Pagina de start a forumului EngLit EngLit
Seminar extension for the students in English Literature at CUNBM
 
 FAQFAQ   CautareCautare   MembriMembri   GrupuriGrupuri   InregistrareInregistrare 
 ProfilProfil   Mesaje privateMesaje private   AutentificareAutentificare 

Sons and Lovers

 
Acest forum este inchis, nu se pot scrie, crea, raspunde sau modifica subiecte   Acest subiect este inchis, nu se pot crea sau raspunde la mesaje    Pagina de start a forumului EngLit -> 2.2 British Modernism (Spring 2019)
Subiectul anterior :: Subiectul urmator  
Autor Mesaj
luca.lorena17
Dunker
Dunker
luca.lorena17

Data inscrierii: 03/Apr/2018
Mesaje: 20

MesajTrimis: 17/06/2019 16:28    Titlul subiectului: Sons and Lovers Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1. Which is the main theme in this novel?
2. What do you think about the protagonist's relationship with his mother? Could this relationship influence his masculinity and / or his relationships with other people, especially women? Does he change after his mother's death?
3. Do you think “Sons and Lovers” is a novel based on human relationships? Why?
_________________
Luca Andreea Lorena, CUNBM, LRE III
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Cristina.Ilcas17
Dunker
Dunker


Data inscrierii: 16/Mar/2018
Mesaje: 18

MesajTrimis: 17/06/2019 19:26    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1. I think the main theme is connection. Why? Because William and (then) Paul are so connected to their Mother. Their bond can't be broken. This strong relationship between the mother and the son could be easily seen in Paul's behaviour. The world spins around his Mother.
Also, we can speak about Paul's connection with Miriam. They have a kind of love that is like a firework, you see it only when it explodes. They do love each other, but Paul's connection with his mother is too strong to intervene with the love that he has for Miriam; he is willing to give up on her anytime his mothers says "come home".

2. I believe Paul's relationship with his Mother is somehow justified. Father being away most of the day, or when being around he shouts at Mother, or he shouts at the kids (even be willing to fight them literally) Paul realized that his Mother has nothing but his love. Whom to put his love into if not his mother herself? I think he believed he needs to find a way to support his Mother both physically and mentally. Also he could confess anything to her, even when he wasn't so sure about his feelings. For example, when his heart is filled with love for Miriam he tells his mother even though he knew she didn't like her at all (because of course, this means that in Paul's heart is room for her, and that Mother was afraid that she would be replaced) or on the contrary, when he comes to the conclusion that has no feelings for her, or even hates her, he confines to Mrs. Morel (and when he does that she couldn't be more happier).

This relationship between Paul and his Mother influenced his masculinity in the sense that he didn't experienced love as he should have as his heart was filled with a maternal love.(" Pretty!" she said, in a curious tone, of a woman accepting a love-token." here I think the author exagerated and compared the Mother and the son with two lovers) For example when he and Miriam have made love, his love for her somehow consumes and thinks that nothing compares with the love he feels for Mrs. Morel. After his Mother falls ill and dies, Paul doesn't believe that he has any purpose to stay in his hometown. His perspective about life\love does not change, he sticks to his "principles".

3. Yes, I do believe that "Sons and Lovers" is based on human relationships. For example (other than Paul's relation to his Mother or to Miriam) Paul's relationship with the co-workers. At work he is nice to the girls, he makes funny jokes, he stays and speak with them, making the work environment more pleasant and he grows to like his job at Jordan’s.

Also we can consider Paul's relationship with Clara. He likes her because she represents everything Miriam is not. Clara is experienced, she has a position in the society, she can speak with him things that are not so deep, as Clara compared to Miriam, doesn't feel atracted by meanless things.

