Pagina de start a forumului EngLit EngLit
Seminar extension for the students in English Literature at CUNBM
 
 FAQFAQ   CautareCautare   MembriMembri   GrupuriGrupuri   InregistrareInregistrare 
 ProfilProfil   Mesaje privateMesaje private   AutentificareAutentificare 

Swift - Gulliver's Travels

 
Acest forum este inchis, nu se pot scrie, crea, raspunde sau modifica subiecte   Acest subiect este inchis, nu se pot crea sau raspunde la mesaje    Pagina de start a forumului EngLit -> ARCHIVE '12: LRE-1.1: Narratology
Subiectul anterior :: Subiectul urmator  
Autor Mesaj
Noemi Bartha
Plunger
Plunger


Data inscrierii: 18/Ian/2012
Mesaje: 33
Localitate: Baia Mare

MesajTrimis: 13/01/2013 18:37    Titlul subiectului: Swift - Gulliver's Travels Raspunde cu citat (quote)

My father had a small estate in Nottinghamshire; I was the third of five sons. He sent me to Emanuel College in Cambridge at fourteen years old, where I resided three years, and applied myself close to my studies: but the charge of maintaining me (although I had a very scanty allowance) being too great for a narrow fortune, I was bound apprentice to Mr. James Bates, an eminent surgeon in London, with whom I continued four years; and my father now and then sending me small sums of money, I laid them out in learning navigation, and other parts of the mathematics, useful to those who intend to travel, as I always believed it would be some time or other my fortune to do. When I left Mr. Bates, I went down to my father; where, by the assistance of him and my uncle John, and some other relations, I got forty pounds, and a promise of thirty pounds a year to maintain me at Leyden: there I studied physic two years and seven months, knowing it would be useful in long voyages.

Soon after my return from Leyden, I was recommended, by my good master Mr. Bates, to be surgeon to the Swallow, Captain Abraham Pannell commander; with whom I continued three years and a half, making a voyage or two into the Levant, and some other parts. When I came back, I resolved to settle in London, to which Mr. Bates, my master, encouraged me, and by him I was recommended to several patients. I took part of a small house in the Old Jury; and being advised to alter my condition, I married Mrs. Mary Burton, second daughter to Mr. Edmund Burton, hosier, in Newgate-street, with whom I received four hundred pounds for a portion. [...]

I was surgeon successively in two ships, and made several voyages, for six years, to the East and West Indies, by which I got some addition to my fortune. My hours of leisure I spent in reading the best authors, ancient and modern, being always provided with a good number of books; and when I was ashore, in observing the manners and dispositions of the people, well as learning their language, wherein I had a great facility by the strength of my memory.

The last of these voyages not proving very fortunate, I grew weary of the sea, and intended to stay at home with my wife and family. I removed from the Old jury to Fetter-Lane, and from thence to Wapping hoping to get business among the sailors; but it would not turn to account. After three years expectation that things would mend, I accepted an advantageous offer from Captain William Prichard, master of the Antelope, who was making a voyage to the South-Sea. We set sail from Bristol May 4, 1699, and our voyage at first was very prosperous.

