Pagina de start a forumului EngLit EngLit
Seminar extension for the students in English Literature at CUNBM
 
 FAQFAQ   CautareCautare   MembriMembri   GrupuriGrupuri   InregistrareInregistrare 
 ProfilProfil   Mesaje privateMesaje private   AutentificareAutentificare 

Jane Eyre

 
Acest forum este inchis, nu se pot scrie, crea, raspunde sau modifica subiecte   Acest subiect este inchis, nu se pot crea sau raspunde la mesaje    Pagina de start a forumului EngLit -> 2.1 Romanticism & Victorian Age 2018-2019
Subiectul anterior :: Subiectul urmator  
Autor Mesaj
Alexandra Noje 17
Plunger
Plunger
Alexandra Noje 17

Data inscrierii: 14/Mar/2018
Mesaje: 27
Localitate: Satu Mare

MesajTrimis: 19/01/2019 18:33    Titlul subiectului: Jane Eyre Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1. How would you describe Jane and Mr. Rochester's relationship? And what do you think they learned in the end?

2. Why did Charlotte Brontë feel the need to make Jane rich?

3. What did the fire solve?

4. Why did Brontë need to cripple and blind Mr. Rochester?
_________________
Alexandra Noje, LRE III, CUNBM
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat Trimite un mesaj
luca.lorena17
Dunker
Dunker
luca.lorena17

Data inscrierii: 03/Apr/2018
Mesaje: 20

MesajTrimis: 19/01/2019 21:22    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1. In the beginning, their relationship is master - maid, but during the novel, the arrogant man is tamed by Jane because he falls in love with her. Jane wanted an affair in which the significant others respect and treat each other as equals; he always thought that Jane is intellectually similar to himself, even if Rochester had a big treasure and Jane was just a poor girl. Between them was a huge difference in age (“there are twenty years of difference in your ages. He might almost be your father”) and Rochester believed that he can control Jane because she’s younger and callow, so he gave her the role of mistress. Like any other woman, Jane turned out to be worthy, rejected this role and left. She returned just when she was richer than her former master and took the lead of the relationship, turning it into a marriage, proving through this the woman’ superiority.

2. Jane Eyre goes through more social status - the orphaned girl raised by her severe aunt, the governess who falls in love with the rich arrogant, and an heiress of an immense wealth -, but unlike other characters she doesn’t judge a person based on social class. I think that in the end the author inherited her main character because she wanted Jane to be much richer than her former master. Jane always blamed herself for supposing that she could ever be worthy for Mr. Rochester, and realized fast that her social class is holding her back. She compared herself with Blanche Ingram, who was everything that she wasn’t, rich and attractive, and she was shocked when Rochester asked her for marriage. She disagreed with the marriage between a wealthy man and a poor girl, so the fortune that she inherited in the final made her fulfill her love: she returns and marries with the man who wasn’t as rich as before.

3. & 4. From my point of view, the fire solved the issue of marriage, because Bertha, Rochester's first wife, triggered the fire and then committed suicide. So, after Jane's return, she and Rochester can marry. But when Jane came back in Thornfield, she found a cripple and blind poor Rochester which was powerless at that time. I think that the author ultimately punished him for his arrogance and superiority that he showed up against Jane; so the novelist transformed her heroine into a powerful, independent, and wealthy woman, and made Rochester inferior to the woman he had discerned at first. Even if Charlotte Brontë elevated Jane above Rochester, her leading lady remained the same young lady all along the novel although her class status transformed drastically.
_________________
Luca Andreea Lorena, CUNBM, LRE III


Ultima modificare efectuata luca.lorena17 la 20/01/2019 15:40, modificat de 3 ori in total
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Alexandra Noje 17
Plunger
Plunger
Alexandra Noje 17

Data inscrierii: 14/Mar/2018
Mesaje: 27
Localitate: Satu Mare

MesajTrimis: 20/01/2019 00:17    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1. My opinion is that Jane Eyre and Edward Rochester’s first meeting was not a proper one for a master and his employee. They should have met properly, with an official introduction. So, as we can see from the very beginning, their relationship is a different one. At their first encounter, she helped him to stand up after he fell from his horse, and he was very ashamed that a woman helped him. He also asked her what she thinks about the master of Thornfield Hall, but her answer was that she didn’t met him yet. After that scene, they had the proper meeting, but none of them spoke of their previous encounter. Mr. Rochester gets to know Jane just from their short discussions. He fell in love with her intelligence and attitude, not with her beauty. In the beginning, the main reason why he is suppressing his feelings is because of the age difference between them, which was 20 years. He is keeping secrets from her, and also is testing her over and over again, to see her reactions. Even if he does that and hurts her feelings (for example, with his proposal to Blanche Ingram), she is willing to accept him, because she loves him: “I had not intended to love him; the reader knows I had wrought hard to extirpate from my soul the germs of love there detected; and now, at the first renewed view of him, they spontaneously revived, green and strong! He made me love him without looking at me”. I believe Jane learned that behind an arrogant mask it may exist a very pure soul which wants to be loved, while Mr. Rochester learned that a relationship should be based on honesty, not on secrets and lies.

2. I believe Brontë feels the need to make Jane rich in an attempt to see how would she react and what would she do with so much money. Will she go back to Rochester and tell him: “Look, I’m rich! I’m like you now!” or she will keep her dignity untouched? Probably another Victorian orphan girl, who just inherited a fortune would use it to marry a wealthy man and have a good life. But Jane is different; her value scale has DIGNITY on the top of it. This was maybe another test, this time coming from destiny, to see if she will change, or she will remain the same good girl as we know her. Of course, she shared her inheritance with her cousins and she continued to be a wonderful person. I think it was an attempt on making Jane equal to Rochester in social class by growing her statute, but it failed.

