| Subiectul anterior :: Subiectul urmator |
| Autor |
Mesaj |
Teacher Administrator

Data inscrierii: 26/Mar/2008 Mesaje: 471
|
Trimis: 23/03/2020 14:24 Titlul subiectului: Robinson Crusoe #3: Isolation |
|
|
Theme 3: ISOLATION + LONELINESS
3A. How does Robinson cope with isolation on the island? Find sections that indicate his mental or psychological condition in relation to isolation and loneliness.
3B. Do you think Defoe described well all the problems that arise from isolation and loneliness? You may have been one week in self-isolation, so you can have a (very weak) idea of what isolation implies. Do you think there are aspects that Defoe neglected?
3C. What do we learn about Robinson’s sexuality? Is he longing for an erotic partner? Explain.
3D. When he imagines a human presence on the island, what kind of relation does Robinson think of?
3E. And then, when he has a fist sign of another human presence/visit on the island, what is his reaction? How does he fotografie those visitors to be? How does he act?
*cope with = a face față |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Teacher Administrator

Data inscrierii: 26/Mar/2008 Mesaje: 471
|
Trimis: 23/03/2020 16:04 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| 3F. Do Robinson’s buildings on the island seem more ready to receive a friend? Or a foe? |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
ArdeleanIGabriel Diver


Data inscrierii: 16/Mar/2020 Mesaje: 54
|
Trimis: 23/03/2020 16:57 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
3A. How does Robinson cope with isolation on the island? Find sections that indicate his mental or psychological condition in relation to isolation and loneliness.
RC's coping mechanism consists of keeping a journal of his experience on the island, keeping count of the days, speaking aloud to himself and even teaching a parrot (who he named Paul) to speak.
Later into the novel he also turned to religion to soothe his loneliness, reading the bible he salvaged from his ship. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Evelin19 Diver


Data inscrierii: 13/Mar/2020 Mesaje: 52
|
Trimis: 23/03/2020 17:02 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
3A sometimes when he thinks about his condition, he just sits down and cries.But he braves himself and never lets negative thoughts take the better of him. In this respect he is strong-willed
Ultima modificare efectuata de catre Evelin19 la 23/03/2020 17:03, modificat de 1 data in total |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Larisa19 Dunker

Data inscrierii: 16/Mar/2020 Mesaje: 14
|
Trimis: 23/03/2020 17:02 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| 3A. Sometimes he was struck by loneliness and the thought that he will perish alone on that ''cursed island'', in instance when he begged God to send him a human-being with whom he could talk. Other times he seemed to have resigned, telling himself that he has everything he needs to live how many days he has on the island. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Ulicianda19 Rookie

Data inscrierii: 06/Mar/2020 Mesaje: 3
|
Trimis: 23/03/2020 17:04 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
3A Crusoe felt captive, like in a prison. He wishes for some companionship. He even trains a parrot to speak to him. Crusoe had good and bad thoughts in his mind.
Evil: I am cast upon a horrible, desolate island, void of all hope of recovery.
Good: But I am alive; and not drowned, as all my ship’s company was.
In this situation it is important to be satisfied with what you have. You live you are not dead, you have more than the others. You are isolated, but at least you live. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Larisa19 Dunker

Data inscrierii: 16/Mar/2020 Mesaje: 14
|
Trimis: 23/03/2020 17:05 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| He was trying to ocupe his time in order to move away from black thoughts. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
ArdeleanIGabriel Diver


Data inscrierii: 16/Mar/2020 Mesaje: 54
|
Trimis: 23/03/2020 17:06 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
3B. Do you think Defoe described well all the problems that arise from isolation and loneliness? You may have been one week in self-isolation, so you can have a (very weak) idea of what isolation implies. Do you think there are aspects that Defoe neglected?
I would say Defoe described the problems and frustrations caused by isolation in a realistic manner, as Robinson becomes self aware and tries to keep his mind busy with the coping mechanisms formerly mentioned. However, naturally, he still cannot cope with his condition entirely and he breaks down crying at seemingly random times due to the stress buildup.
But one thing I expected Crusoe to ponder over more is the wealth and acquaintances he had left behind, who would presume him dead (although he did think about his parents, and reflected upon his father's advice -too late-). |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
malina19 Rookie

Data inscrierii: 13/Mar/2020 Mesaje: 4 Localitate: Satu Mare
|
Trimis: 23/03/2020 17:09 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Robinson's new devotion to Christianity helps him to become content and happy with his life on the island.Having repented and become deeply Christian,Robinson now looks back on his former life with regret,seeing it as wicked and sinful. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Evelin19 Diver


Data inscrierii: 13/Mar/2020 Mesaje: 52
|
Trimis: 23/03/2020 17:10 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| 3A Defoe underlined the effects of loneliness quite well, but I wonder if some people, unlike Robinson, wouldn't go mad after spending so many ears alone on an island. Tbh, i was quite surprised to see how fast Robinson re-adapted to civilization once back in England |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
ArdeleanIGabriel Diver


