Pagina de start a forumului EngLit EngLit
Seminar extension for the students in English Literature at CUNBM
 
 FAQFAQ   CautareCautare   MembriMembri   GrupuriGrupuri   InregistrareInregistrare 
 ProfilProfil   Mesaje privateMesaje private   AutentificareAutentificare 

Pygmalion

 
Acest forum este inchis, nu se pot scrie, crea, raspunde sau modifica subiecte   Acest subiect este inchis, nu se pot crea sau raspunde la mesaje    Pagina de start a forumului EngLit -> 2.1 Romanticism & Victorian Age 2018-2019
Subiectul anterior :: Subiectul urmator  
Autor Mesaj
arianamateoc
Dunker
Dunker


Data inscrierii: 17/Iun/2018
Mesaje: 17

MesajTrimis: 05/01/2019 15:10    Titlul subiectului: Pygmalion Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1. In your opinion, how is Eliza and why do you think she wants so bad to learn how to speak English well?

2. What is your opinion about Eliza's father? Do you think he has any paternal interests in his daughter? What is his opinion about money?

3. Why do you think the author chose this title? Which are the main differences between the play and the mythological story?

4. What is the main thing that this play teaches us?
_________________
Ariana Mateoc, LRE III
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
luca.lorena17
Dunker
Dunker
luca.lorena17

Data inscrierii: 03/Apr/2018
Mesaje: 20

MesajTrimis: 19/01/2019 16:42    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1. From my point of view, Eliza has an enormous character, she is a sensible, wild and fearless. Smart and self-employed, she was a quick learner who understood the explanations of Pickering and Higgins about different accents and proper language. Of course, that’s why later in the play she can pass as a member of high society and exceeded the expectations of her two teachers. Liza turned from the poor girl into a noblewoman who seemed to have forgotten about the past, about the poverty in which she lived. Along the play, Ms. Doolittle performed a role and claimed that she can never be the ignorant person who doesn’t speak correctly and behaves inappropriately. I think that, she wanted to learn English well because she had a dream, Eliza decided that she doesn’t want to be just an uneducated girl selling flowers on the street but a florist at a store: “I want to be a lady in a flower shop stead of selling at the corner of Tottenham Court Road.”.

2. Alfred Doolittle doesn’t show any fatherly love to Eliza and I think that he is not interested in her welfare. Alfred wanted to play the caring father who hurried to recover his feeble daughter from the hands of a bad man who took advantage of her, but he had no concern in Liza's life, because he only wanted to make some money. He is a man with no morals because he plainly asks Higgins to offer him five pounds in exchange for his daughter. Although he wants money, I can’t say that he is a miser because when Higgins provided to give him ten pounds Doolittle vehemently rejected because "ten pounds is a lot of money: it makes a man feel prudent like; and then goodbye to happiness".

3. The author chose this title because he (Mr. Higgins) wanted to shape Liza like a sculpture, transforming her from the simple and poor girl into an aristocratic woman. Mr. Higgins, who is often a misogynist, lacks compassion and treated Eliza like a piece of marble or ivory, he doesn’t really care about her feelings and concerns. He played with her and tried to do her the way he wanted: perfect and spotless when it came to the correct use of the language, but Liza turned out to be an intelligent woman who wasn’t afraid to stand up for herself, so she loathed being regarded as an experiment, as a lifeless subject.

4. In my view, the play teaches us that we must not let anyone influence or control us like Ms. Doolittle did. Eliza left herself in the hands of Higgins, but in the end of the play, after an colossal battle of desires, she made a decision: to strike out on her own (“If I can’t have kindness, I’ll have independence,”). The play revealed us human characters such as: Higgins - the misogynist arrogant, Liza - the beautiful self-employed, Alfred - the “caring” father; this play also showed us the importance of the language relying on the fact that the knowledge and the correct speech of a language can give a different social status, that's why Liza turned from a girl who sold flowers on the street in an aristocratic woman.
_________________
Luca Andreea Lorena, CUNBM, LRE III


Ultima modificare efectuata de catre luca.lorena17 la 09/02/2019 14:18, modificat de 1 data in total
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Cristina.Ilcas17
Dunker
Dunker


Data inscrierii: 16/Mar/2018
Mesaje: 18

MesajTrimis: 03/02/2019 22:51    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1. Eliza is innocent, she is true to herself, she stands up for herself whenever she feels like doing it. Even if at first I thought that she is not that smart I was so wrong, she is smart. I mean she was a good "student", she always obeys to the orders that Higgings is given she sees the difference between Pickering and Higgings behaviour towards her and this means that even if she is not a lady yet she knows that she deserves to be treated like one ( Pickering "treats a girl as if she was a duchess").
It is very simple, she wants to learn English in order to excel herself. She became aware of what her life could become if only she learns how to speak properly " I want to be a lady in a flower shop stead of selling at the corner of Tottenham Court Road". I found it very strange how at that time you could had all the money in the world if you were lacking language, isn't it strange? Language not only has a communicative function but is the mark that people put on you when you belong to a society.
What is really important is that after the "experiment" has ended, she was no longer Eliza, Pickering and Haggins not only taught her how to speak but they also taught her how to behave, so they took the flower girl out of her, giving her a new identity "Oh! If only I could go back to my flower basket! i should be independent of both you and father an all the world! Why did you take my independence from me? Why did i give it up? I am a slave now, for all my fine clothes. "

2. I surely do not think that Mr. Doolitle has any parental interest in his daughter " well the truth is Ive taken a sort of fancy to you, Governer; and if you want the girl, I'm not so set on having her back home again but I might be open for an arrangement.... As a daughter shes not worth her keep" ..." if Eliza is going to have a bit out of this, why not me too?" All she wants from his daughter is her money, instead of showing real concern for his daughter that will share the house with two men, he only thinks how to make the best from this situation.
He has a good theory about money though, he is well aware of the fact that the more you have, the greedier you will become " Undeserving poverty is my line... Dont you be afraid that I'll save it and spare it and live idle on it. I'll have to go to work same as if I'd never had it."

