 |
EngLit Seminar extension for the students in English Literature at CUNBM
|
| Subiectul anterior :: Subiectul urmator |
| Autor |
Mesaj |
Major Octavian Ciprian Dunker

Data inscrierii: 25/Oct/2015 Mesaje: 16
|
Trimis: 14/05/2017 17:08 Titlul subiectului: ”Mrs. Dalloway” by Virginia Woolf |
|
|
”Mrs. Dalloway” by Virginia Woolf
I cannot help but to see Virginia Woolf in this book as a bee and her characters as flowers. She goes from flower to flower, from character to character, collecting information about them and also personal opinions and thoughts about the main character: Clarissa Dalloway, this transition from character to character not being so obvious though.
Personally, I focused more on other characters' opinions about Clarissa, choosing the quotes that were more important in creating an image about Clarissa through characters' perception about her... so let's get it started.
Firstly, the reason why Clarissa didn’t marry Peter is not very clearly expressed in the book, nor in Clarissa's thoughts for that matter:
”So she would still find herself arguing in St. James’s Park, still making out that she had been right — and she had too — not to marry him."
Still, there are a few hints why Clarissa didn't marry Peter. The need of independence perhaps was the most pregnant in making a choice; independence which she could not have with Peter (being together all the time, maybe travelling together, as we all know that Peter loved to travel), but with Richard this need was satisfied: "For in marriage a little licence, a little independence there must be between people living together day in day out in the same house; which Richard gave her, and she him. (Where was he this morning for instance? Some committee, she never asked what.) But with Peter everything had to be shared; everything gone into. And it was intolerable, and when it came to that scene in the little garden by the fountain, she had to break with him or they would have been destroyed, both of them ruined, she was convinced; though she had borne about with her for years like an arrow sticking in her heart the grief, the anguish; and then the horror of the clipă when some one told her at a concert that he had married a woman met on the boat going to India!”
Out of all people, I believe that Peter knows Clarissa the most. His thoughts about her are expressed throughout the book.
Here are some of Peter’s thoughts about Clarissa:
Peter believes that Clarissa has become too cold, not at all how he remembered her. He thinks that the Dalloways, being now in a high-class, would believe him to be a loser, a failure, somehow inferior to them.
”Shall I tell her, he thought, or not? He would like to make a clean breast of it all. But she is too cold, he thought; sewing, with her scissors; Daisy would look ordinary beside Clarissa. And she would think me a failure, which I am in their sense, he thought; in the Dalloways’ sense.”
For a second time, Clarissa is seen as being cold from Peter's point of view. He believes that her timidity from childhood had become conventionality now as an adult, as if she would obey to any rules, not having a personality of her own, being dull...
”There was always something cold in Clarissa, he thought. She had always, even as a girl, a sort of timidity, which in middle age becomes conventionality, and then it’s all up, it’s all up, he thought, looking rather drearily [trist] into the glassy depths, and wondering whether by calling at that hour he had annoyed her”
Peter remembers her as being timid, hard, arrogant, unimaginative and prudish, although her reputation preceeds her again. He says that people tend to bow with her every move.
”He hadn’t blamed her for minding the fact, since in those days a girl brought up as she was, knew nothing, but it was her manner that annoyed him; timid; hard; something arrogant; unimaginative; prudish [pudica, rusinoasa]. “The death of the soul.” He had said that instinctively, ticketing the moment as he used to do — the death of her soul. Every one wobbled; every one seemed to bow, as she spoke, and then to stand up different.”
For a third time, Peter describes her as being cold, as if she was made of wood (with nothing real, like she was a machinery, not a human being anymore), though she had the capability of toying with people's nerves.
”There were always people about — she’d go on as if nothing had happened. That was the devilish part of her — this coldness, this woodenness, something very profound in her, which he had felt again this morning talking to her; an impenetrability. Yet Heaven knows he loved her. She had some queer power of fiddling on one’s nerves, turning one’s nerves to fiddle-strings, yes.”
Among all the negative traits and flaws that he remembered about Clarissa (the fact that she cared too much about social status), Peter mentions others, this time, positive traits (in fact, one positive trait: her honesty). He fears again that he had become the kind of person so despises so much: a fogy, a frump and a failure.