3&4. The fire. In my opinion, the fire is Brontë’s second attempt on making Jane equal to Rochester in social class, but this time by lowering his statute (he becomes poor) and this wasn’t a failure like the other one. The fire was not a disaster; in a way, the fire was the answer to all their problems, the “key” to their happiness and liberty to be together by removing Bertha, his wife, from the plot. Brontë felt like that is the only way to reach an equality of feelings between them. I think Brontë feels the need to cripple and blind Rochester not in order to make him inferior, but to make him the man Jane needs: a humble, loving and honest man which she desired all along.
_________________
Alexandra Noje, LRE III, CUNBM


Ultima modificare efectuata de catre Alexandra Noje 17 la 09/02/2019 19:47, modificat de 1 data in total
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat Trimite un mesaj
Cristina.Ilcas17
Dunker
Dunker


Data inscrierii: 16/Mar/2018
Mesaje: 18

MesajTrimis: 03/02/2019 23:47    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1. Jane and Mr. Rochester's relationship has many ups and downs. Although there is a chemistry that could be seen from miles away their relationship was not founded on true bases. Mr. Rochester is an experienced man, he know how to speak in order to have Jane by his side ( for example when she wanted to live the argument he had is that she will condemn him to death "Then you condemn me to live wretched, and to die accursed") . He falls in love with her sincerity, with her mind (“He sees nothing attractive in me; not even youth—only a few useful mental points…Oh, you need not be jealous!...But if you wish me to love you, could you but see how much I do love you, you would be proud and content. All my heart is yours, sir; it belongs to you; and with you it would remain, were fate to exile the rest of me from your presence forever.”), and with her way of thinking "You are my sympathy - my better self - my good angel. I am bound to you with a strong attachment."
"It is my spirit that addresses your spirit; just as if both had passed through the grave, and we stood at God's feet equal - as we are!" here Jane stands for her feelings, she claims that love should meet no boundaries, that even if they are master and employee they should find a way. And they did, but Rochester's lies and promises turn to nothing when the terible truth comes out: he has a wife, Jane can never accept this, even if he does not love her, she knew that this "demon" will hunt them forever. So she goes away proving that a woman should have principles. ("The more solitary, the more friendless, the more unsustained I am, the more I will respect myself. I will keep the law given by God; sanctioned by man. I will hold to the principles received by me when I was sane, and not mad—as I am now. Laws and principles are not for the times when there is no temptation: they are for such moments as this, when body and soul rise in mutiny against their rigour; stringent are they; inviolate they shall be")
I believe in the end they learned that love would always find a way. That if it is meant to be it will be. I also believe that Rochester learned how important the truth can be, that a relationship can be based only on sincerity and true feelings.

2. I believe Charlotte Bronte wanted to make Jane rich so that she would give Jane a chance to be independent from all men. She wanted to give her something in exchange for her behavior, for her obedience, for her heart.
Also by giving her money readers could see a situation where she can pull the strings. But instead of rising her up, she shares the money with her cousins make her character more lovable than ever.

3. The fire solved everything. Jane and Rochester did not marry as Berta stood in their path to happiness, so, as Bertha died, they could finally merge their souls and consume the relationship. After the fire Jane could let her true feelings come out to light. She has a pure soul, once she found out about Bertha she could not accept to ruin the laws of marriage. She wanted to be loved but she also wanted to be free, she wanted to have a life of her own and not to be in Rochester's life to live a life that would constantly make her feel guilty for loving a man that is not her's and would never be as long as Bertha is bound to him.
"Come to my side, Jane, and let us explain and understand one another."
"I will never again come to your side: I am torn away now, and cannot return."
"But, Jane, I summon you as my wife: it is you only I intend to marry."
I was silent: I thought he mocked me.
"Come, Jane—come hither."
"Your bride stands between us."
Some say that the fire has a purifying effect, so that all the evil can leave the place in order to let the peace be restored.

4. I believe the author made Rochester blind to give a little justice to Jane. Being powerless, Jane was now the one that was superior, she was somehow empowered. When you loose your eyesight an partea interioară eye wakens, so I believe Rochester could see clearer than ever that he has made huge mistake and now he is ready to make things right.
"To be together is for us to be at once as free as in solitude, as gay as in company. We talk, I believe, all day long: to talk to each other is but a more animated and an audible thinking. All my confidence is bestowed on him, all his confidence is devoted to me; we are precisely suited in character—perfect concord is the result."
"There was no harassing restraint, no repressing of glee and vivacity, with him; for with him I was at divin ease, because I knew I suited him; all I said or did seemed either to console or revive him. Delightful consciousness! It brought to life and light my whole nature; in his presence I thoroughly lived, and he lived in mine. Blind as he was, smiles played over his face, joy dawned on his forehead; his lineaments softened and warmed."
_________________
Ilcaș Cristina, LRE III


Ultima modificare efectuata de catre Cristina.Ilcas17 la 09/02/2019 13:38, modificat de 1 data in total
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
ani.mihaela2017
Dunker
Dunker
ani.mihaela2017