Data inscrierii: 16/Mar/2020 Mesaje: 54
|
Trimis: 23/03/2020 17:11 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
3C. What do we learn about Robinson’s sexuality? Is he longing for an erotic partner? Explain.
Uhh i don't remember Robinson expressing his sexuality or a desire for an erotic partner, but rather a platonic companion.
I'd like someone to expand on this if they remember lines regarding sexuality. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Evelin19 Diver


Data inscrierii: 13/Mar/2020 Mesaje: 52
|
Trimis: 23/03/2020 17:12 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| 3C Defoe doesn't give any hint Robinson would lack a romantic partner. Maybe he overlooked this aspect because the book's main focus was on survival and adventure and not such desires as sexuality. Plus at that time sexuality was a very controversial thing, you couldn't talk about this in a book, or rather anywhere as it was considered immoral |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
ArdeleanIGabriel Diver


Data inscrierii: 16/Mar/2020 Mesaje: 54
|
Trimis: 23/03/2020 17:13 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Evelin19 a scris: | | 3A Defoe underlined the effects of loneliness quite well, but I wonder if some people, unlike Robinson, wouldn't go mad after spending so many ears alone on an island. Tbh, i was quite surprised to see how fast Robinson re-adapted to civilization once back in England |
That's true, but he did become anxious when it came to managing his large wealth again (and especially with trusting people to watch over his propriety). |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
siminanicorici19 Rookie

Data inscrierii: 15/Mar/2020 Mesaje: 2
|
Trimis: 23/03/2020 17:14 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
3A. ''I learned to look more upon the bright side of my condition, and less upon the dark side, and to consider what I enjoyed, rather than what I wanted : and this gave me sometimes such secret comforts, that I cannot express them ; and which I take notice of here, to put those discontented people in mind of it, who cannot enjoy comfortably what God has given them, because they see and covet something that he has not given them. All our discontents about what we want appeared to me to spring from the want of thankfulness for what we have.''
As we can see besides being an adventurous and a brave man, RC was emotionally stable, an adjusted person. Actually, I consider that Daniel Defoe's book has at its center the tension between society and isolation. By setting out to sea, Robinson prioritizes his sense of individuality over his family and society at large. Robinson gets exactly what he asks for (and more than he bargained for) when he finds himself stranded alone on his island. One could say that the isolation turned RC into a better person. Robinson himself seems to realise that this experience brought him closer to God and to a life without sin (but he didn't respect others life). I've also found in the book some passage where it is it is unclear whether he even wants to be rescued and returned to society.
P.S: Sorry for my writing mistakes and for my clumsiness, but with all these changes I'm a little bit confused. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Larisa19 Dunker

Data inscrierii: 16/Mar/2020 Mesaje: 14
|
Trimis: 23/03/2020 17:15 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| 3B. I think the author didn't dramatize the isolation so much, and things took a positive turn in a short time. I mean Robinson immediately found survival methods. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Teacher Administrator

Data inscrierii: 26/Mar/2008 Mesaje: 471
|
Trimis: 23/03/2020 17:17 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Ulicianda19 a scris: |
Evil: I am cast upon a horrible, desolate island, void of all hope of recovery.
Good: But I am alive; and not drowned, as all my ship’s company was.
|
@UliciAnda, I’m glad you have brought up this wonderful section where Robinson discusses his own situation, if you remember, by putting it on two columns, the GOOD and the BAD (as many of us do when confronted with difficult dilemmas). Check the page in the 1719 original edition [url=https://ia800304.us.archive.org/BookReader/BookReaderImages.php?zip=/2/items/lifestrangesurpr01defo/lifestrangesurpr01defo_jp2.zip&file=lifestrangesurpr01defo_jp2/lifestrangesurpr01defo_0087.jp2&scale=4&rotate=0]HERE (click)[/url].
Let me ask: Does this approach to Life relate to Robinson being a bourgeois, a merchant?
Ultima modificare efectuata Teacher la 23/03/2020 17:25, modificat de 3 ori in total |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
ArdeleanIGabriel Diver


Data inscrierii: 16/Mar/2020 Mesaje: 54
|
Trimis: 23/03/2020 17:19 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
3D. When he imagines a human presence on the island, what kind of relation does Robinson think of?
Initially RC envisioned that another human presence would mean a companion to him, one he could speak to and co-operate with in order to survive and escape the island.
This image changes when he finds about the savages who occasionally land there in order to kill and eat their war prisoners (which frightens him greatly, but eventually overcomes the fear in order to save Friday). |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Larisa19 Dunker

Data inscrierii: 16/Mar/2020 Mesaje: 14
|
Trimis: 23/03/2020 17:19 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| As Evelin said, for other people the wreck on a desert island would mean death. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Iojiban Diana19 Rookie

Data inscrierii: 13/Mar/2020 Mesaje: 7 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 23/03/2020 17:20 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| i mean, can you fotografie how determined you need to be so you cand stay alive ? |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Evelin19 Diver