3.Pygmalion was a Cypriot sculptor who carved a woman out of ivory, his statue was so beautiful and realistic that he fell in love with it. The author chose this title because Higgings is the sculptor and Eliza is the statute. But of course, in this play there is a huge difference : The sculptor ( Higgings) does not fall in love because of the beauty of his masterpiece (Eliza) but he falls in love with the accomplishment. He loves to teach, to transform seed into flower but he does not care about what will happen with the flower after he no longer suports her; what if the flower is ripped off by the wind? What if the sun does no longer shine and so the flower will be dead? Even if it seems like she became a woman that learns how to go through life I believe she is quite the opposite : " I sold flowers. I didn't sell myself. Now you've made a lady of me I'm not fit to sell anything else. I wish you'd left me where you found me."
All that Higgins wanted was to show off, to once again prove that he is a specialist on his field.

4. This play teaches us that "scopul nu scuza mijloacele". Higgings should have taken into the account her feelings, her desires, he should have guided her towards her goal- good think we also have Pickering in this play to help her out.
This play teaches us how a little thing as learning a language can change a life completely by opening doors and meeting with opportunities. But also that sometimes little is more than enough.
_________________
Ilcaș Cristina, LRE III
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
arianamateoc
Dunker
Dunker


Data inscrierii: 17/Iun/2018
Mesaje: 17

MesajTrimis: 06/02/2019 19:04    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1. Eliza was just a simple flower girl, in London, with not much knowledge about language, and this thing we can see from the way she talks at the beginning. When she heard Higgins and Pickering talk about the bet they made regarding that Higgins can made from Eliza a lady, by teaching her how to talk and what to do in the society, she is very interested and overwhelmed to hear such things. Her wish is not to become a lady in the high class, but to sell flowers being an educated lady, so she shows up at Higgins house and tells him that she wants to learn how to speak correctly. She wants to learn new things, and this thing especially, because it piqued her interest in becoming a lady. Despite that, throughout the play, Eliza seems to forgot who she was; Higgins started to teach her how to speak properly, and Eliza is growing slowly up on the social scale and being seen by other people.


2. Alfred Doolittle is a man that causes controversy and has, for sure, no interest in his daughter. He just take advantage of the situation to receive some money. He feels the need to say many things about the middle class, and their points of view are very interesting though - who deserves and who doesn't deserve to be in it, to have money or not.
Regarding his opinion about money, Doolittle doesn't want much. We could say that Alfred is obsessed with money, because he wants it in exchange for his daughter, but is not really like that. because he, however, has principles, and when Higgins offers to give him more money, he refuses him telling that is too much - he just wants to have enough money to live decent, to buy things that he needed. - and 5 pounds is enough.
An interesting aspect about Doolittle is shown in a part of the dialogue between him and Higgins: ''Have you no morals, man?'' - asked Higgins; and Doolittle replies: ''Can't afford them, Governor. Neither could you if you was as poor as me''. I like this paragraph, because it's strengthening Doolittle's ideas and views about poor life and how these people should be, but this does not excuse his behavior about his daughter, anyhow.


3. As we may or may not know, Pygmalion is a character from Greek mythology, whom he fell in love with his own creation. This thing we can see, also, in this play. When Mr. Higgins started to teach Eliza how to become a lady in the high class, he also started, indirectly, to carve her as he wanted. He, then, treated her like a toy, with no feeling or emotions, just a toy he can play with and do whatever he wants to it. Even if she seems like a person who doesn't know much, Eliza shows us that she has her own personality, she is real, we can feel her transformation into a better women, she knows how to move, how to speak, how to behave in the upper classes, she is intelligent - and this happens because she is doing her best to achieve her goal - she is much more than we could imagine. Her transformation is real, because this is what she wants, but anyhow, Higgins thinks that she is his creation, just because he was part of this transformation.
I think that Shaw named his play like that, because he created in such way, to show us what things worked in those days and how poor people were seen in comparison with high classes, and, mostly, because Higgins treated Eliza in a similar way as Pygmalion did.