We can also take a look at Mrs and Mr Morel relationship. At first, their relation was based on love, they loved each other so much. After the kids appear they forget how to love each other first and then love the kids, so that they could create a HOME. Of course, it's hard to love a man that doesn't care much about the house or his children. He drinks so much and gives little money to his wife.
Mrs Morel states "I no longer love this man, and perhaps I should feel sorry about it, but actually, I do not feel something at all"
So that their familly life looked like this "He was shut out from all family affairs. No one told him anything. The children, alone with the mother, told her all about the day's happenings, everything But as soon as the father came in, everything stopped."
_________________
Ilcaș Cristina, LRE III
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
ani.mihaela2017
Dunker
Dunker
ani.mihaela2017

Data inscrierii: 26/Mar/2018
Mesaje: 16

MesajTrimis: 17/06/2019 21:39    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1. I think the main theme in this novel is Love. The excesive love of a mother for her children and vice versa and the love stories of them are the ones that generate the main conflicts in this novel. There are the stories of Morel boys that can’t find happiness in other women as they have to struggle with their mother’s gelosy and her stubbornness in sharing the love of her boys. But there is also the love stroy bettween the parents. Realizing that she can’t love her husband anymore, Mrs. Moret tries to keep her children forever near and persuade them from finding happiness in a stranger, all of this in order to find her own happiness, without realizing that slowly she destrois their lives.
2. Paul had a starnge relationship with his mother even before being born. When she found out about her pregnancy, Mrs. Morel felt sad but also guilty for the life she’s gonna offer to this infant, as he was the result of an unhappy marriage, so she would rather hate him for being another example of the mistake she made marrying Mr. Moret. But as he grew up, Paul become the only child that mother believed can change her life, she lived her dreams throught her boy, like she started a new a life without her husband.
Paul’s relation with his mother influenced him very much. Having this strong bound, like they had only each other in this world, and seeing how his parents’ relation become nothing, determined Paul to see love as something superficial, something that will bring his destroyment as happened in his mother’s case
Citat:
’’...you love me so much, you want to put me in your pocket.And there I will die smothered.’’
He didn’t believe in true love so this made him doubt about his relations with Miriam and Clara. In the relations with these two women he confused love with pleasure, he had an attraction for them, but couldn’t aproach with all his heart.
Citat:
’’ He always ran away from the battle with himself.Even in his own heart’s privacy, he excused himself, saying, If she hadn’t said so-and-so, it would never have happened.’’

He was instable emotionally. He wanna be loved but can’t offer love, he wanna feel admired and appreciated for his work but doesn’t care if the other ones are happy with him, and all this because this is how his mother taught him. A mother loves her child without conditions, she gives all attention to him and that made his to look in every women more for a mother than for a lover.
3.I think this novel is based on Freud’s theory, the Oedipus complex as this strong relation between Paul and his mother is somewhow anormal. Seeing her mother sad because of a drunk husband and the fear that maybe one day he may lose her because of Mr. Moret, determined Paul to hate his father. In this determination to change his mother’s life to make her happy he tried to take his father’s place, to be the support his mother never had, to treat her with love and made forget about all her problems, so that often we had the impression, like in the Oedipus legend, that this hopelesslly devotion and the love often borders on romantic desire. But there is the end of their strory. As Mrs. Morel became sick, Paul couldn’t recognize in his mother the woman he admired and loved so much, so he decided to end her life by administrating a big amount of morphime. The satisfaction he got when he founds that she finally died, remembered me about a moment in his childhood when destroying Annies’ doll, he decided to burn and bury it as if his mistake will be deleted. In my opinion, he somehow sees his mother like a defect doll that after you get rid of what it was once, you may start over again. So after his mother died he started to find love, but he was unable as he didn’t knew where to find it and most importantly, how to gain it.



Mihaela Ani, LRE II


Ultima modificare efectuata de catre ani.mihaela2017 la 18/06/2019 20:01, modificat de 1 data in total
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
PatakiRoxana17
Dunker
Dunker


Data inscrierii: 22/Mar/2018
Mesaje: 16

MesajTrimis: 18/06/2019 11:50    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1.I think that the main theme in this novel is family because Paul’s behaviour is always influenced by his family. Firstly, he is very affected by his father’s actions of disain for his family and also by his death. Moreover, it is hard for him to see how his family is degrading because, later on, his mother is leaving behind, too and Paul is living a hard moment in his life when he starts drinking and flirting with girls he don’t care about. The fact that he is so close to his mother shows another concerning about family. His entire life is regarded to his family life.


