 |
EngLit Seminar extension for the students in English Literature at CUNBM
|
| Subiectul anterior :: Subiectul urmator |
| Autor |
Mesaj |
Mariana Oros Diver

Data inscrierii: 14/Dec/2015 Mesaje: 54
|
Trimis: 23/01/2017 19:15 Titlul subiectului: Jane Eyre, by Charlotte Bronte |
|
|
1. Why did Charlotte Bronte need to mutilate and ruin Rochester in order to make him acceptable by Jane?
From my point of view, Charlotte Bronte needs to mutilate and ruin Rochester for two reasons; on the one hand, it could be seen as a proof of Jane’s true love for Rochester, because in this way we can see Jane’s true love for Rochester, despite his physical appearance and his disease, the fact that he is blind, after the fire accident, and also he lost everything, from the house to the smallest thing, she is still near him and take care of him. On the other hand, Charlotte Bronte's need to ruin Rochester could be from the feminist issue; we know that the woman's image in the Victorian period was a poor one, and the woman condition in society was low, and I think that is why the author ruin Rochester from the important points of views, financially, materially and socially through his aspect, to give the woman, to Jane, a kind of superiority in front of men, of Rochester. We must not forget that now Jane is an independent woman, even from a financial aspect, and she could represent the woman's voice that wanted to be seen in society as the men are seen. For me, the fact that Rochester is ruined, and Jane as a feminist representative is the one who helped him, suggests a rebellion from the female side, a kind of act of revenge for the way that woman was seen in that period. What do you think about that?
2. Do you think the final is exaggerated or the solution ruins the realism of the novel?
From my point of view, it is not just the final ruins the realism of the novel, there are also other reasons that could ruin the realism of the novel, for instance, when Jane leaves Rochester’s house and she arrives in a village, at the first door she knocked on for help, she found that it was the house of her lost cousins, I think this episode is too exaggerated for the realism of the novel and even the moment when she received the heritage, when everything seemed lost for her, she received a heritage that solved all her problems. In my opinion, those episodes and the final are exaggerated and could ruin the realism of the novel; because those solving problems seem to be fairy tales.
Ultima modificare efectuata de catre Mariana Oros la 23/01/2017 22:45, modificat de 1 data in total |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Selena Acqui Plunger

Data inscrierii: 08/Noi/2016 Mesaje: 33
|
Trimis: 23/01/2017 21:01 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
1. As you mention the woman’s condition in the Victorian Era, I think Charlotte actually tries to invoke through Jane her soul’s deepest secrets and desires regarding the evolution of life. As far as marriage is concerned during this period, the matrimonial links were created on interest, and thus, it was nothing related to love. I think that the author was disgusted by this kind of union, and therefore, she uses Rochester’s mutilation as a detail through which, if we read between the lines, she created the idealized concept of love to which she herself aimed. The author introduces her own way of understanding love, which is one representing the idea that two people who love each other will stick together no matter what. Charlotte was against the conformity to which the bourgeois women’s view was, regarding marriage. The author didn’t want two people to be together as a result of a deal, but because of the union of their hearts, and this is what she expresses through Jane Eyre. She actually creates a counterpart to Jane’s aspirations regarding love, and this is Blanche Ingram, who is the aristocratic and shallow Victorian woman, having as target the “acquisition” of a prestigious partner. Moreover, from my personal point of view, Charlotte hated how the family values were represented, and did not agree with the woman’s conventional figure dictated by social mentality. This is why she created Jane’s genuine pattern during a time when man’s superiority was not questionable.
2. Keeping in mind the structure of the realist novel, we might consider that Charlotte’s novel is, in some situations, far from how things should actually evolve in reality (as you mentioned: when she finds her lost cousins, when she receives an unexpected inheritance). Despite all these, I think this is a novel through which she actually wanted to revive an inner story upon her life. From my own point of view, I think that “Jane Eyre” is, to some extent, her autobiography, but the rest of the story represents the reality Charlotte had wished to live. She wanted to be loved, desired to love, to experience the conflict between passion and reason, to annihilate fake morality, things we encounter in Jane’s personality. No wonder she exaggerated things, and ruined the realism of the novel; she could not conceive only the elements which built up realism. This is why I think that, she actually wished to live a fairy tale herself, and as a result, she mingled misterios elements with concret ones, and created the lost tale of an independent female. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Todorean Iuliana Plunger