”The obvious thing to say of her was that she was worldly; cared too much for rank and society and getting on in the world — which was true in a sense; she had admitted it to him. (You could always get her to own up if you took the trouble; she was honest.) What she would say was that she hated frumps [oamenii imbracati prost], fogies [persoanele cu idei invechite], failures, like himself presumably”
For a fourth and a fifth time Clarissa is described as being cold, this time Peter takes it to the extreme: "cold as an icicle", as if nothing can be colder than her. Maybe he sees her as a rigid, distant woman, far from what he remembered about her, which kind of explains why he is so shocked of this transformation and why he underlines the idea of her being cold so many times.
”That was what tortured him, that was what came over him when he saw Clarissa so calm, so cold, so intent on her dress or whatever it was; realising what she might have spared him, what she had reduced him to — a whimpering [smiorcait], snivelling [mofturos] old ass. But women, he thought, shutting his pocket-knife, don’t know what passion is. They don’t know the meaning of it to men. Clarissa was as cold as an icicle.”
Peter thinks that she became a snob, the type of person that reached a high position in the society and likes to be surrounded only by people from the same class as her; while Richard might think that Clarissa is wrong to take excitement from this; there appears the author's intrusion, who, like a guardian angel, takes Clarissa's side and says that Clarissa simply liked life.
”[...]she enjoyed imposing herself; liked to have famous people about her; great names; was simply a snob in short. Well, Peter might think so. Richard merely thought it foolish of her to like excitement when she knew it was bad for her heart. It was childish, he thought. And both were quite wrong. What she liked was simply life.”
Richard's opinion about Clarissa is expressed in the quote below:
”He had, once upon a time, been jealous of Peter Walsh; jealous of him and Clarissa. But she had often said to him that she had been right not to marry Peter Walsh; which, knowing Clarissa, was obviously true; she wanted support. Not that she was weak; but she wanted support.”
He admits that he had been jealous of Peter at one moment in the past, but Clarissa did right to marry him, instead of Peter. He says that she is the type of woman that needs support from her man, perhaps support which Peter couldn't offer her. So, if we are to think about it... does he refer to financial support?
Flashback about Clarissa:
Even though it seems like Peter only remembers the bad parts of Clarissa, he especially remembers the ocazie in which they went boating. Everything about her seems mesmerizing for Peter, which I take as a proof of love from him:
”He had twenty minutes of perfect happiness. Her voice, her laugh, her dress (something floating, white, crimson), her spirit, her adventurousness; she made them all disembark and explore the island; she startled a hen; she laughed; she sang. And all the time, he knew perfectly well, Dalloway was falling in love with her; she was falling in love with Dalloway; but it didn’t seem to matter. Nothing mattered.”
Sally’s opinion is that if Clarissa enters this high society by marrying Richard Dalloway, her soul would be crushed and she would be turned into what they wanted her to be, she would be basically lost, corrupted by these "perfect gentlemen", which I believe it did happen:
”while she implored him, half laughing of course, to carry off Clarissa, to save her from the Hughs and the Dalloways and all the other “perfect gentlemen” who would “stifle [inabusi] her soul” (she wrote reams of poetry in those days), make a mere hostess of her, encourage her worldliness.”
Other opinions about Clarissa:
Lady Bexborough believes that the "governing class" in which Clarissa had entered influenced her, she would be "straight as a dart", rigid, as if she wanted to be worthy of this new class and at the same time afraid not to lose her respect.
”Lady Bexborough, she said once, held herself upright (so did Clarissa herself; she never lounged in any sense of the word; she was straight as a dart, a little rigid in fact). She said they had a kind of courage which the older she grew the more she respected. In all this there was a great deal of Dalloway, of course; a great deal of the public-spirited, British Empire, tariff-reform, governing-class spirit, which had grown on her, as it tends to do.”