It would not be proper, for some reasons, to trouble the reader with the particulars of our adventures in those seas: let it suffice to inform him, that in our passage from thence to the East Indies, we were driven by a violent storm to the northwest of Van Diemen's Land. By an observation, we found ourselves in the latitude of 30 degrees 2 minutes south. Twelve of our crew were dead by immoderate labor and ill food, the rest were in a very weak condition. On the fifth of November, which was the beginning of summer in those parts, the weather being very hazy, the seamen spied a rock, within half a cable's length of the ship; but the wind was so strong, that we were driven directly upon it, and immediately split. Six of the crew, of whom I was one, having let down the boat into the sea, made a shift to get clear of the ship, and the rock. We rowed by my computation about three leagues, till we were able to work no longer, being already spent with labor while we were in the ship. We therefore trusted ourselves to the mercy of the waves, and in about half an hour the boat was overset by a sudden flurry from the north. What became of my companions in the boat, as well as of those who escaped on the rock, or were left in the vessel, I cannot tell; but conclude they were all lost. For my own part, I swam as fortune directed me, and was pushed forward by wind and tide. I often let my legs drop, and could feel no bottom: but when I was almost gone, and able to struggle no longer, I found myself within my depth; and by this time the storm was much abated. The declivity was so small, that I walked near a mile before I got to the shore, which I conjectured was about eight o'clock in the evening. I then advanced forward near half a mile, but could not discover any sign of houses or inhabitants; at least I was in so weak a condition, that I did not observe them. I was extremely tired, and with that, and the heat of the weather, and about half a pint of brandy that I drank as I left the ship, I found myself much inclined to sleep. I lay down on the grass, which was very short and soft, where I slept sounder than ever I remember to have done in my life, and, as I reckoned, above nine hours; for when I awakened, it was just daylight. I attempted to rise, but was not able to stir for, as I happened to he on my back, I found my arms and legs were strongly fastened on each side to the ground; and my hair, which was long and thick, tied down in the same manner.

TASKS:
4.1. Mention the type of narrator in this excerpt. Give reasons for your choice.
4.2. Is this a homodiegetic or heterodiegetic narrative? Give arguments.
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
CarlaKorpos
Rookie
Rookie


Data inscrierii: 07/Noi/2012
Mesaje: 6

MesajTrimis: 15/01/2013 21:34    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

4.1I think the type of narrator is unreliable because is a character of the story : " I was the third of five sons." "I resided three years, and applied myself close to my studies" , it make the reader suspicious about the story credibility " ...was about eight o'clock in the evening. I then advanced forward near half a mile, but could not discover any sign of houses or inhabitants; at least I was in so weak a condition, that I did not observe them. I was extremely tired, and with that, and the heat of the weather, and about half a pint of brandy that I drank as I left the ship, I found myself much inclined to sleep. I lay down on the grass, which was very short and soft, where I slept sounder than ever I remember to have done in my life, and, as I reckoned, above nine hours" , it`s 1st person


4.2 It is a homodiegetic narrative because the narrator is a character in narrative world : "I was recommended, by my good master Mr. Bates, to be surgeon to the Swallow, Captain Abraham Pannell commander; with whom I continued three years and a half, making a voyage or two into the Levant, and some other parts. When I came back, I resolved to settle in London," , "For my own part, I swam as fortune directed me, and was pushed forward by wind and tide."
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Noemi Bartha
Plunger
Plunger


Data inscrierii: 18/Ian/2012
Mesaje: 33
Localitate: Baia Mare

MesajTrimis: 15/01/2013 21:41    Titlul subiectului: Carla Raspunde cu citat (quote)

Carla,

The fragment involving the reader is the one which should signal you a 'special' narrator. You stated that he is unreliable. Considering the fact that the narrator is referring to the reader in the novel ["It would not be proper, for some reasons, to trouble the reader with the particulars of our adventures in those seas"], would you change your mind regarding the type? Could he be aware of his status as a creator and his relationship with his readership? Why/not?
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Berci Mary
Rookie
Rookie


Data inscrierii: 04/Oct/2012
Mesaje: 7
Localitate: Baia Mare

MesajTrimis: 19/01/2013 18:57    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

4.1 I think the narrator is unreliable bause it's 1st person ''I was recommended, by my good master...'' ,the whole text is written at the 1st person,Gulliver is a character of the story,he tells the story of it's travels and he can make the readers doubtful about the story's credibility because we don't know it those adventures are invented or no.