Data inscrierii: 26/Mar/2018
Mesaje: 16

MesajTrimis: 06/02/2019 14:23    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1.Jane and Mr. Rochester relation
For me their relation express the phrase ‘’Never say never!’’. From the beginning to the end their relation had to go through a lot of hard moments filled with suffer and loneliness. Jane entered in Edward’s life as a governess for his daughter, Adele, so between them was nothing more than a relation strict professional. She came into his house with nothing more than few dresses but with a luggage filled with simplicity, respect, intelligence and a hardworking conscience. So she was different, she was something new, she had something he couldn’t find in other women. Being so amazed by this simple girl, started to be interested to discover her and day by day he fell in love with her. Jane was conscious that there can’t be a relation between a governess and her master because the society won’t allow that so she tried to avoid her feelings, to look indifferent but she couldn’t so she fell in love with the man she considered once ugly. Jane was always looking for someone to love her as she is: independent, realistic and honest. Feeling truly loved for the first time Jane couldn’t see that between that lovely moments penetrated the lies and the secrets. She discovered in her wedding day that the man to which she was ready to vow her love, was already married. Her dreams, her hopes were destroyed in a ocazie so being left with nothing Jane decided to leave him putting an end to what she called love.
“Her coming was my hope each day,
Her parting was my pain;
The chance that did her steps delay
Was ice in every vein .”- Mr. Rochester
She went far away from that place and ended almost dead in a priest’s house, St. John Rivers. She stayed there for a long time, she tried to forget everything, to start a new a life but their love was stronger and called her back. When she returned she couldn’t find anything she left, not the house, not his secret and neither the proud man who lied her. After her departure, Edward’s dark secrets came to light and his mad wife tried to destroy everything by setting the castle in fire leaving him with nothing. So after Jane returned they had a chance to start again, to făcute the life they wanted, to love each other and live happy together.
I think they learned in the end that not a bag of money can make you happy but the person who stands next to you, who cares about you because when you are left with nothing if you don’t have someone to be next to you, your life ends. Even after Jane found out about his mad wife, he couldn’t end his seek relation because Bertha was the source of his fortune. Because of money he couldn’t renounce to that life and tried to make Jane only his mistress. He was so proud, he thought he is strong because of his money, he couldn’t choose between Jane and his wealth.

2. Jane becoming rich
Jane became rich only at the end of the story and here we wonder why. I think that Charlotte Bronte choose this moment to teach us a lesson. Even if she became rich and with this fortune she didn’t had to work anymore she choose to go on with the principles she learned, to spend a simple life as she always did because she knew, as her friend Helen thought her, that as much as you endure the difficulties of life you will make the wish of Father .Living in a school were religious morals were thought Jane couldn’t change her mind and chose to share her fortune with her cousins. But what if Jane found about her uncle when she was little, could she grow up with the same principles as now? Could she have learned something from this life if she will grow in luxury, without knowing the taste of starvation, the harshness of the cold and the reward for a hard work? No. Maybe she wouldn’t have been like the other young ladies but maybe she wouldn’t understand how to be strong in a cruel world, how to stand up over and over again, because rich people think only about how strong they are with some money in their pockets “Do you think me, because I am poor, obscure, plain and little, I am soulless and heartless?”-Jane Eyre. So even if she was poor she had pride and virtues and here comes the lesson: not money make a person but its principles, feelings and ideas. If you’re a man of principles a bag of money won’t change you. Let’s make a comparison between Blanche and Jane...which one loved Rochester truly? The one who had money but wanted more or the one who was poor but loved that person not for money and a status in society but loved him for as he was the man who stolen her heart? So why made Bronte Jane rich only now? To show that love is beyond everything...With money she could run away from a blind and cripple man, to start a new life, as Blanch would have did for sure, but she stood next to him, loved him and took care of him because this is what she knew to help the ones in need and give them a hand when they can’t stand up on their ones.
3. The fire
The fire gave them the chance to a new life. This part is like the legend of the Phoenix bird, burn and reborn from your ashes. This fire deleted Edward’s dark past and let them create new memories. I wonder how would have the novel end if Jane returned and met the same castle and the same proud man she left. I think that until his past wouldn’t have be gone forever, they couldn’t have had a chance to be happy because he couldn’t divorce Bertha and Jane was to independent to accept a destiny like many other girls did, to live in an immoral way, to become his mistress. In her soul was a battle between the love for this man and the morals she learnt. She grow up repeating over and over again how a pure soul should be so how could she just throw away this thoughts? She couldn’t and didn’t wanted to live a life designed by others, she couldn’t lie if the truth was lying in front of her eyes, she couldn’t accept to change what she was just because someone told her that this is not proper. “God waits only the separation of spirit from flesh to crown us with a full reward. Why, then, should we ever sink overwhelmed with distress, when life is so soon over, and death is so certain an entrance to happiness -- to glory?”-Helen.

4. Blind and cripple
Maybe Jane wouldn’t have returned if she wouldn’t have heard Edward calling her, because that was a call for help. When they first met, Mr. Rochester needed help but he was too proud to accept it. He considered Jane too inferior to him just because she was a woman so his pride and prejudice brought him to destruction. The whole story he was the man who couldn’t make compromises even for the woman he loved. He believed he’s strong, he’s someone important because he had some money in his pocket, but time passed, the money are gone and what he’s left with? Nothing. Even his proud burnt in that fire. He is blind, cripple and alone. So he finally realised that not good clothes, tasty food, parties with high people makes you happy but the persons with which you share love, ideas and moments. So this end has a lesson also. It want to say that men and women are equals, they both can be strong in hard situations, they both can be independent, they both have feelings, proud, ideas and a soul that can be broken easily. This end shows that woman should also have rights, a word to say when everybody is silent, and most of them they need to be loved and appreciated because they have feelings too. “I turned my lips to the hand that lay on my shoulder. I loved him very much - more than I could trust myself to say - more than words had power to express”- Jane.
*quotes from the novel ''Jane Eyre'', by Charlotte Bronte
Ani Mihaela, LRE II
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
arianamateoc
Dunker
Dunker


