as if he were an actor. They could catch whatever part of the plot happened to unfold as the boat floated past, and then they'd have to wait until the tide ran back again to catch another snatch of it, if they still happened to be sitting there. Perhaps, Todd has a certain mood when he passes certain people. However, if these people who analyze his attitude remained in the same place they saw him first, later, when Todd walked again on the same route, they might see a different version of him, just because he would be in a different mood. To fill in the gaps they'd have to use their imaginations, or ask more attentive neighbors, or hear the word passed along from upriver or downriver. Most times they wouldn't understand what was going on at all, or they'd think they knew, when actually they didn't. Lots of times they'd be able to see the actors, but not hear them. Sometimes, people think they know things just because they produse a plot within their minds. Indeed, when one sees a person in a certain mood on the street, one might try to follow him or her and identify signs in order to conclude what really happened to that special person. I needn't explain that that's how much of life works: our friends float past; we become involved with them; they float on, and we must rely on hearsay or lose track of them completely; they float back again, and we either renew our friendship -- catch up to date -- or find that they and we don't comprehend each other any more. Friends also play an important role in our lives. Some stay, some leave. Because we all float on our waves of life and nothing ceases the moment, some friends might float back and some might float away. We, as individuals, can either float away from ourselves or float back. And that's how this book will work, I'm sure. It's a floating opera, friend, fraught with curiosities, melodrama, spectacle, instruction, and entertainment, but it floats willy-nilly on the tide of my vagrant prose: you'll catch sight of it, lose it, spy it again; and it may require the best efforts of your attention and imagination -- together with some patience, if you're an average fellow -- to keep track of the plot as it sails in and out of view. Todd Andrews declares this book to be a floating opera, but more than that, his own persona is a floating opera. Does Todd float or sink within his life? Just like Professor Oțoiu mentioned: Fluctuant nec mergitur.

4. John Barth comprises several types of texts:
-the narrative type of text;

To someone like myself, whose literary activities have been confined since 1920 mainly to legal briefs and Inquiry-writing, the hardest thing about the task at hand -- viz., the explanation of a day in 1937 when I changed my mind -- is getting into it.


-the descriptive type of text;

Betty June, at age seventeen, was a thin, almost scrawny little thing, most ungainly and sharp in the face, with good eyes, crooked teeth, coarse blonde hair, fine skin, and no hips or breasts to speak of. She was not considered unattractive in my set, though socially she was certainly of an inferior caste. Betty June was a poor student but a spirited girl, and there was a sharpness in her speech that bespoke a mind livelier than those of a number of more scholarly girls in our class.

-the advertising text (the leaflet advertising The Floating Opera);
-the argumentative type of text;

Why The Floating Opera? I could explain until Judgment Day, and still not explain completely. I think that to understand any one thing entirely, no matter how minute, requires the understanding of every other thing in the world.

-an expository type of text (explaining and analyzing everything he does; giving information about a particular thing)

5. Does Todd float or sink within his life? This question appears again because it concerns Barth’s theme of death in the novel: Should we keep floating while trying to find what makes us happy or should we sink when nothing seems to be right? Todd’s inquiry, after analyzing episodes, scenes and situations that happened throughout his life – his curiosities, melodrama, spectacle, instruction, and entertainment – helps him conclude that life is made out of fractional moments (positive or negative ones) that can manipulate very easily everything we are as human beings.

6. This oscillation might be Barth’s idea that nothing should be treated with an extremely high level of seriousness and that fun should be more present in one's life. This opposition between seriousness and fun comes from Todd’s two major love affairs: the one with Betty (seriousness) and the one with Jane (fun). The difference is, on the one hand, the way he approaches “love”, and on the other hand, the way women approach the situation. However, neither of the women are serious (the only reason I tend to classify Betty as serious is because she is forever hurt about how things ended between her and Todd). Neither of the women love Todd (Jane loves Todd “in a way”, but she is Harisson’s wife). Todd’s relationship with Betty was based, firstly, on them talking about Betty’s crush – Smitty – and because this person lived two houses from Todd, Betty would go very often to Todd’s place. After some time, Todd ends up feeling something for Betty and starts despising Smitty:

I came to loathe Smitty; to rail at him inwardly -- for Betty June allowed not a word of criticism; to lay elaborate plans for his ruin. I wept furiously whenever she spoke of her love for him...