4. From my point of view, this play teaches us, firstly, that no matter who you are, where your from and how poor your knowledge are, you can become a lady, you can become who you want to become. If you really want something, you can achieve it, no matter how many people will try to prevent you from your journey to the goal.
Secondly, Eliza teaches us that becoming a lady is much more than manners and good looking - is about intelligence, realness, inside beauty, kindness, and perseverance.
Last, but not least, we learn that we are not anybody's toys and no one can tell us what to do and how to be and, especially - take us for granted. Mr Higgins thought that if he made from Eliza a lady, he can do whatever he wants to her, control her emotions, how to feel, what to feel, how to behave etc., but Eliza prove him wrong.
_________________
Ariana Mateoc, LRE III
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
ani.mihaela2017
Dunker
Dunker
ani.mihaela2017

Data inscrierii: 26/Mar/2018
Mesaje: 16

MesajTrimis: 06/02/2019 21:29    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1. Eliza
For me Eliza is another example on how cruel was the society with women, how inferior and helpless were they considered to be. How hard it was for a woman to work for her living, to be judged wrong and most of all to don’t have a word to say in front of others, and still this poor women kept the society on their shoulders, worked as much as they could and united their voices to shout loud the truth about the real society: “I have to live for others and not for myself: that’s middle class morality.”
Being a woman Eliza couldn’t have a profitable job so she had to sell flowers, working like this every day to gain something for her living.
Being there, in the street Eliza saw the difference between herself and girls from good families, how good they are treated and how can a dress and a good control of language changes everyone opinion about you, about your life. Eliza wanted to live such a life, and her dream comes true. With the help of Professor and his friend, Colonel Pickering, Eliza learn how to speak correct, how to dress properly and how to behave in society. But she learned another lesson from this experience, that society is cold, insensitive and once you are a part of it it’s like you don’t belong anywhere. “I sold flowers. I didn't sell myself. Now you've made a lady of me I'm not fit to sell anything else.” So she gave all of her just for a chance but her life was stolen, she became a new Eliza, a young lady designed by the preferences of the society, a nice companion but a lost soul in the middle of everything. She was a good person since the beginning but there was no one to show her that so she became part of an experiment . But she learnt a lesson from this experience, that not a nice dress and dancing at a party make you superior but the way you think and treat the others: “The great secret, Eliza, is not having bad manners or good manners or any other special sort of manners, but having the same manner for all human souls: in short, behaving as if you were in Heaven, where there are no third-class carriages, and one soul is as good as another.”
2.Eliza’s father
I think that if Eliza’s father had any paternal interests in her, he shouldn’t let her live like that. “HIGGINS. Have you no morals, man?
DOOLITTLE [unabashed] Can’t afford them, Governor. Neither could you if you was as poor as me.”
Eliza’s father couldn’t see in her his reflexion, his blood but a person he had to support a time then he should throw her away from the nest as it is too small to carry so many souls. So she was left alone in a society were a single woman couldn’t live easily, were to have a good job was almost like a dream for a woman, many girls ending up as mistresses and puppets in the hands of the powerful ones. After Eliza decided to change her life and ended up living in the professor’s house, Doolittle looked for his daughter but not to see if she is in good hands but to try to take a profit from this situation. As his name says ‘’Do little’’ this character takes his life as it is and doesn’t do something to improve it but just to survive by taking money from the others.

3.The title
I think the author choose this title because as in the Greek legend, this story is about creating your own kind of life. The professor took an unfinished creation and refined it after his own matrix. But from the Greek mythology where ‘’Galatea never does quite like Pygmalion’’ because ‘’ his relation to her is too godlike to be altogether agreeable.”, Eliza falls in love with his creator and not vice versa so here is the difference. If Pygmalion took a lifeless object and created it after his own heart, Professor Higgins played with a person. He could adjust her appearance and her manners but he couldn’t change her heart. In Greek mythology but also in the Christian religion the ones that gave life are the gods. So he took the creation of God and tried to change it but he couldn’t because this creation was blessed with intelligence and a heart that beats uncontrolled. Because how much we try to look better, to speak properly in the bottom of our hearts we are still that little kids that want to conquer the world, we are still unable to control our feelings and our destinies.
4. The lesson
“I can't turn your soul on. Leave me those feelings; and you can take away the voice and the face. They are not you.”
The play teaches us that we are different. How much we try to be like others, to feel like we are part of a group we will never be like them because there will always be something that will make the difference.
They lived and we live in a society where to be like the others matters more than who you are. Trying to reach a standard we loose ourselves at the half of the way, we forget what are we made of, what do we think and what we feel. We became like some puppets in the hands of the ones who say how and what. But what matters after all? A beautiful appearance that will disappear in time, expensive clothes that make us look good know but later will become obsolete, this and many others are things that make us feel good, but later we won’t remember how we looked but what we felt.
*quotes from the play ''Pygmallion'' by G.B. Shaw
Ani Mihaela, LRE II
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Alexandra Noje 17
Plunger
Plunger
Alexandra Noje 17

Data inscrierii: 14/Mar/2018
Mesaje: 27
Localitate: Satu Mare

MesajTrimis: 06/02/2019 22:29    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1. Eliza is a girl whom I appreciate very much. From the point when she accepted professor’s Higgins proposal of teaching her to speak English properly to the one in which she became a respectable woman, I admire the way she fights for a better life. In that period of time, if you were born in a lower class family, like Eliza, you could climb up the social ladder only by working hard. And that’s what she did. Given the fact that the statute of women was changing and they were finally starting to be more appreciated and valued in the family life, I think that Eliza was lucky to have this chance to become such a woman. For me, she is a truly valuable woman.

2. Eliza’s father is not even concerned about his daughter's life. The only thing that made him look for her at that point was money: “If you want the girl, I'm not so set on having her back home again but I might be open for an arrangement...“. He remorseless says that she is: “A daughter shes not worth her keep”. My opinion is that when Mr. Higgins wanted to give him 10 pounds and he refused, he was very cynical.