Data inscrierii: 17/Iun/2018
Mesaje: 17

MesajTrimis: 06/02/2019 17:27    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1. I think their relationship is unique and everyone can learn something from this, even them - Jane and Rochester. From their first meeting, we can see that Mr. Rochester wants to show Jane a powerful man, brave and strong, that doesn't need any help, especially from a woman. In my opinion, that was an essential ocazie regarding the evolution of their relationship; maybe if their meeting wasn't like that, they would have not ended up together. During the novel, as any other relationship, it has many ups and downs; at the beginning, Edward teases Jane, he is arrogant with her, he even told her that she bewitched is horse to make him fall from it. Despite all these things between them, they end up falling in love with each other. He loved him, even if he ostentatious courted another woman; and he loves her for her mind, for her intelligence (even if she is young), for who she truly is. I think they both learned from this journey together, but who learned mostly, was Mr. Rochester, because even if he knew that he loves her, he continued to do things that weren't advantageous for their evolution together. At least, in the end everything was put together. They learned a lot of things from each other, Jane learned that a good man can hide under many masks and you just have to look under it and be patient; on the other hand, Edward learned that you have to look at the inside of a person, not the outside, because this is what matters the most.


2. Jane was a person that has to go through a lot since she was a child, she endured a lot of things. In my opinion, the fact that Bronte made her rich was a reward for Jane; her journey was sprinkled with a lot of bad and good things, but she never gave up; she continued to be who she really was, she even left from the man whom she loved the most, just because she didn't wanted to become Edward's mistress. She ended up alone, hungry, but with her perseverance and her desire not to gave up she found two nuns and lived an ordinary life.
Therefore, the reason why Bronte felt the need to make her rich, was a prize because Jane finished her ''race'' in life very well.


3. As many of us think the same, so do I. The fire was the new path that was made for these two to find each other again. But, maybe it was not all just that. Mr. Rochester needed a lesson he had to learn from and to establish the social status between them. Even if the fire scene is a bad one, it leads to a good ending, where two lovers recover each other and learned from the situations they had been through.


4. In my opinion, I think that Edward blindness was the price he had to pay for making some bad decisions and for his personality that was not a nice one all the time. Bronte did that to him, because maybe, in that way, Mr. Rochester will value the life much more than before, but, especially, he will value more Jane, respect her more, show tenderness to her and they will be equal, finally.
_________________
Ariana Mateoc, LRE III
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Emanuela Negru
Dunker
Dunker
Emanuela Negru

Data inscrierii: 26/Mar/2018
Mesaje: 18

MesajTrimis: 07/02/2019 10:15    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1. I think Jane is a strong girl with a good heart. I really like her personality because even if she suffered a lot without nobody by her side she is powerful. She is an orphan girl but this thing didn’t stop her to follow her own dream. She took her destiny in her hand and fought for her life. The austere environment where she grow up didn’t affect her. Even if she was not love by her aunt, he became a women of character. Jane Eyre was a special child, she like to read books and to be close to people. She develop herself to what she wanted to be not in what society wanted from a woman. In that time were strict rules that a woman have to follow, but Jane is deosebit from all point of view. Firstly, she have a job, she is a teacher, secondly she say directly what she has in her mind. She like the idea of being free. “ I am not bird; and no net ensnares me : I am free human being with an independent will” The idea of freedom and liberty can distinguish her. He was some kind of rebel girl, who didn’t follow the rules that have to be followed. Even if she didn’t have anybody on the earth to help her, she think that she is the only one who can do something for her. “I care for myself. The more solitary, the more friendless, the more unsustained I am, the more I will respect myself” This girl understood the fact that on the earth there is none that can help you. You have to respect yourself in every situations. When everybody is by your side and also when you are alone. The clipă when her aunt shown her real feelings toward her, Jane Eyre became more conscious about the real world, that exist outside. Nobody in the house love her because she is too wild, and also she is not beautiful like her cousin, Georgiana. There is a ocazie in the book, at the beginning when she spilt. Her cousin, John Reed fight with her, more exactly he punched her, and she hit him and her aunt close her in the red room where her uncle died. After this her aunt is very cruel with her, and at some point in the book, she will tell her about her feelings “Do you think I am an automaton? A machine without feelings? and can bear to have my morsel of bread snatched from my lips, and my drop of living water dashed from my cup? Do you think because I am poor, obscure, plain and little, I am soulness and heartless? you think wrong!” She wanted to prove the fact that she is a person like everybody, she has feelings. The relationship between Jane Eyre and Mr. Rochester is very complicated. They have secrets and also the intervention of supernatural, their telepathy at some point in the end. Their first meeting was in a someway the prediction of the future, in the future he will need her help. I think Jane Eyre is the definition of the real woman “Women are supposed to be very calm generally; but women fell just as men feel; they need exercise for their faculties and a field for their efforts, as much as their brothers do; they suffer from too rigid a restraint, to absolute a stagnation, precisely as men would suffer; and it is narrow minded in their more privileged fellow-creatures to say that they ought to confine themselves to making puddings and knitting stocking, to playing on the piano and embrodering bags. It is thoughtless to condemn them, or laugh at them..” This quote shows us how a women have to be in that period and also the Jane Eyre opinion about the differences that were between men and women. Mr. Rochester observe Jane behavior and he like to talk with her because he love her intelligence, her spontaneous personality, her answers to his questions. Also, he studied her when she teach Adele Varnes, Mr. Rochester “child”, her mother, Celine abandoned her and he raised her and gave her an education. Also, Jane wanted to see Mr. Rochester more and more, she started to like him even if he was not a handsome man. Their love is strong and there is none to stop Mr. Rochester to break the rules and married with a girl with a different social rank, not even Blanche Ingram who is the representation of the woman for that period of time. She is after the money and social rank that Rochester have. She didn’t love him but she wanted his money. In the period when Miss Ingram Blanche is I the castle, Jane became a little bit jealous. She saw her the representation of beauty and intelligence. She thought that Mr. Rochester will marry her. Jane characterized her like a woman without feelings and kindness “She was very showy, but she was not genuine: she had a fine person, many brilliant attainments; but her mind was poor, her heart barren by nature: nothing bloomed spontaneously on that soil; no unforced natural fruit delighted by its freshness. She was not good; she was not original: she used to repeat sounding phrases from books: she never offered, nor had, an opinion of her own. She advocated a high tone of sentiment; but she did not know the sensations of sympathy and pity; tenderness and truth were not in her.” The apparition of Ingram at the castle represent the moment when Jane is conscious about her real feelings for Mr. Rochester. A representative moment for their relationship is when they are all together in the drawing room and then appear a gypsy woman. This is the moment when Mr. Rochester played a game with her. He wanted to know her heart and her feelings for him. The only person who recognize Mr. Rochester is Jane. In conclusion, their relationship is complicated but in the end they are together and happy with a child and Mr. Rochester can see. I think is amazing how they progress at the end of the novel. Jane is rich and MR. Rochester is blind and alone. They still love each other and they are happy.