Data inscrierii: 24/Oct/2015 Mesaje: 38 Localitate: Targu Lapus
|
Trimis: 23/01/2017 22:48 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
1. Why did Charlotte Bronte need to mutilate and ruin Rochester in order to make him acceptable by Jane?
I think that Bronte mutilate and ruin Rochester as a punishment.He was not a bad owner and his servants cared about him, but he had that thing that makes the others feels like he has an enormous power in his hands and could do whatever he wants. The only one who was not affected was Jane. They did met each other earlier in the novel when Rochester felt in the forest and Jane helped him, but he wanted like that scene to be forgotten. He did not accepted that he was helped by somebody else. Charlotte mutilate and ruin Rochester because she wanted to show us that even those who have power can ending like Rochester and they will have to please for help and somebody like Jane who was poor at the beginning and now had more money can be the helper. Bronte gives Jane superiority and makes the man helpless.
2. Do you think the final is exaggerated or the solution ruins the realism of the novel?
I think that Bronte has a lot of exaggerated solutions in the novel. The first part of the novel is surely realistic but on the moment Jane left Rochester in the novel appears some ’’intruders’’ which no longer gives us the faith that the novel is complete build in a realistic way. I think that Bronte’s first wish was to make a realistic novel , but there interfere her own wishes and her own expectations from life. She never had been married, she was living somewhere in the countryside and she did not was a popular person. Bronte through Jane lives another life. She makes Jane to succeed because she could not succeed in her life. I do not think that Rochester mutilation belongs to fairy tail because accidents like this one can happen all the time. The thing that make us to think about is how does Jane found that Rochester had problems. I think that that ’’signal’’ belongs to fairy tails. _________________ Iulia |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Ananie Sorina Dunker

Data inscrierii: 01/Noi/2015 Mesaje: 18
|
Trimis: 24/01/2017 16:59 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
Koposciuc Bianca
Perhaps Bronte wanted to show that, in a society in which men hold power, and women are considered inferior beings, roles can change: a man can reach to depend totally on a woman (an unusual fact). Also, she probably wanted to prove that women are not as helpless as the society thinks. But I think that, unwittingly, she has just lifted the man on a pedestal. She clearly showed that a man can depend on a woman only if he is blind, handicapped, without any source of income, homeless, while a woman depends on man by its very nature; and this cannot be changed except through force of circumstances. So, my opinion is that Bronte played with Rochester's fate just to humiliate him, and she did this because of her own spiritual unfulfillment, as a woman, who is dissatisfied with her own condition.
I think that the final is exaggerated and the realism of the novel ruined. Why? Because realism should reflect reality, and what has happened in this novel does not mean reality. All events that occurred were not just a coincidence, but a quirk of the author, as I said earlier. The end of the novel belongs to a fairy tail, not to realism. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
caiadiana Dunker

Data inscrierii: 04/Noi/2015 Mesaje: 12
|
Trimis: 24/01/2017 21:48 Titlul subiectului: Jane Eyre |
|
|
Muresan Catalina Simona
1.Why did Charlotte Bronte need to mutilate and ruin Rochester in order to make him acceptable by Jane?
In my opinion,Charlotte Bronte need to mutilate and ruin Rochester for many reasons:on the one hand,thi action could be seen as a affective reason,in fact Jane truly loves Rochester despite his appearance of a bad person,filled by indifference and pride,when he had the accident and became blind and pennyless,she keeps her feelings,she were with him over this tragedy.On the other hand,the writer ruins Rochester for a feminist reason,beacause in the Victorian ages the woman condition in society was lowest than the condition of the man.The tragedy of Rochester when he lost his financially and social status,the woman became superior to him,even in her soul she believed that they were equal,united by the love.This act of ruined the man is a manifestation wich brings the woman of that times beyond the social order,but not beyond the human feelings. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
caiadiana Dunker

