 |
EngLit Seminar extension for the students in English Literature at CUNBM
|
| Subiectul anterior :: Subiectul urmator |
| Autor |
Mesaj |
Teacher Administrator

Data inscrierii: 26/Mar/2008 Mesaje: 471
|
Trimis: 01/02/2014 17:04 Titlul subiectului: Text 4: Mike, Alec, or Rufus |
|
|
MIKE, ALEC, OR RUFUS
by Dashiell Hammett
I don't know whether Frank Toplin was tall or short. All of him I ever got a look at was his round head—naked scalp and wrinkled face, both of them the colour and texture of Manila paper—propped up on white pillows in a big four-poster bed. The rest of him was buried under a thick pile of bedding.
Also in the room that first time were his wife, a roly-poly woman with lines in a plump white face like scratches in ivory; his daughter Phyllis, a smart popular-member-of-the-younger-set type; and the maid who had opened the door for me, a big-boned blond girl in apron and cap.
I had introduced myself as a representative of the North American Casualty Company's San Francisco office, which I was in a way. There was no immediate profit in admitting I was a Continental Detective Agency sleuth, just now in the casualty company's hire, so I held back that part.
"I want a list of the stuff you lost," I told Toplin, "but first—"
"Stuff?" Toplin's yellow sphere of a skull bobbed off the pillows, and he wailed to the ceiling, "A hundred thousand dollars if a nickel, and he calls it stuff!"
Mrs. Toplin pushed her husband's head down on the pillows again with a short-fingered fat hand.
"Now, Frank, don't get excited," she soothed him.
Phyllis Toplin's dark eyes twinkled, and she winked at me.
Manila paper = hârtie solidă si gălbuie de tipul celei utilizate pentru pungi; se încreţeşte uşor.
four-poster bed = pat cu patru stâlpi (baldachin)
bedding = aşternut (de pat)
roly-poly = durdulie
sleuth = copoi, detectiv
n the casualty company's hire = angajat în solda companiei de victime. (Hey, there's no such company!)
TASKS
4A. Is the narrator a protagonist of his own story? A witness?
4B. Can we assume that the narrator here knows less than his character? Why?
4C. This is the beginning of a detective story written by famous author of the hard-boiled detective genre Dashiell Hammett. Do you expect that the narrator's deficit of information be maintained througout this story? Does omniscience work well with the detective genre? Why?
4D. Is the narrator emotionally detached from the scene? Is he ironic? How do you know that? |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
AlexandraMi Dunker

Data inscrierii: 08/Oct/2013 Mesaje: 16
|
Trimis: 02/02/2014 19:05 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
4a Yes, the narrator is a protagonist of his own story, he is actually the detective who describes the other characters. We know the narrator is a character because he uses 1st person singular pronouns: 'I had introduced myself as a...'.
4b Yes, we can assume this because, being stuck in the body of a detective, the narrator tries to find out facts hidden by the other characters, who seem to know more:'Mrs. Toplin pushed her husband's head down on the pillows again with a short-fingered fat hand'.
4C. I believe that the narrator maintaines the deficit of information througout this story. The narrator as a character will certainly clarify some questions until the end but we cannot speak of omniscience in this kind of stories. Omniscience doesn't work well with the detective genre because in this case you expect mistery, troubles, liers, misleading information etc. If the omniscient narrator would tell us everythig, the book would not be interesting to read.
4D. I think the narrator is ironic. I realised that when he said 'There was no immediate profit in admitting I was a Continental Detective Agency sleuth, just now in the casualty company's hire, so I held back that part'. I think he knew he would become 'the voctim' of The Toplins too because this family is very good at manipulating people. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Teacher Administrator

Data inscrierii: 26/Mar/2008 Mesaje: 471
|
Trimis: 03/02/2014 12:10 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
Very well, Alexandra! You nailed those!
Excellent answers for all questions (ea,4c,4d). <aybe with the little exception of 4b, where, while your observation is correct, the example you gave would require a bit of more explanation.
So, I reckon you've read this book? Or you're a fan of the hard-boiled genre?
I'm awaiting comments form you and your colleagues on the other texts as well. Bon courage! |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
andrada dunca 1D Rookie

Data inscrierii: 06/Dec/2013 Mesaje: 2 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 04/02/2014 13:10 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
4A.The narrator is the protagonist of his story as he describes the situation from his point of view,and we can also figure it out as he uses nouns such as:"I", "me".
4B.I think that the narrator knows less than his character, becouse in the first part of his text when he tries to describe Frank Toplin, he says that he can not remember the way he looks.
4C.I think that the narrator doesn't reveal too much of the informations he had, becouse as long as this is the begining of a detective story, he let us to get involved in the story, and to make diferent assumption of the way the story goes.
4D.I think that the narrator is definitely detachet from the scene, and he's ironic, this thing beeing visible in the way that he asks for the list of the "stuff" that Toplin lost, and Toplin's reaction, hearing that ward, can confirm that. _________________ D.A. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Monica Hoz Dunker