3. I think that G.B. Shaw chosed this title because in his play he picked up many of the myth’s elements. As the girls previously said, in the Greek mythology, Pygmalion was a sculptor and he was not interested in women or in marriage, until he created a beautiful sculpture. He named it “Galatea”. He fell in love with his own creation and prays to Aphrodita, the Greek goddess of love, to bring it to life. The goddess fulfilled his wish and he married his creation, because he saw perfection in it. In my opinion, the main difference between the play and the mythological story is that Mr. Higgins does not fell in love with Eliza and he doesn’t want to marry her. Also, she doesn’t want to marry him either. She has a strong will and character and doesn’t allow him to trample her: “I sold flowers. I didn't sell myself. Now you've made a lady of me I'm not fit to sell anything else.”

4. The main thing that this play teaches us is that no women should let anyone to trample her, even if that person helped her in a way. Back then, maybe another woman would accept her faith, but Eliza is a smart woman and she believes in her abilities. To help someone achieve something is one thing, but to try to take advantage of that is a very malicious attitude. Sadly, this mechanism still works nowadays.
_________________
Alexandra Noje, LRE III, CUNBM
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat Trimite un mesaj
PatakiRoxana17
Dunker
Dunker


Data inscrierii: 22/Mar/2018
Mesaje: 16

MesajTrimis: 07/02/2019 13:03    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1. Eliza...an unexperienced girl, an immature one and a very easy-handle one meaning an influential girl. Eliza didn't have high expectations from life. The fact that she wants to learn how to speak English well is just a moral thing for her. Probably she would feel more confident, and she thought that learning to speak accurately English make her a mature woman."A woman who utters such depressing and disgusting sounds has no right to be anywhere—no right to live. Remember that you are a human being with a soul and the divine gift of articulate speech: that your native language is the language of Shakespear and Milton and The Bible; and don't sit there crooning like a bilious pigeon." and this was the judgements that she heard day by day. Actually, her desire is to work in a flower shop. In my opinion, the fact that she cannot speak properly English makes her unique. For instance, when she gets angry she use to howl like: "Ah-ah-ah-wo-wo-wo-oo!" fact wich make her special and emphasise her feelings. Another beautiful thing about her is the fact that she is not afarid to show her feelings and to tell what she thinks about. Her simplicity is revealed in the clipă when she was afraid to have a shower with warm water and to throw away her plainclothes in order to become an educated woman. "I tell you, it's easy to clean up here. Hot and cold water on tap, just as much as you like, there is. Woolly towels, there is; and a towel horse so hot, it burns your fingers. Soft brushes to scrub yourself, and a wooden bowl of soap smelling like primroses. Now I know why ladies is so clean. Washing's a treat for them. Wish they saw what it is for the like of me!" It is to be appreciated the fact that she accepted Higgin's proposal to teach her how to speak English in spite of the fact that she had known that he will do this on personal purpose and for his satisfaction. Moreover, Higgins didn't behaved nice to Eliza, at all. Her transformation shows the importance of the language and education in society. Once you are educated and you have the ability to know how to express yourself, you are apreciated in any domain.

2. Unfortunatelly, Eliza's father didn't know how to teach his daughter about life. Actually, he didn't have an interest in it. The only important thing for him was how to gain money in order to spend it on beverage. As I said, he didn't have a paternal interest in his daughter because when he found out that his daughter live in Mr Higgin's house, he visited him on the purpose of paternal interest but, in fact, he wanted a certain amount of money from him. For Mr. Alfred Doolittle, money was not a problem of increase but the assurance for days when he lakes drinking. In my opinion, a man like him couldn't be named as a FATHER.

3.The author referred to the Myth of Pygmalion because Higgins have seen Eliza as a sculpture because he insisted on his work towards Eliza, meaning to make her a duchess in three months. Then he didn't care about her future or what she would do later on. He was obssed with his work and fell in love with his work as Pygmalion fell in love with his statue. "HIGGINS [becoming excited as the idea grows on him] What is life but a series of inspired follies? The difficulty is to find them to do. Never lose a chance: it doesn't come every day. I shall make a duchess of this draggletailed guttersnipe."

4. We can learn two things from this play. Firstly, it is important to know how to behave, to know how to speak and to tell your point of view. It is important not to let others handle you and to make of yourself another person as you are. Another thing is the fact that Mr. Higgins was selfish regarding his behaviour towards Eliza and he had fallen into his own trap by falling in love with his own work.
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
ceuca.dorinela17
Dunker
Dunker