Miss Kilman’s opinion about the Dalloways:
”Miss Kilman stood on the landing, and wore a mackintosh; but had her reasons. First, it was cheap; second, she was over forty; and did not, after all, dress to please. She was poor, moreover; degradingly poor. Otherwise she would not be taking jobs from people like the Dalloways; from rich people, who liked to be kind. Mr. Dalloway, to do him justice, had been kind. But Mrs. Dalloway had not. She had been merely condescending. She came from the most worthless of all classes — the rich, with a smattering of culture. They had expensive things everywhere; pictures, carpets, lots of servants. She considered that she had a perfect right to anything that the Dalloways did for her.”
I believe Miss Kilman was in a way jealous of what the Dalloways had and what the Dalloways were. She couldn't reach the riches, their way of living and therefore she chosed to despise them with all her heart, especially Clarissa. She says that at least Richard was kind to her, while Clarissa wasn't; therefore, if Clarissa hadn't been so lucky, she would work in a factory with all her "fine ladies" friends.
”She pitied and despised them from the bottom of her heart, as she stood on the soft carpet, looking at the old engraving of a little girl with a muff. With all this luxury going on, what hope was there for a better state of things? Instead of lying on a sofa — “My mother is resting,” Elizabeth had said — she should have been in a factory; behind a counter; Mrs. Dalloway and all the other fine ladies!”
”But Miss Kilman did not hate Mrs. Dalloway.”
”Fool! Simpleton! [naiva] You who have known neither sorrow nor pleasure; who have trifled your life away!”
Miss Kilman also thinks that Clarissa's problems are not problems at all, because she had the luck to not know sorrow. She only wasted her life with small things.
How Clarissa wanted to be + how servants see her:
”[...]she went on saying in gratitude to her servants generally for helping her to be like this, to be what she wanted, gentle, generous-hearted. Her servants liked her.”
Clarissa's reputation and social status (from a high-class) preceeds her wherever she goes. She is treated with respect even by strangers:
”Tall men, men of rezistent physique, well-dressed men with their tail-coats and their white slips and their hair raked back who, for reasons difficult to discriminate, were standing in the bow window of Brooks’s with their hands behind the tails of their coats, looking out, perceived instinctively that greatness was passing, and the pale light of the immortal presence fell upon them as it had fallen upon Clarissa Dalloway. At once they stood even straighter, and removed their hands, and seemed ready to attend their Sovereign, if need be, to the cannon’s mouth, as their ancestors had done before them.”
Septimus Warren Smith's death
I believe that Septimus's death could have been avoided. He believed that his doctor, Mr. Holmes, wanted to steal his soul, and that's the reason he jumped out of the window, impaling himself in the fence. He specifically asked for another doctor (when he went to see Sir William Bradshaw) to show up and take care of him, but when Mr. Holmes showed up, he had no choice but to save his own soul by killing himself. Apparently, there was no purpose in asking for a second opinion. If only Mr. Holmes hadn't shown up... maybe Septimus would still be alive, recovering in that isolated house where Sir William Bradshaw wanted to put him in... poor Septimus. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Selena Acqui Plunger

Data inscrierii: 08/Noi/2016 Mesaje: 33
|
Trimis: 03/06/2017 09:26 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
Virginia Woolf seems to be, as you said, a bee in search of thoughts. Not only does she manage to fabricate an atmosphere in which time is felt to have vanished, but she also enchains series of her characters' thoughts. “Mrs Dalloway”, or as it was called in the first instance – “The Hours”, made critics take two sides regarding Clarissa's picture in the novel. According to Elaine Showalter in her Introduction to the Penguin Edition of "Mrs Dalloway", the novelist, Paul Bailey had the impression that, “at her most interesting she is a snobbish, vain, repressed lesbian who has dabbled in culture, but for the greater part of the novel she is only a shadow, poetically enshrined.” However, feminist critics like Sandra Gilbert and Susan Gubar, “describe her as 'a kind of queen' who 'with a divine grace...regenerates the post-war world' ”. Woolf has also described the essential idea of her narrative technique in one of her notes:
“My discovery: how I dig out beautiful caves behind my characters; I think that gives exactly what I want; humanity, humour, depth. The idea is that the caves shall connect, & each comes to daylight at the present moment.”