4.2 It's homodiegetic because the writer is the same person as the character from the story''My father had a small estate in Nottinghamshire; I was the third of five sons. He sent me to Emanuel College in Cambridge at fourteen years old, where I resided three years, and applied myself close to my studies'' practically the entire fragment is based on this thing..
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
CarlaKorpos
Rookie
Rookie


Data inscrierii: 07/Noi/2012
Mesaje: 6

MesajTrimis: 20/01/2013 22:09    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

4.1 I think the narrator is self-concious because it`s 1st person gramatical perspective ''I was recommended, by my good master...'' , it adress to the readers "It would not be proper, for some reasons, to trouble the reader with the particulars of our adventures in those seas" , make references about personal regarding
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Grebles Lavinia Daniela
Dunker
Dunker


Data inscrierii: 11/Dec/2012
Mesaje: 10

MesajTrimis: 21/01/2013 11:22    Titlul subiectului: Grebles Lavinia Daniela Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1. I think the narrator is unreliable.
At first, the narrator is also a character in the story: ''I was the third of five sons.'', ''I went down to my father'', ''I studied physic two years and seven months".
Secondly, he makes us doubt of him, because he tells us: '' but could not discover any sign of houses or inhabitants; at least I was in so weak a condition, that I did not observe them. I was extremely tired, and with that, and the heat of the weather, and about half a pint of brandy that I drank as I left the ship, I found myself much inclined to sleep. I lay down on the grass, which was very short and soft, where I slept sounder than ever I remember to have done in my life, and, as I reckoned, above nine hours; for when I awakened, it was just daylight", so we can't trust him because he isn't sure about what he was seeing and he was drunk: ''I drank as I left the ship.'' We can't trust a drunker. Maybe he doesn't tell us the truth.
Also, I think the narrator is unreliable because appears in this story where we have the 1st person narrator such a protagonist/character.
Maybe the story is true, we don't have how to check this, but is he was drunk, we can't be sure that he was telling us the truth. He doesn't own pur trust because he said: ''I drank as I left the ship".



2. I think that is a homodiegetic narrative.
Firstly, we have the first person: ''I was recommended'', ''When I came back, I resolved to settle in London''. So, we can say that the narrator know as much as the character. He knows the same things, all the actions that the character is doing. Also, the narrator is a character in the story: ''I was surgeon successively in two ships'', ''I grew weary of the sea''.
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Noemi Bartha
Plunger
Plunger


Data inscrierii: 18/Ian/2012
Mesaje: 33
Localitate: Baia Mare

MesajTrimis: 24/01/2013 21:20    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

Berci Mary a scris:
4.1 I think the narrator is unreliable bause it's 1st person ''I was recommended, by my good master...'' ,the whole text is written at the 1st person,Gulliver is a character of the story,he tells the story of it's travels and he can make the readers doubtful about the story's credibility because we don't know it those adventures are invented or no.

4.2 It's homodiegetic because the writer is the same person as the character from the story''My father had a small estate in Nottinghamshire; I was the third of five sons. He sent me to Emanuel College in Cambridge at fourteen years old, where I resided three years, and applied myself close to my studies'' practically the entire fragment is based on this thing..


The fact that the narrator speaks in the 1st person sg (in the Pasive Voice) does not make the narrator unreliable. In the course you noted that reasons for unreliability could be: drinking, young age, or mental illness. Does this nattaor fit any of these categories? If yes, then you have the confirmation that the narrator is unreliable, if not, then the narrator is reliable (whihc I would tend to think, as this fragment reveals a short personal history of a surgeon who explains to readers how he ended up on a ship).

Yes, it a a homodiegetic narrative (as Genette says) because the narrator and character 'share' the same grammatica person (first singular). You should keep in mind that the writer (or real author) and the character might share some features, but only in a diary or autobiography. It could be the case of fiction, too, but it could be a docufictional narrative or a well-documented information which could clearly indicate a personal history behind the fictional story.
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Noemi Bartha
Plunger
Plunger


Data inscrierii: 18/Ian/2012
Mesaje: 33
Localitate: Baia Mare

MesajTrimis: 24/01/2013 21:25    Titlul subiectului: Re: Grebles Lavinia Daniela Raspunde cu citat (quote)