2. I think that Charlotte Bronte fell the need to make Jane rich to show us the fact that a person with a good heart will be the same even if her social condition has changed. Jane Eyre is ready to help her relatives and she didn’t want all the money just for her. So, a good person is a better person when she have the opportunity to help people. But if we take a look at the moment when Jane had no money, she was a teacher, a good teacher, she worked hard to do something for the children from that village. But, in the moment when she have money, like all readers, I would expected from her to opened a school, or to make a contribution at Lowood school. After she received that inheritance from her uncles, she left the school and children.

3. The fire in the night when Jane left the castle killed Bertha, Rochester’s wife and also affected Rochester. After this event he was blind and cripple. Bertha, a crazy woman represent in an ironical way the fact that the society in that time can make a woman crazy. Also she the representation of the psycho character. There a several moments when she attend to kill someone. She tried to kill her husband, with fire and than she knife her brother, Richard Mason. The fire represent the end of a story, the crush between Jane and Mr. Rochester. It's like a stamp put on their life. The ruins, represent in a metaphorical way Rochester's soul after Jane's running.

4. After the fire incident, there is a change in Rochester attitude towards society and people. Before the fire he was a healthy man who love society and to travel. After he became blind he refuged in the woods, in an hidden place where he didn’t want to see anyone. I think this change shows us the fact that even the strong person in a day can be down, but what is important is the power inside you who can help you to go through the dark valley of fear. Also the power of love is stronger than anything because that power keep Mr. Rochester alive. After you were in the dark you esteem more the power of light. Sometimes you need to be down just to arise from the ashes and to be a better person. Before the incident, in the moment when Jane was preparing for the weeding, Mr.Rochester came to Jane and gave her clothes and jewelry for their weeding, but in the end we can see the fact that he is another man. He is not interested in such kind of things, all he want is the Jane’s love for him. I think, he is a character who changed himself at the end of the novel. HE see the God in his life, and he is full of joy even if he is blind. “I did wrong: I would have sullied my innocent flower—breathed guilt on its purity: the Omnipotent snatched it from me. I, in my stiff-necked rebellion, almost cursed the dispensation: instead of bending to the decree, I defied it. Divine justice pursued its course; disasters came thick on me: I was forced to pass through the valley of the shadow of death. HIS chastisements are mighty; and one smote me which has humbled me for ever. You know I was proud of my strength: but what is it now, when I must give it over to foreign guidance, as a child does its weakness? Of late, Jane—only—only of late—I began to see and acknowledge the hand of God in my doom.” At the end of the novel we see a reformed man who is more happy now then in his days of the glory when he has healthy. Also, he see everything that happened in his life like a divine justice for him. He is ready to accept the punishment for what he was done in his life. Also, I think the writer show us the fact that true love is for ever, no matter how you look, or what have you done. Love keep you alive when all things fall down “Love is patient and kind; love does not envy or boast; it is not arrogant or rude. It does not insist on its own way; it is not irritable or resentful; it does not rejoice at wrongdoing, but rejoices with the truth. Love bears all things, believes all things, hopes all things, endures all things.” I think this is the best description of love that I found in the Bible(1Corintheni 13). I think Charlotte Bronte made a revolutionary change with her book and let the people understand that love is blind sometimes and sometimes love give you power to fly. Also, I think in that time a man have to be strong, stronger than a woman and the fact that Mr. Rochester is blind and depend of Jane’s help is a revolutionary change that is inacceptable in society. I think, Charlotte Bronte shows the fact that woman are equal with man.
NEGRU EMANUELA, LRE II


Ultima modificare efectuata Emanuela Negru la 10/02/2019 01:35, modificat de 5 ori in total
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
PatakiRoxana17
Dunker
Dunker


Data inscrierii: 22/Mar/2018
Mesaje: 16

MesajTrimis: 07/02/2019 21:23    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1. When it comes to speak about relationships, it is a very complex subject because every relationship has its own splendor. Jane and Mr. Rochester's relationship is a completing one because one cannot live without the other and both have equal flaws. First of all, they are both, intelligent persons. With his intelligence, Mr. Rochester tries to analyse the way Jane thinks, more than her social status. Moreover, due to his experience gained during his life he could manipulate the young Jane by keeping secrets from her. As a result, when she found out about Bertha, left him. Jane was always an honest girl and this is why she could't accept Mr. Rochester's lies. In the end, when his wife have died, he came back to Jane, who was able to forgive him as long as the lies were purged.