Regarding Clarissa and Peter’s meeting after so many years, a mix of memories, thoughts, impressions, and emotions is shown. Clarissa may have had her reasons, but Peter still seems to be affected by her decision. After a long time of not seeing each other, at first, when they meet, Peter seems to be thrilled. She is also content to see him, but she manages to control her feelings. While analysing how time has changed them, Clarissa is the one who can distinguish more features, as Peter is overcome by emotion:
“ ‘And how are you?’ said Peter Walsh, positively trembling; taking both her hands; kissing both her hands. She’s grown older, he thought, sitting down. (...) She’s looking at me, he thought, a sudden embarrassment coming over him, though he had kissed her hands.”
“Exactly the same, thought Clarissa; the same queer look; the same check suit; a little out of the straight his face is, a little thinner, dryer, perhaps, but he looks awfully well and just the same.”
As she looks at Peter, Clarissa appears to be pleased to see him, but past feelings start to make room in her mind, as well :
“He’s very well dressed, thought Clarissa; yet he always criticises me.”
As he looks at Clarissa, Peter remembers her social status and a feeling of jealousy is felt among his thoughts, as he analyses Clarissa’s image for a moment:
“Here she is mending her dress; mending her dress as usual, he thought; here she’s been sitting all the time I’ve been in India; mending her dress; playing about; going to parties; running to the House and back and all that, he thought, growing more and more irritated, more and more agitated, for there’s nothing in the world so bad for some women as marriage, he thought; and politics; and having a Conservative husband, like the admirable Richard.”
Peter has a bunch of negative thoughts about Clarissa which, I think, grows as memories are brought into discussion or people appear by chance. For instance, Clarissa reminds Peter of the time passed at Bourton, but only after saying it aloud, Clarissa realises that she has just brought back Peter’s memory regarding her refusal in marrying him. Thus, Peter seems to start feeling weak:
“(...) it almost broke my heart too, he thought; and was overcome with his own grief, which rose like a moon looked at from a terrace, ghastly beautiful with light from the sunken day. I was more unhappy than I’ve ever been since, he thought.”
Also, when she reminds him of the lake, he can’t control his feelings anymore, and this is the ocazie when he starts thinking of how cold Clarissa really is. However, among all the negative features with which he characterises her, he realises that she has an extraordinary power of bringing back the past:
“And it was awfully strange, he thought, how she still had the power, as she came tinkling, rustling, still had the power as she came across the room, to make the moon, which he detested, rise at Bourton on the terrace in the summer sky.”
Besides all the negative description Peter has made regarding Clarissa, he ends up admiring how she could impose herself in a crowd of people:
“She had a perfectly clear notion of what she wanted. Her emotions were all on the surface. Beneath, she was very shrewd – a far better judge of character than Sally, for instance, and with it all, purely feminine; with that extraordinary gift, that woman’s gift, of making a world of her own wherever she happened to be. She came into a room; she stood, as he had often seen her, in a doorway with lots of people round her. But it was Clarissa one remembered. Not that she was striking; not beautiful at all; there was nothing picturesque about her; she never said anything specially clever; there she was, however; there she was.”
What I also consider to be interesting and makes Peter confused and angry is Clarissa’s way of calling her daughter, “My Elizabeth”:
“The way she said ‘Here is my Elizabeth!’ – that annoyed him. Why not ‘Here’s Elizabeth’ simply? It was insincere. And Elizabeth didn’t like it either.”
However, Clarissa also remembers, analyses, and reacts to what they talk about. At some instances, we can even notice that she says something to Peter, but thinks of other things:
What she thinks: “Now of course, thought Clarissa, he’s enchanting! perfectly enchanting! Now I remember how impossible it was ever to make up my mind – and why did I make up my mind – not to marry him, she wondered, that awful summer?
What she says: “ ‘But it’s so extraordinary that you should have come this morning!’ she cried, putting her hands, one on top of another, down on her dress.”
When Clarissa asks Peter if he remembers the lake, she actually seems to have a lot of emotions going on in her heart:
“ ‘Do you remember the lake?’ she said, in an abrupt voice, under the pressure of an emotion which caught her heart, made the muscles of her throat stiff, and contracted her lips in a spasm as she said ‘lake’.”