2. Paul’s relation with his mother is a little bit „toxic” for him. I don’t want to be missunderstood, he must love and respect his mum, of course, but he can’t relate to other woman in his life exepting Mrs. Morel. After William’s death, she needs Paul to be hers, being so possesive „She wants to absorb him. She wants to draw him out and absorb him till there is nothing left of him, even for himself." She doesn’t like Miriam, or any of Paul’s girlfriends because she want Paul to be only hers but she didn’t realise that she ruined his life.

Definitely yes, his mother is influencing the relationships with other people especially with women because when rejecting Miriam, Paul had a feeling of satisfaction, of sacrifice, thinking that he is devoted to his mother and that he showed her respect. The irony is that by doing this, his mother is withdrawing him from developing himself as an independent person fact that make it impossible for him to love another woman.

After his mother death, Paul suffer a tragedy following his father’s actions, he is living revelry, he goes deeper and deeper in this bad life, even thinking of commiting suicide in order to be with his mother again. He didn’t realise that it is his mother who brought him in this position. Hardly had he tried to live a good life after many, many days of gloom.


3. Yes, I think that „Sons and lovers” is a novel based on human relationships because we can only realizate feelings from the connection with other people. We can see the relationship between Paul and his mother, between Paul and Miriam or even the relationship between Mrs. Morel and Walter. They are all realistic relationships with strong feelings and implication. Lawrence tried to captivate the reader through this reastic connections between persons who we can retrive ourselves.
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
luca.lorena17
Dunker
Dunker
luca.lorena17

Data inscrierii: 03/Apr/2018
Mesaje: 20

MesajTrimis: 18/06/2019 15:10    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1. & 2. & 3. The novel is the story of the Morel family: Gertrude, a wealthy girl, falls in love with a miner, then marries him, and at first her life seems to be fulfilled. As her marriage turns out to be a hell for her, because the scandals caused by an alcoholic and irresponsible husband are becoming more and more frequent, Mrs Morel focuses her attention on her children by giving them all her affection. Gradually her children become the source of happiness and her refuge from the miserable marriage she has.

I think the main theme is LOVE. The theme is outlined in the first pages of the book by the relationship and marriage between the Gertrude and Walter, and then is accentuated by the strong love felt by the mother for her children, but also by the love they feel for her. Maternal love becomes suffocating during the novel, because when the boys reach maturity, they remain subjugated and cannot love another woman more than their mother. William engages, but Gertrude Morel does not accept the girl (the superficial Louisa Western) and the young man is put in a situation that destroys him: the body belongs to his fiancée, but the soul belongs to his mother. Once he has lost his identity and love, William dies. The situation is somehow different with Paul. Miriam (“was romantic in her soul”), the girl he falls in love with for the first time, fights for his soul, stirring up his mother's jealousy. She is sure that Paul will return to her and that they will continue their love story: “He would come back to her, she was sure; with some of his young freshness gone, perhaps, but cured of his desire for the lesser things.”. As for Clara, the young lover's second love, she gives him passion, but she doesn't manage to possess him entirely, as he would have wanted. Paul finds no fulfilment in his relationships and often doesn’t know what he wants or feels.

So, the closest person to the mother and the most "affected" is Paul Morel, the middle-aged son, who fails to have his own life, because is always controlled by his mother. Loved first by Miriam, then by Clara, both constantly driven by the desire to have him and crushed by the misery of not really possessing him: “That's how women are with me " said Paul. "They want me like mad but they don't want to belong to me.”. Paul can't overcome the love he feels for his mother, this being the most powerful love he has ever felt in his life.