2. I think that Charlotte Bronte wanted to give the readers a lesson by showing us how important it is to be a good soul and without any drop of selfishness. Yes, Jane became rich, but she was not arrogant or ungrateful, because when she found out about her Uncle's will that she inherited, she chose to share it with her NEWFOUND cousins. She could keep it only for herself because she was needy her entire life. I really appreciate her for the decision she made. She is totally a remarcable character in English literature.

3.We all know that the fire is a symbol for puryfication, abstersion. As a result, the fire lead to Bertha's suicidal which allowed Jane and Rochester to rediscover themselves. It is suggested the idea that what is meant to be, it will be. "He is not to them what he is to me," I thought: "he is not of their kind. I believe he is of mine;—I am sure he is,—I feel akin to him,—I understand the language of his countenance and movements: though rank and wealth sever us widely, I have something in my brain and heart, in my blood and nerves, that assimilates me mentally to him. […] I must, then, repeat continually that we are for ever sundered:—and yet, while I breathe and think I must love him."

4. I think that Bronte played the Mr. Rochester destiny's role by crippling and blinding him. Why? Because he have to see the fact that even if Jane is in a higher status than him, at that moment, she had not left him and she had not acted arrogant at all. She showed her equality towards him until the end, far from superiority. "If people were always kind and obedient to those who are cruel and unjust, the wicked people would have it all their own way: they would never feel afraid, and so they would never alter, but would grow worse and worse. When we are struck at without a reason, we should strike back again very hard; I am sure we should—so hard as to teach the person who struck us never to do it again. […] I must dislike those who, whatever I do to please them, persist in disliking me; I must resist those who punish me unjustly. It is as normal as that I should love those who show me affection, or submit to punishment when I feel it is deserved."
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
ceuca.dorinela17
Dunker
Dunker


Data inscrierii: 28/Mar/2018
Mesaje: 16

MesajTrimis: 08/02/2019 15:29    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1 The relationship between Jane Eyre and Rochester evolves very much. Initially she went at Rochester`s house as a governess but after several episodes things were completely changed. Their first meeting was a real surprise for everyone. She went hastily to send a letter but in her way Rochester appear on his horse and in that moment he fell off the horse and Jane was there to help him. He was surprise in the clipă when he saw Jane again because he comes home especially for meeting her. He was surprise by her way to talk and her mind. People could not think of their alleged relationship because their social status was different. She was only an orphan, a poor girl and he was a rich man who could buy ‘everything’. They fall in love even there was a huge difference between they as a status but also was a difference of age. This novel is a continuous surprise because Jane inherited a lot of money and her destiny is going to be change. Their relationship stopped for a moment because they were going to married but Jane found out that Rochester has a secret wife which is kept in a room. Here comes out her dignity because she could not accept to be married with a man who has already a wife. She preferred to leave far away from him and from that mysterious house. She became an independent woman and her character it has to be admired because she did not accept to became ‘another from Rochester`s mistress’

2 Maybe Charlotte Bronte wanted to give color to this novel and make Jane Eyre a rich woman and independent. She wanted to change the Jane`s status and also her destiny for more creativity and she create another image of society. Even she was poor or rich she did not accepted the Rochester`s proposal and she kept her dignity as woman. I can say that she is different from this point of view and the novel has a real success because of this character.

3 From my point of view, the fire solved many things, for example the fire prevented Jane from living in a lie, because Rochester did not want to tell this secret very soon and they would be married if that man did not tell the truth about Rochester`s situation.

4 I think Charlotte Bronte decided to cripple and blind Rochester as a punishment for his mistakes. He was an arrogant man and uses to treat the people with superiority and also he lied the women about his secret wife. I think he has no excuse for what he did because it is a huge step to want married with someone but that person knows nothing about this situation, for example Jane. It proves your character and the way you decide to live. Also Jane proves once again her kindness because after all of these she decided to go to him.

Ceuca Dorinela LRE II
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
ioanaosan2017
Dunker
Dunker


Data inscrierii: 22/Mar/2018
Mesaje: 15
Localitate: Mocira

MesajTrimis: 09/02/2019 00:46    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1.In my opinion, their relationship is a classic one. Mr. Rochester has the arrogant and supreme attitude at first and he's always upside down. He behaves badly with Jane, but eventually things take an unexpected turn, he falls in love with her. Although sometimes a person tends to be arrogant when they can not express their feelings. Both can not live without one another. Mr.Rochester always feels the need to communicate with Jane, no matter what. And she has her visual atingere with him throughout her conversations. I personally seemed funny to some of them. Every time he ends the conversation with Jane, and lets her return to her room, she suddenly remembered having something to say to her. And he called her back. An opportune ocazie they are staying with is when Mr. Mason is injured by his wife, and Jane helps him clear his blood until he gets to the doctor. Although their wedding has not happened because of Bertha, but she still realizes how much she loves it and goes back to him.