Even if their “love” story ends up badly, and with fun (as far as he is concerned), his relationship with Jane starts with fun, but ends up in a very serious way. Their affair is just fun, until Jane ends up being pregnant, gives birth to a child and feels she has to be more responsible for her actions. Seriousness and fun – this is the mix of feelings that keeps floating in Todd.

7. Even if there are three major moments in the novel – that are not delimited accurately – they can be separated very easily. The first moment in the book, the past period before the day he wants to commit suicide, enchains a flow of events that composes, in the end, the adequate patches put together in order to help him conclude his inquiry. The second moment in the book is the day he decides to commit suicide, but through a series of “inconveniences” and a set of conclusions, he decides he should not do that. The third clipă in the book is everything that happens after this crucial day: the moment he gets to the conclusion of his self-inquiry.

8. The major idea of the book is whether one should or should not commit suicide. Todd’s inquiry collects a set of ideas that appeal to the negativity of life in general only to reach the end and realize that there is no reason to live but at the same time, there is no reason to die:
I. Nothing has intrinsic value.
II. The reasons for which people attribute value to things are always ultimately irrational.
III. There is, therefore, no ultimate “reason” for valuing anything.
IV. Living is action. There’s no final reason for action.
V. There’s no final reason for living (or for suicide).

One might believe that Barth’s idea could be linked to the philosophical problem Camus discusses in The Myth of Sisyphus, but John Barth explains simply:

There certainly may be similarities between them, but it didn't color my work because I haven't read The Myth of Sisyphus. I believe Camus says the first question that a thoughtful man has to ask himself is why he is going to go on, then make up his mind whether to blow his brains out or not; at the end of The Floating Opera my man decides he won't commit suicide because there's no more reason to stop living than to persist in it. ([url=http://iasir.net/AIJRHASSpapers/AIJRHASS15-884.pdf]article[/url])

9. There are instances and episodes where Todd is obsessed by irrational thinking. For instance, such an episode could be the one in the war when he kills the German soldier with whom he shared a moment of human anti-degeneration, only because he thought the German soldier would decide to kill him because he is older and seems to have more experience than him.

How could I be certain that our incredible sympathy did not actually exist only in my imagination, and that he was not all the while smiling to himself, taking me for a lunatic or a homosexual crank, biding his time, resting, smoking, sleeping -- until he was good and ready to kill me? Only a hardened professional could sleep so soundly and contentedly in a mudhole during a battle. There was even a trace of a smile on his lips. Was it not something of a sneer?

Indeed, his thoughts might be considered adequate for the situation he was in, but at the same time, manipulation and violence could have broken out a fear that he could no longer control.
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Ananie Sorina
Dunker
Dunker


Data inscrierii: 01/Noi/2015
Mesaje: 18

MesajTrimis: 04/06/2018 19:34    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

Bianca Kopoșciuc

There are some irrational facts in this book. For instance, Todd’s father’s “look” when he was found dead was very weird: “his hair was neatly combed” and “his clothes were perfectly creased and free of wrinkles”. It is very strange for a person who is in front of death to be so preoccupied of his look. It seems like he would plan the “perfection” of the moment. But what is stranger than that is the fact that he is not preoccupied at all about his son’s feelings, about what he will think of his father, but he cares so much about his hair and clothes. He did not even let him a letter to explain his decision. [/b]
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Todorean Iuliana
Plunger
Plunger


Data inscrierii: 24/Oct/2015
Mesaje: 38
Localitate: Targu Lapus

MesajTrimis: 06/06/2018 12:13    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1.Why in some situations a non-professional writer is better than a professional one? I think that a non-professional writer could be a little bit closer to the reader, he could understand the reader necessities, and also his writings could be read by a numerous group of people because it doesn’t require a specific knowledge.
Like Selena says, a non-professional writer could be spontaneous in writing, I don’t find him interested in the form of the novel, or in the meaning of it. He just write like in a diary almost everything it’s in his mind. He also addresses to the reader directly.
“So, reader, should you ever find yourself writing about the world, take care not to nibble at the many tempting symbols she sets squarely in your path, or you'll be baited into saying things you don't really mean, and offending the people you want most to entertain. Develop, if you can, the technique of the pall bearers and myself: smile, to be sure -- for fucking dogs are truly funny -- but walk on and say nothing, as though you hadn't noticed.”

2. Anticallophile. The author writes only about what things which could be easy to understand by the reader. He doesn’t give more details, doesn’t use descriptions which aren’t necessary, which could make the reader uncomfortable with.