Data inscrierii: 28/Mar/2018
Mesaje: 16

MesajTrimis: 07/02/2019 13:23    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1 At the beginning Higgins said that a woman who pronounce such disgusting words has no right to be anywhere, no right to live .‘’A woman who utters such depressing and disgusting sounds has no right to be anywhere no right to live. Remember that you are a human being with a soul and the divine gift of articulate speech that your native language is the language of Shakespeare and Milton and The Bible and don't sit there crooning like a bilious pigeon. Why can`t the English learn how to speak?’’. This girl, Eliza Doolittle, believes in her potential and she really wanted to learn how to speak correctly. She wanted to become a lady in a shop and she goes at Higgins, she wanted to pay him for teaching her how to speak. They accepted and this was like a challenge because they wanted to teach her and presented her as a duchess. They started the process and they take care to change Eliza from all these point of view. She was shocked when Mrs. Pearce take her to make a bath and she has an weird reaction. After these episodes Higgins explain her to understand what`s the next step and what they want to do with her: ‘’If you are good and do whatever you`re told you shall sleep in a proper bed and have lots to eat and money to buy chocolates and taxis but if you are naughty and idle you will sleep in the back kitchen among the negru beetles and be walloped by Mrs. Pearce with a broomstick. If she refuse this offer you will be the most ungrateful girl and angels will weep for you’’. She need to practice a lot and Higgins apply all the strategies. Higgins put six pebbles in her mouth as an exercise to pronounce the words correct. ‘’The rain in Spain stays mainly in the plain’’, is the first sentence that she succeed to pronounce correct. After all these she was disappointed because she thought that Higgins wanted only to find a resolve to the challenge and after will abandon her ans she prefer to leave the house. I can say that Eliza has her dignity even if her life was not the best, she is confident and this experience make her be more strong. She succeed to become an independent woman and she learn to keep a balance in her life. She is an example for a lot of women .

2 ‘’What is middle class morality? Just an excuse for never giving me anything. Therefore, I ask you, as two gentlemen, not to play that game on me. I'm playing straight with you. I ain't pretending to be deserving. I'm undeserving; and I mean to go on being undeserving. I like it; and that's the truth. Will you take advantage of a man's nature to do him out of the price of his own daughter what he's brought up and fed and clothed by the sweat of his brow until she's growed big enough to be interesting to you two gentlemen? Is five pounds unreasonable? I put it to you; and I leave it to you’’. Eliza`s father think of himself, he is not a real father to her , he did not take care of her and also he did not take care about her education as a parent should do. He used to drink all his money and Eliza often gives him money. After he found about Eliza that she is at Higgins` home he go there for money, it make us understand that he sold his daughter for money.’’ Give me what I asked, not a penny less, not a penny more’’ , these are the words he used when meet Higgins. He meet there Eliza but he had no reaction as a parent. After he had money he gave drinks to all his friends. Also we can say that he does not deserve this kindness from Eliza, he is not an example to follow, more is an example that must be avoid .

3 In the mythology, Pygmalion was a sculptor who fell in love with the statue he carved, he created a woman. Also in our story is a similarity because Higgins took Eliza ‘as a baby child’ and he teach her everything was necessary for making her being as a ‘duchess’. He behaves with her in some moments like with an object or better say like a sculpture. He wanted to shape Eliza according with his ideals and make her exactly as he imagine. From this point of view he lost very much because he forgot that this ‘sculpture’ has a soul, a heart and more important she has feelings. Initially he wanted just to follow his purpose and he ignore what was the essential , what was the most important .

4 In my opinion this book teach us to believe in us and believe in our dreams. Eliza was a poor girl who did not have anything but because she wanted something she fight for her dreams and she succeed. She is an example for the women because she shown that even she was alone in this world she could do something better. She did not have a father to protect her and no one to offer her a better life, she needed to work for what she wanted. After this process of learning the language she now has a lot of possibilities to grown up and to become what she wanted from the beginning.

Ceuca Dorinela LRE II
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
ioanaosan2017
Dunker
Dunker


Data inscrierii: 22/Mar/2018
Mesaje: 15
Localitate: Mocira

MesajTrimis: 09/02/2019 01:15    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1.In my opinion Eliza is a beautiful but naive woman, maybe because she did not have a good education from her poor family. Her behavior is peasant, does not have a vocabulary too developed, and the pronunciation of her words is stunted. She accepts Higgins' challenge to teach her English to perfection in just six months because she hurts to work in a flower shop not at the corner of the street. But I think she did it because she did not want to be criticized by other people like English. I have seen Eliza and perseverance, because the way she teaches English was not exactly one worthy of a woman or even a man, rather than a dog. She supports all of Mr. Higgins's experiments just to climb into society.

2.The father of Eliza is the kind of archetype that raises children for the benefit to take money. He is a poor man who always waits for Eliza to make money by selling flowers for him to take and drink. Father Eliza is convinced that if she is his daughter he has every right to take his money. Although there were other times, they were poorer and only those who had money had an enviable status. Today you can not do anything without money.

3.As far as I know the name Pygmalion has its origin in mythology, where the author is inspired. Myth is about pygmalion who was alone sculptor and created the sculpture of a woman, but he gets to fall in love with her. The author thinks it was easier to put the name Pygmalion instead of naming Higgins to call it more artistically. But also because Higgins is sort of a sculptor trying to make Eliza an experiment. He wants to sculpt her own tongue and make her speak English well. Higgins is trying to do all sorts of exhausting experiments, such as learning vocals or other things that were difficult for Eliza. But eventually she manages to make her a masterpiece, elegance, cheerfulness and an English she spoke perfectly. The result of the experiment is only seen when Eliza arrives at the palace, but it must go unnoticed as if she were born with a perfect English language.And the difference between Pygmalion and Mr. Higgins is that one sculpts a woman, and the other sculpts only the language she speaks.
_________________
Osan Ioana Paula, CUNBM Litere LRE III
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat Trimite un mesaj
Emanuela Negru
Dunker
Dunker
Emanuela Negru