2.Jane is the orphan girlfriend, without wealth, who was terrorized by her aunt and hopes for a better status through freedom. I think the author wanted to show the world as an orphan, who has no rich status, can become rich. Well for Jane, the freedom of being afraid to feel, to have no pressure on you, the freedom to love and to be loved means wealth. That is why Mr. Rochester, even if he was wealthy, had a tremendous wealth, he lacked the true "love" treasure, and it was that he was a jerk. And that it does not matter the rank as long as we are equal. Additionally, Charlotte Bonte did not make Jane a bitter orphan, but she also gave her some important qualities such as the beauty of both body and soul, intelligence and courage to overcome any situation


3.Fire is usually a purifying element, even if it has the power to destroy everything in the way. The fever comes in two hypostases here, when Mr. Rochester's bedroom burns and the one at the end of the story. The first fire accident occurs because of his wife who is hidden on the third floor of the house. Probably his wife does not support the idea that there is still a woman in the house, so she left the candle in front of Jane's door. Jane is the first to observe the fire coming from Mr. Rochester's room. It does not sit down and help him. I think that's the first part in which both begin to feel something for the other. Probably Mr. Rochester understands by this event that Jane can be with him for good and hard times. And the fire at the end of the story is probably the result of a carm, because at first he considered Jane inferior to him because he had no fortune and was an orphan. The fire leaves Mr. Rochester homeless and without eyes, leaving him in the impost of feeling without judging.
_________________
Osan Ioana Paula, CUNBM Litere LRE III
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat Trimite un mesaj
Marius Mesaros
Dunker
Dunker


Data inscrierii: 16/Mar/2018
Mesaje: 19

MesajTrimis: 09/02/2019 19:34    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1. Their relationship is anticipated by Bronte in the scene where they meet accidentally on a field near the house. Their first encounter is emblematic for their future relationship, in the sense that as their first encounter was tense, so their relationship will be. Their common stubbornness and strong personality are some of the reasons for the complicated relationship that they will develop. This first encounter also show us a Mr. Rochester apparently friendly, reaching his hand for the help of a simple girl, like Jane, an attitude that will turn around in the their next encounters.

At the end of their dramatic episodes I think they learned and felt that they were matched souls recognizing that they were somehow built for each other, and maybe that with great costs, eventually love wins.

2. The need of Bronte to make Jane and in a way herself rich, is maybe because she sensed the need to compensate and change the misfortune and maybe in the same time to show us, the readers, the philanthropic side of her and also her activist side, in the sense of her active involving in education and active change in schools at that time, herself being marked by the experiences at the Lowood School.

3. The burning of the Rochester`s house could be the symbol of rebirth, of a new beginning, in the sense of the mythological Phoenix bird. With fire, the dark past of the house and Mr. Rochester is cleaned.

4. The punishment brought upon Mr. Rochester, by blinding him, is maybe the need of Bronte to show to the reader the price that him had to pay in order to redeem from his past, to clean it from lies and dark. In another way, this punishment could show us the feminist side of Bronte, by punishing a man in this cruel mode.

Marius Mesaros - LRE II


Ultima modificare efectuata de catre Marius Mesaros la 11/02/2019 10:18, modificat de 1 data in total
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Sabadis Andreea
Dunker
Dunker


Data inscrierii: 25/Mar/2018
Mesaje: 17

MesajTrimis: 10/02/2019 03:04    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1. Firstly I must mention that Jane Eyre is one of the most interesting novels that I have ever read. The relationship between Jane and Rocheter shows us that in love it doesn't counts the age, goods, inteligence. Jane loved Rochester even he is older than her, even she is more sensitive than him. In love doesn't counts the social position, fortune, age, money. In the end of the novel they learned that they are one for another. Their relationship did not seem to have a future,especially after the ocazie from the churc, when Jane found that Rochester was married and his wife is alive. But all the attempts they have made their relation to be strong.
2.Charlotte Bonte feel the need to make Jane rich because she deserve a beautiful live now when Jane is an adult, if she was an orphan and had a cruel childhood. Jane isn't rich, she is kind-hearted, smart, good governes, good teacher, she liked to help other people. She needs a man who fills her. She didn't have money, but Rochester have.
3.The fire made that their relationship to be possible. If the Thornfield Hall would not have caught fire, the first wife of Rochester woudn't dead and Rochester couldn't marry with Jane.The fire made Rochester blind but this wasn't an obstacle for the relationschip between Jane and Rochster. The author need to cripple and blind Mr. Rochester because in this way Jane feel equal with Rocester, even superior.

SABADIS ANDREEA LRE II
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Alexandra Noje 17
Plunger
Plunger
Alexandra Noje 17

Data inscrierii: 14/Mar/2018
Mesaje: 27
Localitate: Satu Mare

MesajTrimis: 10/02/2019 08:44    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

Answers from DANCIU ALEXANDRA-NICOLETA, LRE II:

1) I think that, first of all, Jane and Mr. Rochester’s relationship can be described as a relationship which passed the hard test of life. Despite the difference in years between them, I think that both Jane and Edward were at a new beginning in their lives when they met. After two more years spent at Lowood as a teacher, Jane decided it's time for her to make a change. So she accepted a post of governess at Thornfield. After some failed relationships with other women: Bertha Mason (Rochester’s clandestine wife) and Celine Varens (a French opera dancer with whom Rochester had an affair), Edward was looking for a new relationship. This was the clipă when life brought them together. Their first encounter was rather unusual and the fact that Edward needed Jane’s help was like a foreboding. I think that from the very beginning, Bronte established the statute of each of them in their relationship. The good-hearted girl proved to be the a kind person, eager to help a stranger in need and this was the ocazie when Eduard observed for the first time her noble soul. His reaction was the reaction of a powerful, arrogant and independent man with authority and an important position in the society. These first impressions were confirmed after they had started to know each other better. Her attitude was the same after she found out that he was her master. Even if she was a poor girl, she was an educated person with a strong personality and strong principles. The fact that she has had an unhappy childhood determined her to change her future. The lack of love, support and compassion which marked her first years of life built a woman of character, able to take the good decisions and make the right choices. When she fell in love with Edward, she was aware of the impediments she had and she tried to concentrate on her strict principles: “He sees nothing attractive in me; not even youth—only a few useful mental points…Oh, you need not be jealous!...”. Edward saw the beauty of her mind and realized that in this respect they were equally. For him, her rank in the society was not important because he was the man able to fall in love with the woman’s soul and with her mind. Jane knew to listen and could understand that Edward’s feeling for her were true. They loved each other with a pure love. The incident that took place on their wedding day and its consequences proved their true love and strong connection between them. He did his best to find her and she did her best to hide from him, but the Universe was a partaker at their love. The intervention of supernatural was a sign of the Universe which also did his best to save their love. I think that in the final, they learned that love is above all and they learned to appreciate one another above the superficial values of the society in which they lived.