Data inscrierii: 04/Noi/2015 Mesaje: 12
|
Trimis: 24/01/2017 21:54 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
Muresan Catalina Simona
2.I think that the final is not exaggerated and does not ruin the realism of the novel because the idea of the heritage that Jane received when everything was lost for her,means a blessing for her,after all the years when she had a hard existence,without luck ,even she was an independent woman.The life of someone can beat the "movie",so the end of the novel is realistic by the changes of Jane's destiny by what she really worths. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
caiadiana Dunker

Data inscrierii: 04/Noi/2015 Mesaje: 12
|
Trimis: 24/01/2017 23:01 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
1).Why did Charlotte Bronte need to mutilate and ruin Rochester in order to make him acceptable by Jane?
I think that Charlotte Bronte needed to mutilate and ruin Rochester because Fairfax writes to Jane while she is at the Reeds, informing her that the house party has ended and that Rochester has gone to London to buy a new carriage, supposedly in anticipation of his upcoming marriage to Blanche.Then,comes the part where she thinks that if she will remain with him.After all,in this chapter Jane is described as a creature,so I think,the reason why she wants to ruin Rochester,again,is an affective reason
2).Do you think the final is exaggerated or the solution ruins the realism of the novel?
Personally,I think that the final is exaggerated.Even if this novel is a happy-ending Victorian story,I don't think that all the characters should be rewarding to Jane.One exemple is that,the materialism and sensuality,of an English life that Adele lives,is not associated with foreign womens.Because,a foreign woman is the one one who doesn't live a life like she did.After all,the final is a little too exagerated,but I liked the most that Rochester and Jane are reunited like it says:"no woman was ever nearer to her mate than I am: ever more absolutely bone of his bone and flesh of his flesh". |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Butean Dana Plunger

Data inscrierii: 27/Oct/2015 Mesaje: 49 Localitate: Lapus
|
Trimis: 25/01/2017 14:03 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
Ilies Adriana Iulia.
1. I think that Bronte needs to mutilate him physical, because Jane was already "mutilate"sentimantaly by Rochester, when he didn't tell her that he is married with Bertha. I think that Bronte did this because want to make them equal. Jane suffered very much because of Rochester's actions, and in this way he paid for her suffering.
2. I don't think that the final is exagerated, or that the solution ruins the realism of the novel. I think that Bronte wanted to give Jane a happy end and a better life. Because of this Jane finds her cousins and return to Rochester. This final can be a new beginning, more happyand a better life for the poor orfan girl. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Butean Dana Plunger

Data inscrierii: 27/Oct/2015 Mesaje: 49 Localitate: Lapus
|
Trimis: 25/01/2017 14:14 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
1. Why did Charlotte Bronte need to mutilate and ruin Rochester in order to make him acceptable by Jane?
Therefore Jane will know what is love, but at the some time, sadness an suffering. Rochester proposes to marry with Jane, but is separated from it beacuse still find that Rochester is married with Bertha so Jane runs away from home.
So because of this, Jane him mutilated physically and not mentally or sentimental.
2. Do you think the final is exaggerated or the solution ruins the realism of the novel?
I think the end of the novel is not exaggerated because Jane returns to his aunt's house and reviews his cousins and from love for Rochester returns to him and not leave. This is a gesture of true love. so the ending is a happy one despite the unpleasant events of the two exponents. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
|
|
Nu puteti crea un subiect nou in acest forum Nu puteti raspunde in subiectele acestui forum Nu puteti modifica mesajele proprii din acest forum Nu puteti sterge mesajele proprii din acest forum Nu puteti vota in chestionarele din acest forum
|
|