I tend to think that the main theme can also be HUMAN RELATIONSHIPS AND CONNECTIONS. Lawrence pursues in detail all the relationships in the novel: Gertrude – Walter (an abusive relationship and marriage), Gertrude - William / Paul (a relationship that slowly destroys the boys' love life), William's relationship with Cristina which exhausts him so badly that he falls ill and dies, Paul's attempts to have a relationship with Miriam and Clara.

But the most important relationship, the one around which the book revolves, is that of William and Paul with Gertrude, a pure but destructive relationship and love that distances the two sons from all the women who are trying to approach them. Throughout the novel it is repeatedly pointed out that Paul and his mother behaved like two lovers and moreover she is jealous of Miriam considering she will lose Paul's attention if Miriam exists in his life: “Miriam's not like an ordinary woman, who can leave me my share in Paul. She wants to absorb him. She wants to draw him out and absorb him till there is nothing left of him, even for himself.”.
_________________
Luca Andreea Lorena, CUNBM, LRE III
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Alexandra Noje 17
Plunger
Plunger
Alexandra Noje 17

Data inscrierii: 14/Mar/2018
Mesaje: 27
Localitate: Satu Mare

MesajTrimis: 18/06/2019 17:09    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1&2&3. My opinion is that in this novel the main themes are psychology and sexuality. This nearly incestuous relationship between the mother and her son is affecting his personality and his other relations with other women (like Miriam and Clara) when he becomes an adult. Also, at that time, sexuality was a very delicate subject, but the author had the courage to approach it. I think that this story also highlights the Oedipus Complex in order to deepen these themes of the novel.

Paul and his mom are toxically bounded, he being the one who becomes emotionally crippled during the story. Every human relationship from this story is important, but the one that is really important is between Paul and Gertrude Morel. I think that the fact that the marriage of Gertrude and Walter Morel becomed a dysfunctional one after the children were born ("He was shut out from all family affairs. No one told him anything. [...] As soon as the father came in, everything stopped."), leaded to her being so overprotective with their children, and by doing this, she influenced a lot both William and Paul’s destinies.

In the end, Paul learned that he is incapable of having intense feelings in order to sustain a relationship with another woman, except his mom. Even after her death, Paul felt that no other human being could ever fill in the gap left by his mother in his heart.
_________________
Alexandra Noje, LRE III, CUNBM
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat Trimite un mesaj
ioanaosan2017
Dunker
Dunker


Data inscrierii: 22/Mar/2018
Mesaje: 15
Localitate: Mocira

MesajTrimis: 18/06/2019 17:49    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1.The contradictions between the characters could be one of the themes noted in the novel. Each character gets to be with someone opposite his own personality. Mrs. Morel is refined, beautiful and elegant, and Mr. Morel is just an arrogant miner who likes to drink a lot. I think the biggest opposition is between love and hatred. Appears about every character: Although Mr. Morel is not a good man, he drinks a lot, is always arrogant and problematic, he still finds a bit of love or tolerance for him. Perhaps that's what her attracts, its opposite character. Love and hatred also occurs in William and Paul. William loved Louisa until he arrived at home, when he came to him, he began to despise her. Paul walks between love and hatred for all the women in his life, including his mother. Miriam loves her and hates her in the same time (she hates her because she behaves badly with her mother and sometimes she is mischievous). Passionate love appears by nature. Paul and Clara in the midst of nature and night expose their deepest and passionate thoughts and feelings. Paul feels a stronger attraction for Clara than for Miriam. The strong bond with Clara is formed in the middle of nature, with flowers, which are also symbols that induce passion and form bonds.