Data inscrierii: 13/Mar/2020 Mesaje: 52
|
Trimis: 23/03/2020 17:21 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Teacher a scris: | | Let me ask: Does this approach to Life relate to Robinson being a bourgeois, a merchant? |
yes because as a merchant you have to see both the dark and bright side of the things otherwise at the slightest difficulty or issue you might take a wrong step and lose your whole business. As a merchant you have to put things into perspective as in business there are always ups and downs |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
ArdeleanIGabriel Diver


Data inscrierii: 16/Mar/2020 Mesaje: 54
|
Trimis: 23/03/2020 17:22 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Teacher a scris: |
Let me ask: Does this approach to Life relate to Robinson being a bourgeois, a merchant? |
It certainly does, it almost looks like a Stengths-Weaknesses chart used by modern business owners. He Counts his blessings as well as his losses in order to better understand his current situation and take the right course of action. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Evelin19 Diver


Data inscrierii: 13/Mar/2020 Mesaje: 52
|
Trimis: 23/03/2020 17:25 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| 3D initially when RC thinks of human presence on island he perceives a friendly relationship, for example when that Spanish ship wrecks near the island he wishes a member of the crew had remained alive so he could have sb to talk to. But when he finds the footstep he becomes apprehensive and frets about cannibals' presence near his fortress |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
maria.lisca19 Rookie


Data inscrierii: 14/Mar/2020 Mesaje: 8
|
Trimis: 23/03/2020 17:26 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Also, the clipă Friday was discovered, Robinson Crusoe was frightened, because he didn't know how to relate to another human being who had a phenomenally different cultural background. He thought maybe he should fear for his life, because the saved can kill their saviors. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Teacher Administrator

Data inscrierii: 26/Mar/2008 Mesaje: 471
|
Trimis: 23/03/2020 17:28 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Evelin19 a scris: | | 3D initially when RC thinks of human presence on island he perceives a friendly relationship, for example when that Spanish ship wrecks near the island he wishes a member of the crew had remained alive so he could have sb to talk to. But when he finds the footstep he becomes apprehensive and frets about cannibals' presence near his fortress |
Well, isn’t that weird? Why should he freak now, instead of rejoycing at the anticipation of a human companion? |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
ArdeleanIGabriel Diver


Data inscrierii: 16/Mar/2020 Mesaje: 54
|
Trimis: 23/03/2020 17:28 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
3E. And then, when he has a first sign of another human presence/visit on the island, what is his reaction? How does he imagine those visitors to be? How does he act?
We've accidentally answered this question previously: Unfortunately for Crusoe, the first human visitors of his islands were Savages, who he observed to murder and eat other humans in a ceremonious manner (with singing and dancing) - He imagines them to be immoral people, forsaken by God (though he disputes this point quite a lot during the novel) and is terrified by them.
It would take RC a long time to rebuild the confidence to leave his fortress, but eventually he would even envision a plan to defeat the savages, should he find himself in a life or death predicament. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Evelin19 Diver


Data inscrierii: 13/Mar/2020 Mesaje: 52
|
Trimis: 23/03/2020 17:30 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Teacher a scris: | | Well, isn’t that weird? Why should he freak now, instead of rejoycing at the anticipation of a human companion? |
Because his actual human companions could eat him. Nevertheless, he has that dream when he rescues one of the cannibals and invites him in his fortress to hide from the rest of the cannibals, so when this comes to pass he acts almost just like in the dream |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Larisa19 Dunker

Data inscrierii: 16/Mar/2020 Mesaje: 14
|
Trimis: 23/03/2020 17:30 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| 3C. I was surprised when I got to the part where he said he got married. I did not expect it because until then he was not interested in this aspect. It seems that even after his marriage he did not show great interest for his wife or family life. He dedicated himself entirely to adventure. So after his wife death (which he probably considered an impediment), he left on the sea again. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
ArdeleanIGabriel Diver


Data inscrierii: 16/Mar/2020 Mesaje: 54
|
Trimis: 23/03/2020 17:31 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Teacher a scris: | | Well, isn’t that weird? Why should he freak now, instead of rejoycing at the anticipation of a human companion? |
Mainly because he wasn't expecting to see any other human on the island at that time - he didn't see any settlements on the island or any boats or canoes land there. I think this is why seeing human footsteps (other than his own) freaked him out. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Teacher Administrator

Data inscrierii: 26/Mar/2008 Mesaje: 471
|
Trimis: 23/03/2020 17:32 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| maria.lisca19 a scris: | | ...frightened, because he didn't know how to relate to another human being who had a phenomenally different cultural background. |
You said it very clearly, @MariaLisca, a ”phenomenally different cultural background”. However,all this had been all right if Robinson had never met people from other cultures.
But is that the case? Did he not know anything of other ethncities or races? let’s have a look at his past. Those nearly 100 pages of journeys before the shipwreck... |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Evelin19 Diver


Data inscrierii: 13/Mar/2020 Mesaje: 52
|
Trimis: 23/03/2020 17:33 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Teacher a scris: | | But is that the case? Did he not know anything of other ethncities or races? let’s have a look at his past. Those nearly 100 pages of journeys before the shipwreck... |
He actually met and cooperated with Xury who was a moor if i am not mistaken, after he had escaped from captivity |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
|