Data inscrierii: 26/Mar/2018
Mesaje: 18

MesajTrimis: 09/02/2019 21:02    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1. Eliza is an interesting girl who wanted to learn English just to be a florist and to make a business with flowers. In her childhood she didn’t have the opportunity to study because her mother died and her father, Alfred Doolittle has no interest in her education. He is telling her that she is a mature girl and she can survive alone. Eliza is a smart girl who learn manners and dialect in a short period of time with the help of professor Henry Higgins and colonel Pickering. Professors Henry Higgins is a professor of phonetics and also a temperamental man who see her like an experiment. He condense everything to time and lessons without thinking about her feelings. Colonel Pickering is the author of Spoken Sanskrit. On the other side, Eliza is very spontaneous, she say everything that she has in her mind. She is a courageous girl who make everything to sell her flowers, so we can say she is a “businesswoman”. She is telling professor Higgins in act I that she is a respectable girl who make honest penny. I think, she represent “le bon savage”, the theory that was sustained by romantic poets like William Wordsworth, the spontaneous person who is uncivilized but very innocent. She is a direct person, she speak directly and also she is not tainted by society. Honestly, I don’t think that society make you a bad person, we can see from Eliza transformations. At the beginning of the book she is a fool girl , a little bit wild and without manners. We can see all this in her way to dress and also in her language. She didn’t use the correct form of the words, she speak an altered form of English. But in the end, we see a completely changed girl who is unrecognizable. She become an independent lady who can discuss at a tea or at a ball with everyone. She has manners and now she speak a good English. This book is about the process of building a character. In act I, professors Higgins speak very ruthless with her, but the girl didn’t seem to be affected by his behavior. Eliza seems very foolish, like she didn’t understand that the professor speak about her and her language. “R. A woman who utters such depressing and disgusting sounds has no right to be anywhere—no right to live. Remember that you are a human being with a soul and the divine gift of articulate speech: that your native language is the language of Shakespeare and Milton and The Bible; and don’t sit there crooning like a bilious pigeon.” Mr. Higgins is telling her that she is a human creature with a singular gift, the power of articulate words, that can form a phrase helping you in society. I found very funny her answer to his words, after Mr. Higgins told her about her irrationality in using the words, she just imitate some kind of sounds “[quite overwhelmed, and looking up at him in mingled wonder and deprecation without daring to raise her head] Ah—ah—ah—ow—ow—oo!”This is her answer to professor ‘s observation. The most important moment of the book, is the beginning, the moment that collapsed everything, the Mr. Higgins observation regarding the flower girl “ You see this creature with her kerbstone English: the English that will keep her in the gutter to the end of her days. Well, sir, in three months I could pass that girl off as a duchess at an ambassador’s garden party. I could even get her a place as lady’s maid or shop assistant, which requires better English. That’s the sort of thing I do for commercial millionaires. And on the profits of it I do genuine scientific work in phonetics, and a little as a poet on Miltonic lines.” He said that in three months he can get her a place in high society. We can say this is the beginning of the story, everything started from his words. In the next day the girl arrived at the professor’s home with the noble reason of giving him a job and money to teach her English. She sees everything very simple, I offered you money and you have to teach me. But what she gave him is inadequate for this job, she needs more money. What she wanted I think is a human desire, to change your life when you have the opportunity. To have the courage to follow your own dream. For professor Henry, Eliza’s dream seems too small, but for her is the only way to survive in an hostile world. And now the question is if her dream is adequate for their level of perception. He can’t teach her English just to return in the place where she was before. He wanted to make her a lady, and her place will be not on the streets, she will became a true lady. I think, his book reveals us the fact that everybody can dream to a better life. YOU can make a change in your little, insignificant life. I really like Eliza’s courage to go to professor’s house and take the decision to be a lady. This book shows us the women’s social rank in that society. If you are a lady you have to behave properly and to have a nice long chat to a ball with a beautiful tucker, you have to make a very good impression. Eliza is a voice for girls without a voice, and an example for the girls who wanted to change their life. In that time, I think were girls who were on the wrong side of society maybe because didn’t have the opportunity to study, or because didn’t have money.

2. I think Alfred Doolittle is not interested in his daughter’s education. He is a very good orator, he has a unic gift, to talk with people and to determine them to give him what he wanted. For example, when Eliza is in the house of professor Henry, he arrived here and he wanted money. He is not interested about his girl, he wanted money. At a first impression, the reader didn’t know what to believe, the fact that he is a foolish man or the fact that he I very sneaky.” HIGGINS: Then how did you know she was here? DOOLITTLE: [“most musical, most melancholy”] I’ll tell you Governor, if you’ll only let me get a word in. I’m willing to tell you. I’m wanting to tell you. I’m waiting to tell you.” He seems to be an intelligent man regarding his social rank. But he is an ignoble man because he is selling his daughter without compunction. “DOOLITTLE. Course they are, Governor. If I thought they wasn’t, I’d ask fifty. HIGGINS [revolted] Do you mean to say, you callous rascal, that you would sell your daughter for 50 pounds? DOOLITTLE. Not in a general way I wouldn’t; but to oblige a gentleman like you I’d do a good deal, I do assure you. PICKERING. Have you no morals, man? DOOLITTLE [unabashed] Can’t afford them, Governor. Neither could you if you was as poor as me. Not that I mean any harm, you know. But if Liza is going to have a bit out of this, why not me too?” In his opinion is not such a bad thing to sell your daughter for 50 pounds, and of course of all things to a gentleman, this is more than good. Also he wanted just 5 pounds, nothing more, for a middle class man, he is a little bit unconventional. He is living his life following his rules, and he amazes Higgins with his oratorical abilities. “HIGGINS [rising, and going over to Pickering] Pickering: if we were to take this man in hand for three months, he could choose between a seat in the Cabinet and a popular pulpit in Wales.” He is that type of man who wanted to enjoy his life, he didn’t like to be rich, also if his daughter has a privileged life he wanted to take advantage of this. “If Liza is going to have a bit out of this, why not me too?” So, he is the man who take advantage from every situations, also he is a resourceful man.