2.In the first part of the novel, the protagonist is William, this guy is the mother's favorite son, because in the second part of the novel Paul, the middle-aged son takes his place. William is the mother's favorite son because he was well-off, a job, helping her mother with the money, and even if he did not listen to her advice, she still liked to see what he would do next. They always talk about anything and have no secrets to each other He is very close to his mother, and even if he went to London he constantly sent his mother's letter. I do not know if his relationship with his mother has somehow plummeted his masculinity, but somehow he fell in love with a young man he really wanted she marries when she gets home to William, because she has a diva constantly and gives orders to her sister. William's mother does not agree with her behavior. And here William also moves away from her. In the second part novel by Paul de comes the protagonist.William dies because of a disease, his mother is devastated by pain, and somehow Paul makes him pass this difficult moment.Never Paul is no less than William, he has a job even if he earns less like the brother But, as far as Paul's masculinity is concerned, I'm sure his mother influenced him, but in an indirect way. His first love was Miriam. He loved Paul a lot, but every time he was close to him or of his mother became mischievous and arrogant. Paul somehow dispelled this, because to him the most important thing was that his mother was happy. Miriam became so because he did not like that he was very close to his mother and he had no more a lot of men take their own decisions. He was always smoother and his mother had to take care of him, and maybe that opened up his affection. He did not have too much desire, he wanted to marry a pretty girl, have children, have a decent job and stay close to his mother. After his mother's death Paul is lost, he does not know what to choose or what to do with his life. He prefers to go to work constantly to defeat the souls left behind by his mother. Even if Miriam tries to take it, he refuses, she realizes that she still belongs to her mother. Probably, the attachment to his mother was too big and he did not miss any suggestions except his mother's. And that love for it has remained unchanged. Probably because his father did not take care of him, but she only took care of him.


3.I believe that in this novel several types of relationships are exposed: family, friendship, love. Relationships in this novel are as if you grow in life. In the first part of your life you have a family relationship where you learn what's good and what's wrong. As in this novel their family relationship is a common one, with quarreling and reconciliation, quarrels and beats should not be part of family life, but in everyday life it happens. I think this brings a reality to the novel. The children were scared by their father and despised him just like his mother. From this family relationship we grow to a friendly relationship, Morel's children come to have all sorts of friends, William to London, Paul to Willy Ferma, then Annie and Arthur. From the friendship relationship, the protagonists head to the relationship of love. William falls in love with Louisa Lily Denys Western, with whom she wants to marry her, but her family is not too excited about her presence, and William moves away from her. Paul, like William, falls in love with Miriam and Clara, but he does not have one because he is too close to his mother. But all these relationships that life offers us are like a circle. When you fall in love with someone, you grow your own life (with good and with bad) having the same relationships: family, friendship and love. Then the descendants will do the same. But perhaps the family relationship is the most important, because you form an identity that you will develop in other relationships. The Morel family did not have a pleasant livelihood. As I said before, there were quarrels and fear in children. Although there were these arguments Mrs. and Mr Morel still did not split up, if they did not love each other, they probably had something to link their relationship, namely children. The children were probably the only link for which their family relationship continued.
_________________
Osan Ioana Paula, CUNBM Litere LRE III
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat Trimite un mesaj
Emanuela Negru
Dunker
Dunker
Emanuela Negru

Data inscrierii: 26/Mar/2018
Mesaje: 18

MesajTrimis: 18/06/2019 20:49    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1.The main theme in this novel is contradictions between feelings. We see Paul who is bound between hate and love. He hate his father but he loves his mother. Also, sometimes he loves Miriam, but in the other day he hates her.
Citat:
And a touch of hate for her crept back again into his heart… And immediately he hated Miriam bitterly.

He didn’t understand his heart. He loves his mother not in the way he should love her, sometimes he sees her like his lover. Also, Mrs. Morel loves and hates her husband.
2&3.I think Paul is followed by his mother love all his life. He can’t love a woman because he wanted to see her mother in every women. And here appears Freudian theory about boys who are attached to their mothers and girls to their fathers. Everything started when she found out the fact that her husband didn’t pay the furniture bills. He lied to her and started coming home drunk. After this Mrs. Morel flood her love upon her children. They started to feel insecure when her father came home and to fear about their mother’s security. After Paul grew up he imagine his life not being married with his children, but living with his mother in his house, after his father’s death
Citat:
And then, when his father died, have a cottage with his mother, paint and go out as he liked, and live happy ever after.