2) I think Charlotte Bronte feels the need to make Jane rich to prove one more time her noble soul and strong principle by which Jane guided her life. Living in a society in which the money made the difference between „low” and „high”, Jane broke the rule and nullified the money’s value.
Maybe Bronte made Jane rich when she was away of Edward to show her that money means nothing when you need love so as to understand Edward’s situation and to feel by her own that soul poverty can’t be enriched with money, but with love. I think that the moment when she became the only heir of the fabulous amount of money was the moment she was the poorest in her entire life: she had no one to love and protect her. Through her inheritance, she discovered her only relatives and she had the pleasant surprise to see that they were even her rescuers. They had told Jane one day about the quarrel between their father and their rich uncle. This common uncle was the only chance of the three brothers for a better life. However, he did’t care about them. One more time, Jane could see that money cannot warm your heart. Jane shared equally the money with her cousins, proving that a truly noble soul cannot be destroyed by money. I think this is a lesson: lack of money does not mean poverty, as their possession does not mean wealth. If you have a noble soul, the money does not change you.

3) Through fire, Jane and Mr. Rochester’ relationship became possible. The fire solved the problem of Bertha Mason’ s existence. I think Bertha was a product of the society and her tragic destiny was representative for women who accepted and assumed the position imposed by the society. Rochester’s clandestine wife set the manor ablaze which killed her and destroyed the Thornfield manor. But the fire caused another problem. In his attempts to save Bertha, after saving his servants, Edward lost a hand and blinded himself.

4) I think Bronte feels the need to cripple and blind Mr. Rochester just to prove the power of love and faith which can save us. The powerful and independent man became cripple and blind, but Mr. Rochester’s weakness was more visible in his attitude about the world. He refuged in the most hidden place possible, in the woods, far from the world and the entire society. The only purpose of his life was to wait Jane. The hope kept him alive.
Jane was the devoted woman who always wanted to be useful and she was given the chance. The humble man was dependent on her help and her love, and she was ready to be in his service. Jane loved the inside beauty of Edward more than ever and Edward learned that to see the inside beauty he didn’t need eyes. I think Bronte’s reason was to made Edward reach other level of spiritual life and I think that from the beginning of their relationship, each of them has gone through a necessary metamorphosis process to take their love to the supreme level.
_________________
Alexandra Noje, LRE III, CUNBM
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat Trimite un mesaj
Marius Mesaros
Dunker
Dunker


Data inscrierii: 16/Mar/2018
Mesaje: 19

MesajTrimis: 10/02/2019 13:52    Titlul subiectului: Jane Eyre - Ionut Chereji`s answer Raspunde cu citat (quote)

Jane Eyre - Ionut Chereji`s answer

1. Personally I see that the relationship between Jane and Rochester is getting together over time, and he always looks for her, for her advices and presence, Jane managing to hide her stronger emotions for him. The first meeting between the two will impress Jane despite the difficult nature of Mr. Rochester. Jane despite her feelings for him, she doesn't consider herself good enough to love, she don't even know what love means while Rochester loves her secretly. When Rochester calls her, she answers him softly, listens to him, supports, speaks to him with sincerity, hiding that part that is in love with him. We have to mention that this love between this two is a true, sensible, sincerely love which never get down or ,,burned" with the House of Mr. Rochester, she will always have feelings for him despite that the fate will separate them.

2. Charllote Brontë has built a strong, intelligent and independent character but what was missing was money which appear not after long time. In my opinion Brontë wanted to see Jane's evolution, if the money or wealth she has now is going to affect her decisions, thinking, and behavior in some way and it seems that no, Jane continues to remain as it used to be, Jane Eyre is honest! With all the people around her but especially with herself, like this is how she grows, this was her mentality, she had a nightmare childhood with a terrible aunt. I think I'm starting to like more and more Jane, if tomorrow I meet Jane I would ask if she wants to be my girlfriend 😅

3. Ohh… the fire…I think we needed a little drama, right?
Meanwhile Rochester became a helpless man, his crazy wife burned the mansion and commits suicide. Rochester survived but still as powerful in love with Jane as she is. In my opinion we (the readers), we all wanted to happen this, like the ,,good" always wins and Rochester married Jane and what I want to point out is that only in marriage, Jane can fully enjoy the love of Mr. Rochester.


Ionut Chereji - LRE II
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Afiseaza mesajele pentru a le previzualiza:   
Acest forum este inchis, nu se pot scrie, crea, raspunde sau modifica subiecte   Acest subiect este inchis, nu se pot crea sau raspunde la mesaje    Pagina de start a forumului EngLit -> 2.1 Romanticism & Victorian Age 2018-2019 Ora este GMT + 2 ore
Pagina 1 din 1

 
Mergi direct la:  
Nu puteti crea un subiect nou in acest forum
Nu puteti raspunde in subiectele acestui forum
Nu puteti modifica mesajele proprii din acest forum
Nu puteti sterge mesajele proprii din acest forum
Nu puteti vota in chestionarele din acest forum


Powered by phpBB © 2001 phpBB Group
trevorj :: theme by ~// TreVoR \\~
Fa-ti si tu propriul forum GRATUIT, pe www.myforum.ro