3. Pygmalion is a myth from Greek mythology about a sculptor who fall in love with his sculpture. He was disgusted by all women that he met in his life. He decided to make a sculpture to represent the perfect woman. He fall in love with his work and Aphrodite had given life to the statue, whose name was Galatea. Pygmalion was full of joy and after this they formed a couple. Pygmalion myth represented a source of inspiration for George Bernard Show who wrote a play, in which the girl is “animated” in art of speech by two men: professor Higgins and colonel Pickering. In contrast to Pygmalion myth, in the play written by George Bernard Show, the girl is a young lady who didn’t speak a correct English. She is taught by a professor of phonetics how to speak, and how to behave like a lady. If in the mythology the creator fall in love with his creature, in the play, the creator is inhuman, he didn’t count the girl feeling, he treated the girl like an experiment. He loves experiments, and with this opportunity he is all in this project. The girl is like an object, the object of his passion, phonetics, the language. At some point, in the end, the girl tell him her opinion about his behavior, the fact that she is a human creature, not a object of his work. In the moment when they are returning after the ball, Higgins had a conversation with Pickering about the girl’s performance. The girl is in the room, but they talk about her like her is not there and her opinion about that night is not important. They discuss about all details without counting the girl in their conversation. Also Higgins is telling to his mother that the girl is his creation. “You let her alone, mother. Let her speak for herself. You will jolly soon see whether she has an idea that I haven’t put into her head or a word that I haven’t put into her mouth. I tell you I have created this thing out of the squashed cabbage leaves of Covent Garden; and now she pretends to play the fine lady with me.” In this quote, Higgins suggest the fact that he made the girl and now she play a game with him. But Eliza told him about his bad behavior and his bad manners and also about Pickering, the only men that deserve her gratitude. We can say that in the end of the book, Eliza is an independent girl who take her decisions in life, and she is not influenced by another person.

4. I believe that “Pygmalion” was written to shows us the transformation of a character. That naïve girl who had nothing in her life, just a bouquet of flowers became a special girl who had the world at her feet . Her personality was shadowy by the strict rules of society. But after someone refined her personality, teaching her how to behave, how to dress and how to speak the girl found her confidence in herself. The girl was the same, at the beginning to the end, but what changed was her manners, and her way to speak and think about the world. I really admire her character and her power to believe in herself. Her dream comes true at the end of the story being married with Freddy Eynsford Hill, a naive boy, like Higgins tells Eliza about him. In conclusion, what is important is our character that counts more than anything and also our humanity, our kindness. “The great secret, Eliza, is not having bad manners or any other particular sort of manners, but having the same manners for all human souls: in short behaving as if you were in heaven, where there are no third-class carriages, and one soul is as good as another” I think, in the final what is important is the way that we had related to our life, our kindness, our feelings regarding other people.
In the end of the story, Eliza is telling Higgins “I sold flowers. I didn’t sell myself. Now, you’ve made a lady of me, I’m not fit to sell anything else.” She is grateful to Higgins but now she can take care of herself, because she didn’t need his help, and she will never sell her dignity. She endures everything to shape her character, but now she will not endures the humiliation, and the fact that she is treated like an object. There is a quote that I like very much “The difference between a lady and a flower girl is not how she behaves but how she is treated” from “ My fair lady”(Audrey Hepburn as Eliza Doolittle) When Eliza was just a flower girl people had a bad behavior regarding her, even if she was kind with them. But in the moment when she changed her social rank, people started to appreciate her and they treated her different. It’s true the fact that she dressed different, she speak different but in the society sometimes the social rank is more important than our personalities. Sometimes, we just forget the fact that everyone is a person who had feelings, not just money or power.
NEGRU EMANUELA, LRE II


Ultima modificare efectuata de catre Emanuela Negru la 10/02/2019 01:19, modificat de 1 data in total
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Sabadis Andreea
Dunker
Dunker