His relationship with Miriam, the innocent girl was disapprove by his mother. In a way or another she felt like her son is not hers, and Miriam had a big influence upon his life. Their “spiritual relationship” was a threat for his mother, she thought she’ll lose her son. The paradox here is the fact that his mother approve his relationship with Clara, even if she had a husband. We see Paul asking for mother’s approval in his relationships and in his job. Also, there are several moments when he is walking with his mother and they talk as if they are two lovers.
Citat:
He loved to go with her across the fields to the village and the sea. She was afraid of the plank bridge, and he abused her for being a baby. On the whole he stuck to her as if he were HER man.

And sometimes returning home from Miriam, his mother didn’t fall asleep, she was waiting for him. So, in a night she told him that she never has a husband and he kissed her on he head
Citat:
And I’ve never—you know, Paul—I’ve never had a husband—not really—-‘ He stroked his mother’s hair, and his mouth was on her throat. ‘And she exults so in taking you from me—she’s not like ordinary girls.’ ‘Well, I don’t love her, mother,’ he murmured, bowing his head and hiding his eyes on her shoulder in misery. His mother kissed him a long, fervent kiss. ‘My boy!’ she said, in a voice trembling with passionate love.

After his mother death, Paul is destroyed and can’t live anymore. He broke up from Clara, searched his mother on the streets, feeling alone and missing her very much. His life has no meaning after his mother death. Yes, this book is based on human relationship. We see Paul, William, Miriam and Clara with their personality that influenced their destiny. Paul's relation with his mother,and with the women from his life.
Emanuela închis la culoare LREII
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
ceuca.dorinela17
Dunker
Dunker


Data inscrierii: 28/Mar/2018
Mesaje: 16

MesajTrimis: 18/06/2019 22:36    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1. The main theme in this novel could be one based on jealousy because the jealousy predominates in this novel and causes many effects. First of all there is the jealousy and disagreements between Mr. and Mrs. Morel and then appear the jealousy of sons’ lovers. There are many misunderstandings between Mr. and Mrs. Morel because he was a drunkard and he caused a lot of problem, he was a miner and their marriage was unhappy. She suffered very much because of him and in one episode she was locked outside and then hit in the head with a drawer. Many bad and unhappy things happened in their life and negative effects occurred. There was no affected, spiritual life for Mrs. Morel without her children. I think this is one reason why Mrs. Morel became such a jealous person and she turned her attention to her son, Paul who seems to be her favorite (initially William was her favorite until he took a job in London and he was capable to confront his mother except Paul), Paul became everything for her and she was capable of anything for him. ‘’When she fretted he understood and could have no peace, his soul seemed always attentive to her’’.


2. The relation between Paul and his mother, from my point of view is a sick one because she was obsessed with his life and also with his lovers. Their relationship becomes more unhealthy and provokes unhappiness and also their relationship is too close and too suffocating to be called as a natural one. ‘’ Paul always rather delicate and quiet, got slimmer and trotted after his mother like her shadow’’. Paul tells his mother everything, he is sensitive, temperamental and his mother influence him a lot but not in a normal way and he is ‘’command’’ by his mother in some ways. When Paul was in a relation with Miriam his mother does not agree with her because of her intelligence and she wanted to take him away from her ( She could feel Paul being drawn away by this girl and she did not care for Miriam, she wants to draw him out and absorb him till there is nothing left of him, even for himself’’). Miriam is the first Paul’s love and she loves him very much but he does not want to marry her because he sees her as a sacrificial, spiritual soul she is too virginal to claim him, frigidity. When it comes about Clara, Mrs. Morel changes her opinion and things are more clearly and it is more comfortable with this. Clara is older and she has a husband and she attracted Paul with her sensuality. When his mother get ill he carry for her and he was broken after her death.