3. Explain the metaphor in the book, the meaning of the floating opera.
The meaning of the floating opera is given by the narrator in many circumstances. He saw it like a boat where the protagonists mime the real world. The boat represents the community of people and the ocean represents their problems. If the problems are enormous the boat could sink.

4. The writer is mixing different types of text, which are them?
Lyrical, description, argumentation, advertisement.

5. Is a philosophical book, in which moments the writer speaks about this philosophical themes (the death)
The writer speaks about death when he feels insecure about him. He suffer a trauma when he was a child seeing his father hanged. Since that ocazie he understood that if you don’t realize something in life, you are nothing. He asked himself many times if he had a reason to live or not. He put in balance everything he has done, concluding that maybe there is a reason to live.

6. Love can be serious or fun, what makes the difference?
I think that love can be both serious and fun, depending on how much a person could give in a relation. A serious love can be turned in a fun one and vice versa. For example Todd was in love (serious) with Betty but his affection changed and his love becomes a fun one. In the opposite the fun relation with Jane turned into a serious one because of Todd’s feelings.

7. What are the ideas and the theories of the writer?
Like my colleagues have said: there is no reason for committing suicide or to live, nothing has intrinsic value, the reasons for which people attribute value to things are always ultimately irrational, there is no ultimate “reason” for valuing anything, living is action, there’s no final reason for action.

8. Exist in the book irational thinking?
Many times, when he is trying to kill everyone who attended the show or when he killed the soldier because he felt insecure with him.
_________________
Iulia
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Teacher
Administrator
Administrator


Data inscrierii: 26/Mar/2008
Mesaje: 471

MesajTrimis: 13/06/2018 12:45    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

BUTEAN - Correct transciption of the issues left open in class. Question 7 is badly transcribed, it is just a statement of the obvious, not really a question. Bad grammar in question 9 (check the lesson about "How to build the Interrogative of the Present Indicative"!
1/5

SELENA - Excellent set of answers.
A1: Great discussion of the set of aquatic metaphors for the writer’s craft. Yes, about spontaneity.
A2: Thanks for mentioning Camil Petrescu’s fitting metaphor, that I was not aware of.
A3: Both answers (floating opera = 1. the present book replicating one’s passage through life, and 2. the writer’s grasp of things) are convincingly argued and amply documented by you, Selena. Thanks for reading my Preface to the book.
A4: Right!
A5: ”life is made out of fractional moment” - yes, thus relativizing everything.
A6: Good, you went farther with your analysis than I had anticipated.
A7, A8, Thanks for making all these so clear.
A9. Yes, and thus Barth connects from his very first book(s) (he has a similar in his other debut novel "The End of the Road”) with the philosophical dilemma of his age: distrust in reason.
5/5

PETROVAN: Good points about the Author = an Amateur; his need of a system.
Sometimes, like when answering question 6, you are betrayed by your grammar...
2.7/5

BIANCA: Yes, that’s another irrational fact. 1/5

MARIANA: Very well articulated answer to Q1.
A4: Good connection of the genre mix and PoMo hybridization.
A8: Another good connection to "the fall of good ideas" as you call Lyotard’s demise of Grand Narratives. 3.3/5

TODORAN:
A2: Most readers would disagree on that. Actually you make a basic error when you think (as you also did in your exam paper) that all thea postmodernism does is to make things easier for the reader. As I said in the course, this is a promise, a bait, that lures the reader plunge into the book, even if eventually the book turns out to deal with very serious stuff. Take this case of this book: labelled by its quthor a mere "an amateur inquiry" about a (self-)murder (well, failed), it ends up becoming a philosophical exploration.
Most your ideas are just rephrasings of what Selena had said before...
2/5
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Afiseaza mesajele pentru a le previzualiza:   
Acest forum este inchis, nu se pot scrie, crea, raspunde sau modifica subiecte   Acest subiect este inchis, nu se pot crea sau raspunde la mesaje    Pagina de start a forumului EngLit -> ARCHIVE: 3.3 Postmodernism (Spring 2018) Ora este GMT + 2 ore
Pagina 1 din 1

 
Mergi direct la:  
Nu puteti crea un subiect nou in acest forum
Nu puteti raspunde in subiectele acestui forum
Nu puteti modifica mesajele proprii din acest forum
Nu puteti sterge mesajele proprii din acest forum
Nu puteti vota in chestionarele din acest forum


Powered by phpBB © 2001 phpBB Group
trevorj :: theme by ~// TreVoR \\~
Fa-ti si tu propriul forum GRATUIT, pe www.myforum.ro