Data inscrierii: 25/Mar/2018
Mesaje: 17

MesajTrimis: 09/02/2019 22:32    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1.From my point of view, Eliza is a poor girl who tries to survive selling flowers.She came from a poor family, from where she didn't have what to learn. It is to be apreciated that she has chosen to earn her living working and not begging. If we are looking at the poors today, we see that many of them don't have a job, they don't want to work. They choose to beg every day. Maybe, one of us can tell that Eliza begs from the other people, but she offers something instead. ''THE FLOWER GIRL [to Pickering, as he passes her] Buy a flower, kind gentleman. I’m short for my lodging.'' In the biginning Eliza is thankfull of her pozition, she did't want to change her statut till Higgins tells her that she can be a lady if she want. She isn't disappointed by her English:''THE FLOWER GIRL [springing up terrified] I ain’t done nothing wrong by speaking to the gentleman. I’ve a right to
sell flowers if I keep off the kerb. [Hysterically] I’m a respectable girl: so help me, I never spoke to him except to ask him to buy a flower off me.'' Higging told her that if she want, she can be a lady'' Well, sir, in three months I could pass that girl off as a duchess at an ambassador’s garden party. I could even get her a place as lady’s maid or shop assistant,
which requires better English.'' Of course that when she heard that she can become a lady, she wanted to learn English and to change her statute.
2.I think that Eliza's father hasn't paternal interests in his daughter'' Well, the truth is, I’ve taken a sort of fancy to you, Governor; and if you want the girl, I’m not so set on having her back home again but what I might be open to an arrangement. Regarded in the light of a young woman, she’s a fine handsome girl. As a daughter she’s not worth her keep; and so I tell you straight. All I ask is my rights as a father; and you’re the last man alive to expect me to let her go for nothing; for I can see you’re one of the straight
sort, Governor. Well, what’s a five pound note to you? And what’s Eliza to me?'' Doolittle wanted money to spent with his missus''Not me, Governor, so help me I won’t. Don’t you be afraid that I’ll save it and spare it and live idle on it. There won’t be a penny of it left by Monday: I’ll have to go to work same as if I’d never had it. It won’t pauperize me, you bet. Just one good spree for myself and the missus, giving plăcere to ourselves and employment to others, and satisfaction to you to think it’s not been throwed away. You couldn’t spend it better''. He thinks that if the people have many money they spend many, if the people have few, they spend fewer.
3.I think that the author chose this title because his story resembles with the mythological story. Higgins wanted to make a lady from Elize like a sculpture. Higgins is associated with Pygmalion and Eliza with Galateea. The main difference between the play and the mythological story is the fact that Pygmalion have feelings for Galateea, instead Higgins didn't care so much about Eiza's feelings. He thought only at his purpose, he didn't think that maybe Eliza have feelings, will, or other interests.
4.In my opinion, the play teaches us that we should't let other people to decide our lives. We can receive advise from other people, but we make decisions. Anther think that we cam learn from this play is the fapt that in life doesn't matter our social position, ef we are ambitious, we can make our dreams become reality.
SABADIS ANDREEA LRE II
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Sabadis Andreea
Dunker
Dunker


Data inscrierii: 25/Mar/2018
Mesaje: 17

MesajTrimis: 09/02/2019 22:38    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1.Eliza is a young girl with an unatractive accent and a faulty pronunciation,these things attract the famous professor Henry Higgins who was very confident that he could make Eliza look like a duchess.In my opinion Eliza wanted to be a lady, to overcome her condition and most important herself,to be respected and to maintain her dignity.At first Eliza's ambitions were smaller and she did not think so far but the professor Higgins insistence turn them in ideals,she saw that everything depends on her.
2.Eliza's father,Alfred Doolittle is a man of nothing,once he saw Eliza near proffesor Higgins,he he begin to take his ,,father's role" seriously,in other words Doolittle had some principles but not in the positive way.He had some bad habits like drinking and spending all his money having fun but in order to achieve these he needed money that Professor Higgins has.Shameless Doolittle demands Mr. Higgins five pounds for Eliza's custody with a very good talking skills.Higgins is amased by this speaking skills and accept.Eliza's father accept only five pounds and no more because he can't handle more money because he is in a different social class,in the poor one.
3.The author took the name (Pygmelion) from the mythological story,in the myth was a sculptor that sculpted ore made feminine figure that is brought to life.In ,,our" story this sculptore is Professor Higgins with his little experiment Eliza,which tried to found the best version of herself or to surpass ownself.From my point of view the difference between ,,Pygmelion" and the mythological story is that in the story the sculptor fall in love with his creations before they turned to life,in Pygmelion,Professor Higgins disrespected Eliza feelings,he made fun of her and even bullied her.After this transformation of Eliza he started to change his behaviour and started to admire her because Eliza become finally a lady with confidence,self respect and higher standards.
4.The play teach us that every human being is special and unique,the author bring to us the transformation of Eliza,the effort of professor Henry Higgins and what he saw in Eliza,he told her that he could become like a duchess and he did it somehow.Professor Higgins fixed her target,he believed in her,showed her how to talk and behave in society.
CHEREJI IONUT LRE II
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Afiseaza mesajele pentru a le previzualiza:   
Acest forum este inchis, nu se pot scrie, crea, raspunde sau modifica subiecte   Acest subiect este inchis, nu se pot crea sau raspunde la mesaje    Pagina de start a forumului EngLit -> 2.1 Romanticism & Victorian Age 2018-2019 Ora este GMT + 2 ore
Pagina 1 din 1

 
Mergi direct la:  
Nu puteti crea un subiect nou in acest forum
Nu puteti raspunde in subiectele acestui forum
Nu puteti modifica mesajele proprii din acest forum
Nu puteti sterge mesajele proprii din acest forum
Nu puteti vota in chestionarele din acest forum


Powered by phpBB © 2001 phpBB Group
trevorj :: theme by ~// TreVoR \\~
Fa-ti si tu propriul forum GRATUIT, pe www.myforum.ro