Even when she finds out that Peter is in love, she seems confused, but also, a little jealous:
“ ‘In love!’ she said. That he at his age should be sucked under in his little bow-tie by that monster! And there’s no flesh on his neck; his hands are red; and he’s six months older than I am! Her eye flashed back to her; but in her heart she felt, all the same; he is in love. He has that, she felt; he is in love.”
“(...) this indomitable egotism charged her cheeks with colour; made her look very young; very pink; very bright-eyed as she sat with her dress upon her knee, and her needle held to the end of green silk, trembling a little. He was in love! Not with her. With some younger woman, of course.”
Regarding the support she actually needed, this is debatable. She might have wanted financial support, as well as someone to understand her dreams. Perhaps she felt that she would get more support from Richard than Peter, who would usually criticise her. However, I think that, being a young girl when she chose whom to marry, the financial status might have also influenced her. This can be, perhaps, inferred through her thoughts regarding marriage, while thinking back at Peter, when Richard brings her the flowers and can’t tell Clarissa that he loves her:
“ ‘And it came over me ‘I might have married you’;’ she said, thinking of Peter sitting there in his little bow-tie; with that knife, opening it, shutting it. ‘Just as he always was, you know’.”
During her conversation with Richard, she actually wonders whether she wishes she had married Peter. Before he leaves, Clarissa thinks of how there is a certain side in people’s relations that cannot be fulfilled with emotions, a side which is private for everyone:
“And there is a dignity in people; a solitude; even between husband and wife a gulf; and that one must respect, thought Clarissa, watching him open the door; for one would not part with it oneself, or take it, against his will, from one’s husband, without losing one’s independence, one’s self-respect – something, after all, priceless.”
Moreover, I think Clarissa believes that the most pure love she has ever felt is the one she has had for Sally:
“The strange thing, on looking back, was the purity, the integrity, of her feeling for Sally. It was not like one’s feeling for a man. It was completely disinterested, and besides, it had a quality which could only exist between women, between women just grown up. It was protective on her side; sprang from a sense of being in league together, a presentiment of something that was bound to part them (they spoke of marriage always as a catastrophe), which led to this chivalry, this protective feeling which was much more on her side than Sally’s.”
Concerning the relation between Clarissa and Miss Kilman, the latter went from hatred to pity regarding Clarissa, but Miss Kilman still didn’t like her:
“Miss Kilman was not going to make herself agreeable. She had always earned her living. Her knowledge of modern history was thorough in the extreme. She did out of her meagre income set aside so much for causes she believed in; whereas this woman did nothing, believed nothing.”
Clarissa, however, despises this woman, thinks of her being “odious” and she is afraid that she may lose Elizabeth because of her:
“(...) This woman had taken her daughter from her! She in touch with invisible presences! Heavy, ugly, commonplace, without kindness or grace, she know the meaning of life!”
Even when Miss Kilman and Elizabeth leave the house, Clarissa fights, “with a sudden impulse, with a violent anguish” that her daughter is taken away from her by this woman, and runs to the banister where she tells Elizabeth one more time, “Remember the party! Remember our party to-night!”
To her servants, she would usually be kind, especially when she thanked them for helping her. Therefore, she thought her servants liked her:
“(...) thank you, thank you, she went on saying in gratitude to her servants generally for helping her to be like this, to be what she wanted, gentle, generous-hearted. Her servants liked her.”
For instance, Lucy, one of her servants, really thinks that among a lot of people, her favourite would still be Mrs Dalloway:
“(...) They would come; they would stand; they would talk in the mincing tones which she could imitate, ladies and gentlemen. Of all, her mistress was loveliest.”
The best contrast which Woolf makes in this novel is, indeed, the one between Clarissa Dalloway and Septimus Warren Smith. According to Elaine Showalter’s Introduction, Virginia Woolf wrote in her notebook the following lines:
“Suppose it to be connected in this way: Sanity and insanity. Mrs D. seeing the truth, SS seeing the insane truth. The pace to be given by the gradual increase of S’s insanity on the one side; By the approach of the party on the other side.”