CEUCA DORINELA LRE II
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Marius Mesaros
Dunker
Dunker


Data inscrierii: 16/Mar/2018
Mesaje: 19

MesajTrimis: 19/06/2019 06:51    Titlul subiectului: Ionut Chereji`s answer to Sons and Lovers Raspunde cu citat (quote)

Ionut Chereji`s answer to Sons and Lovers

1. I know the relationship between mothers and sons has a unic nature, without being very initiated in psychology, here is about the concept of "Oedipus complex," but with all that I think the book can really be "felt" by men in particular.
Oedipus complex is that intense, sometimes even excessive, phase of the 3-6 year olds' feelings towards the opposite sex, is the need to establish a privileged and union relationship with the opposite sex partner, which can even translate into a rivalry towards the father in the case of boys, the relationship between Mrs Morel and her sons perfectly describes this complex. Everything is linked, from childhood , but you can not figure it out what happends next.

2. When boys reach maturity, they remain subjugated and can not love another woman. William engages, but Gertrude Morel does not accept the girl and the young man is put in a situation that destroys him: the body belongs to the fiancée, but the soul is of his mother. William gets sick and dies. The situation is somehow different with Paul. As for Clara, much older than him, she gives him passion and love, but she does not manage to have it all, as he would wanted. Paul often does not know what he wants or feels. He loves both Miriam and Clara, but also he hate them ... a hate that he feels sometimes for her mother too, of course, he does not compare to the hate he feels for his father, he wants to beat him, even his death.
Paul fulfills his mother's frustrated aspirations through education and art, but the almost incestuous relationship between mother and son risks his adult development and his sexual relations with other women. He remains the same after his mother`s death, focused on his "strong" principles.
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Sabadis Andreea
Dunker
Dunker


Data inscrierii: 25/Mar/2018
Mesaje: 17

MesajTrimis: 21/06/2019 16:34    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1.The main theme in this novel is love. I think that around the love the action took place. Firstly, in the relation between parents, the love is missing. If they didn’t respect each other, didn’t understand each other there is no love. I think that they get married not because they loved each other but because they was attracted one of other. When that attraction disppeared the parents began to hate each other.
Secondly, there is love between mother and her children. If the mother couldn’t love her husband, she transmited all her fellings to her childrn, especialy to William and then Paul.
2. Initially, I apreciated Paul for his respect for her mother. He helps her, understands her, loved her. But mother wanted that Paul to be only her, to stay always near her. And this is imposible. It is normally that a mother loves her child but when he become mature, he must be allowed to think alone, to act alone, to live his life.His mother tried to live though Paul’s life. Mother infuence his masculinity because Paul didn’t experience anything alone. He know what live means only though mother’s perspective. When Paul know Miriam, his mother fells how Miriam steals Paul from her.
3.Yes, ‚Sons and Lovers’ is a novel based on human relationships, because is about the relation between parents,parents and children,Paul and Miriam, Paul and Clara. There are many characters in relation with others. The novel contains characters of every social position.The author describe how live families of miners, how are build their houses. He describes the society from the beginning of the twenty-first century.
SABADIS ANDREEA LRE II
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Afiseaza mesajele pentru a le previzualiza:   
Acest forum este inchis, nu se pot scrie, crea, raspunde sau modifica subiecte   Acest subiect este inchis, nu se pot crea sau raspunde la mesaje    Pagina de start a forumului EngLit -> 2.2 British Modernism (Spring 2019) Ora este GMT + 2 ore
Pagina 1 din 1

 
Mergi direct la:  
Nu puteti crea un subiect nou in acest forum
Nu puteti raspunde in subiectele acestui forum
Nu puteti modifica mesajele proprii din acest forum
Nu puteti sterge mesajele proprii din acest forum
Nu puteti vota in chestionarele din acest forum


Powered by phpBB © 2001 phpBB Group
trevorj :: theme by ~// TreVoR \\~
Fa-ti si tu propriul forum GRATUIT, pe www.myforum.ro