Grebles Lavinia Daniela a scris:
1. I think the narrator is unreliable.
At first, the narrator is also a character in the story: ''I was the third of five sons.'', ''I went down to my father'', ''I studied physic two years and seven months".
Secondly, he makes us doubt of him, because he tells us: '' but could not discover any sign of houses or inhabitants; at least I was in so weak a condition, that I did not observe them. I was extremely tired, and with that, and the heat of the weather, and about half a pint of brandy that I drank as I left the ship, I found myself much inclined to sleep. I lay down on the grass, which was very short and soft, where I slept sounder than ever I remember to have done in my life, and, as I reckoned, above nine hours; for when I awakened, it was just daylight", so we can't trust him because he isn't sure about what he was seeing and he was drunk: ''I drank as I left the ship.'' We can't trust a drunker. Maybe he doesn't tell us the truth.
Also, I think the narrator is unreliable because appears in this story where we have the 1st person narrator such a protagonist/character.
Maybe the story is true, we don't have how to check this, but is he was drunk, we can't be sure that he was telling us the truth. He doesn't own pur trust because he said: ''I drank as I left the ship".



2. I think that is a homodiegetic narrative.
Firstly, we have the first person: ''I was recommended'', ''When I came back, I resolved to settle in London''. So, we can say that the narrator know as much as the character. He knows the same things, all the actions that the character is doing. Also, the narrator is a character in the story: ''I was surgeon successively in two ships'', ''I grew weary of the sea''.


You could be right, however, try to make sure you do not make a drunkard of every narrator/character who mentions drinking. What could have signaled another type of narrator, is the fragment "It would not be proper, for some reasons, to trouble the reader with the particulars of our adventures in those seas" which clearly points to: suspending of the story narrative and the intrusion of the narrator who cuts short the story, further mentioning breifly onlywhat he considers relevant for the reader (which means he intrudes in the narrative and comments on it). So i would be tempted to say that this narratoe is rather intrusive and self-conscious than unreliable.
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Noemi Bartha
Plunger
Plunger


Data inscrierii: 18/Ian/2012
Mesaje: 33
Localitate: Baia Mare

MesajTrimis: 24/01/2013 21:55    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

CarlaKorpos a scris:
4.1 I think the narrator is self-concious because it`s 1st person gramatical perspective ''I was recommended, by my good master...'' , it adress to the readers "It would not be proper, for some reasons, to trouble the reader with the particulars of our adventures in those seas" , make references about personal regarding


The use of the Passive Voice in a narrative does not imply the narrator's unreliability. You started well by indicating that the narrators 'addresses the readers' - this should be your starting point. Which type of narrator addresses the reader by saying that the storyline shall be interrupted ans shortened, lest it should bore the reader?
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
CarlaKorpos
Rookie
Rookie


Data inscrierii: 07/Noi/2012
Mesaje: 6

MesajTrimis: 25/01/2013 22:35    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

Self-concious narrator- comments within the text on the story telling process, in-order to underline the difference between fiction and reality


-addressing to the reader
-a story about a someone reading or writing a book
-characters that are aware that they are taking part in a story
-commenting on the story while telling it, either in footnotes or within the text
-a story with a narrator that exposes himself as both a character and the narrator
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Afiseaza mesajele pentru a le previzualiza:   
Acest forum este inchis, nu se pot scrie, crea, raspunde sau modifica subiecte   Acest subiect este inchis, nu se pot crea sau raspunde la mesaje    Pagina de start a forumului EngLit -> ARCHIVE '12: LRE-1.1: Narratology Ora este GMT + 2 ore
Pagina 1 din 1

 
Mergi direct la:  
Nu puteti crea un subiect nou in acest forum
Nu puteti raspunde in subiectele acestui forum
Nu puteti modifica mesajele proprii din acest forum
Nu puteti sterge mesajele proprii din acest forum
Nu puteti vota in chestionarele din acest forum


Powered by phpBB © 2001 phpBB Group
trevorj :: theme by ~// TreVoR \\~
Fa-ti si tu propriul forum GRATUIT, pe www.myforum.ro