Suffering from shell-shock, from losing his friend, Septimus Warren Smith hears voices and has hallucinations. According to some specialists’ analysis, because of these, as well as of his constant sense of guilt, we could be suggested that he suffered from schizophrenia. All this might have started as a consequence of remorse concerning his attitude when Evans had died. I think we can also talk about remorse when we mention what he had felt for Lucrezia. From my point of view, the most disturbing fact is, that during and after the war, he actually loses his capacity of emotions; he loses his ability of reacting to things:
“(...) when Evans was killed, just before the Armistice, in Italy, Septimus, far from showing any emotion or recognising that here was the end of a friendship, congratulated himself upon feeling very little and very reasonably. The War had taught him. It was sublime. He had gone through the whole show, friendship, European War, death, had won promotion, was still under thirty and was bound to survive. He was right there. The last shells missed him. He watched them explode with indifference.”
“When peace came he was in Milan, billeted in the house of an innkeeper with a courtyard, flowers in tubs, little tables in the open, daughters making hats, and to Lucrezia, the younger daughter, he became engaged one evening when the panic was on him – that he could not feel.”
“She could not grow old and have no children! She was very lonely, she was very unhappy! She cried for the first time since they were married. Far away he heard her sobbing; he heard it accurately, he noticed it distinctly; he compared it to a piston thumping. But he felt nothing.” |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
CCD Dunker

Data inscrierii: 26/Oct/2015 Mesaje: 21
|
Trimis: 09/06/2017 13:21 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
Throughout the story, there is no one who fully knows or understands Clarissa Dalloway. Everyone sees only a part of her: the wife, the mother, the friend, the girlfriend. Not even Clarissa knows who she is anymore as the time that passed by took her youth with it. She used to be regarded as a beautiful woman who was drawing others’ attention and admiration whenever she entered a room. She is terrified that, like a flower that loses its color and beauty in time, she will too be ignored and forgotten: “How much she wanted it — that people should look pleased as she came in, Clarissa thought…But often now this body she wore (she stopped to look at a Dutch picture), this body, with all its capacities, seemed nothing — nothing at all. She had the oddest sense of being herself invisible; unseen; unknown; there being no more marrying, no more having of children now, but only this astonishing and rather solemn progress with the rest of them, up Bond Street, this being Mrs. Dalloway; not even Clarissa any more; this being Mrs. Richard Dalloway”.
Diana Ciocotişan |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Butean Dana Plunger

Data inscrierii: 27/Oct/2015 Mesaje: 49 Localitate: Lapus
|
Trimis: 11/06/2017 22:00 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
"For Heaven only knows why one loves it so, how one sees it so, making it up, building it round one, tumbling it, creating it every clipă afresh; but the veriest frumps, the most dejected of miseries sitting on doorsteps (drink their downfall) do the same; can’t be dealt with, she felt positive, by Acts of Parliament for that very reason: they love life."
I loved this quote very much and is part of Clarissa's thoughts when she goes to the flower shop in the morning, and Big Ben calls his watch, reveals his strong attachment to life and the concept of life as his own invention. The appearance, her mood reflects her enthusiasm to be alive on this June day. Clarissa thinks that the impressions of the things around her have no beauty or significance in themselves, but that people act as architects, building impressions in extraordinary and beautiful moments. She herself enjoys this act, the effort that life desires, and knows that even the poorest person living on the streets can draw the same miracle of life. She notes that happiness does not belong to a certain class, but she knows that every man can be happy. Later, her husband, Richard, sees a vagabond woman on the street, but it only classifies her as a matter of society that the government has to resolve. Clarissa believes that every class of people has the ability to become aware of beauty and enjoy life, and therefore believes that government intervention has limited uses, it does not have to do everything. It does not mark the equality of class and happiness. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
|
|
Nu puteti crea un subiect nou in acest forum Nu puteti raspunde in subiectele acestui forum Nu puteti modifica mesajele proprii din acest forum Nu puteti sterge mesajele proprii din acest forum Nu puteti vota in chestionarele din acest forum
|
|