Data inscrierii: 30/Oct/2013 Mesaje: 13
|
Trimis: 04/02/2014 13:24 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
4A. In my opinion the narrator is also a protagonist of the story because he gets involved with the characters; the narrator starts to describe the characters he met during his investigation.
4B. From the beginning of this part of text it can be seen that the narrator knows less than his characters, regarding their physical aspects, "I don't know whether Frank Toplin was tall or short." and regarding the sources of evidences he needs. Therefore, in order to gain more knowledge for his mission, he uses others help, "I want a list of the stuff you lost".
4C. I am confident that the narrator will maintain a deficit information throughout this story because we can say this is like a general "rule" of the detectives stories. Thus, the omniscience is not working in this kind of genre because its role is to keep in suspense and in constant tension the readers, so they will follow the plot story wholeheartedly.
4D. The narrator is not detached from the story because he depicts the characters in an ironic and amusing way, "naked scalp and wrinkled face, both of them the colour and texture of Manila paper", "a roly-poly woman with lines in a plump white face like scratches in ivory", and "Toplin's yellow sphere of a skull bobbed off the pillows". _________________ monihoz |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Dochita Bondea Dunker

Data inscrierii: 12/Oct/2013 Mesaje: 12 Localitate: Poienile de sub Munte
|
Trimis: 05/02/2014 13:27 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
4 A. Yes, the narrator is located in the story and also he is a protagonist of his own story, which means he relates as a witness the events and describes characters from his point of view during his investigation ("he is a Continental Detective Agency sleuth"). The pronouns "I", "myself" and the verbs used at first person "I got",""I had introduced", "I was", "I held" proves that the narrator is internal, inside among the event: "I had introduced myself as a representative of the..."
4 B. Yes, we can assume this because the narrator has a superior knowledge about the character's world, he is a character who is reflector, witness or an observer. He knows less about the characters: " I don't know whether Frank Toplin was tall or short. All of him I ever got a look a..." but, being detective, he tries to discover the true about "the stuff".
4 C. I think that the narrator's deficit of information will be maintained throughout this story because , being detective, the narrator tries to dissolve and to find an answer about the importance of that "stuff" , but he has inferior knowledge about character's world so he can not be omniscient, just a reflector or witness. Refering to omniscience, it does not work well with the detective genre because the detective's case, the mistery about the stuff is not solved, and he doesn't know exactly how the action occured. So, the mistery of detective's work makes the story more dynamic and interesting.
4 D. From my point of view, the narrator is emotionally detached from the scene and ironic. From the beginning, he describes ironic his character Frank Toplin: "I don't know whether Frank Toplin was tall or short. All of him I ever got a look at was his round head—naked scalp and wrinkled face, both of them the colour and texture of Manila paper...". About him and his job, he admits:"I had introduced myself as a representative of the North American Casualty Company's San Francisco office, which I was in a way", but when it comes to say about his qualities as a detective , he says:"There was no immediate profit in admitting I was a Continental Detective Agency sleuth, just now in the casualty company's hire, so I held back that part". |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
COSTIN GEORGIANA Rookie

Data inscrierii: 07/Dec/2013 Mesaje: 2 Localitate: Somcuta Mare
|
Trimis: 08/02/2014 17:45 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
4A.The narrator is the protagonist of his story as he describes the situation from his point of view,and we can also figure it out as he uses nouns such as:"I", "me".
4B.I think that the narrator knows less than his character, becouse in the first part of his text when he tries to describe Frank Toplin, he says that he can not remember the way he looks.
4C.I think that the narrator doesn't reveal too much of the informations he had, becouse as long as this is the begining of a detective story, he let us to get involved in the story, and to make diferent assumption of the way the story goes.
4D.I think that the narrator is definitely detachet from the scene, and he's ironic, this thing beeing visible in the way that he asks for the list of the "stuff" that Toplin lost, and Toplin's reaction, hearing that ward, can confirm that. _________________ Buna!Sunt Costin Georgiana de la LRE I. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Teacher Administrator

Data inscrierii: 26/Mar/2008 Mesaje: 471
|
Trimis: 10/02/2014 00:16 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
4A. ++, +, +, ++, +
Yes, a protagonist. All of you are right.
Extra points for Alexandra (ice-breaker...) and Monica Hoz (precisions).
4B. +, ++, ++, +, +
Yes, he knows less.
Andrada and Monica get the extra points for bringing up new stuff. Dochita and Georgiana just repeated the same (well, the disadvantage of the late-comer...).
4C. ++, +, ++, +, ~
I did not understand the Georgiana's answer.
Alexandra and Monica get extra points as they indicate that this deficit of info is a rule of the detective genre.
4D. ++, +, —, ++, +
Monica, I don't think anyone can be ironic without also being detached. irony is a form of detachment and distance (we speak of "ironic distance"). So, no points for you on that.
Best answers: Alexandra and Dochita. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
|
|
Nu puteti crea un subiect nou in acest forum Nu puteti raspunde in subiectele acestui forum Nu puteti modifica mesajele proprii din acest forum Nu puteti sterge mesajele proprii din acest forum Nu puteti vota in chestionarele din acest forum
|
|