 |
EngLit Seminar extension for the students in English Literature at CUNBM
|
| Subiectul anterior :: Subiectul urmator |
| Autor |
Mesaj |
luca.lorena17 Dunker


Data inscrierii: 03/Apr/2018 Mesaje: 20
|
Trimis: 15/12/2018 21:37 Titlul subiectului: Great Expectations |
|
|
1. Choose a character and characterize her/him, also add your opinion about that character.
2. How do you think it would have been Pip's life if he wouldn’t go to London?
3. Estella is beautiful, but cold-hearted. Why do you think Pip didn’t give up the love he felt for her?
4. The end of the novel can be interpreted in different ways. Imagine another final for "Great Expectations".
 _________________ Luca Andreea Lorena, CUNBM, LRE III |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
luca.lorena17 Dunker


Data inscrierii: 03/Apr/2018 Mesaje: 20
|
Trimis: 18/12/2018 20:21 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
1. Although she is a controversial character, I liked very much Miss Havisham. I believe that I liked her because I’ve put myself in her place, I felt her pain and tried to understand her; I mean, let’s be honest how many girls would be happy if they were deserted on their wedding day? If I were Miss Havisham, I would have forced myself to move on from the past and see the beauty of life, although I knew this would be hard at first because it is difficult to start over after a heartbreak, but I’m sure that I could not live in isolation my whole life.
Miss Havisham is the first person who brought together Pip and Estella (although she takes delight in the fact that Pip likes her daughter and she encourages Estella to be malicious with him: “Love her, love her, lover her! If she favours you, love her. If she wounds you, love her. If she tears your heart to pieces - and as it gets older and stronger, it will tear deeper - love her, love her, love her!”).
In the novel, her name is mentioned for the first time in Chapter VII, when Mrs. Gargery and Uncle Pumblechook talk about the fact that a rich bachelorette wants Pip to go and play with her ward (“She wants this boy to go and play there.”). Also, in Chapter VII, the main character made her a little characterization (“an immensely rich and grim lady…who led a life of seclusion”) and describes the place where she lives (“who lived in a large and dismal house barricaded against robbers”).
She lives her life as if time stopped from the identic clipă at which she was jilted by her fiancé (“She was dressed in rich materials - satins, and lace, and silks - all of white. Her shoes were white. And she had a long white veil dependent from her hair, and she had bridal flowers in her hair, but her hair was white. Some bright jewels sparkled on her neck and on her hands, and some other jewels lay sparkling on the table”). Miss Havisham's awkward and obsessive behaviour in stopping time in the ocazie of the greatest crisis of her life destroys her gradually (“There was a clock in the outer wall of this house. Like the clock in Miss Havisham's room, and like Miss Havisham's watch, it had stopped at twenty minutes to nine.”); her pain and suffering are enormous, she can’t get over them and remain stuck in the past forever.
She is characterized throughout the novel as a lifeless creature who refuses to grow, to come to light and be reborn from her ashes like a Phoenix (“a skeleton in the ashes of a rich dress”, “Now, waxwork and skeleton seemed to have dark eyes”, “she had the appearance of having dropped, body and soul, within and without, under the weight of a crushing blow”, “the faded spectre in the chair by the dressing-table glass”).
She’s blinded by hate and motivated by her desire “to wreak revenge on all the man sex”, that’s why she educated Estella to be proud, arrogant, because she wants her to break men’s hearts in the most ruthless way possible, making them fall in love without receiving the same love back. Cruel-hearted, egocentric and manipulative woman (because she uses Estella as a weapon against men; Miss Havisham: “Let me see you play cards with this boy”/ Estella: “With this boy? Why, he is a common laboring boy”/ Miss Havisham: “Well? You can break his heart”), can buy everything she wants, but she’s impoverished spiritually because without love, money is not worth having. That’s why the wealthy spinster, Miss Havisham, made herself a prisoner of her own life.
The bachelorette is incapable of empathy until near the end of the novel in Chapter 49 when she finally able to understand the harm she caused because the hatred she had on men, on both Estella and Pip. She prays for Pip’s mercy and forgiveness and she receives it after her death. (“O!" she cried, despairingly. "What have I done! What have I done!”; “But as she grew, and promised to be very beautiful, I gradually did worse, and with my praises, and with my jewels, and with my teachings, and with this figure of myself always before her a warning to back and point my lessons, I stole her heart away and put ice in its place.”).
2. I consider that the main character would have been unhappy with his life because Pip was a man that all through his young life he tried to overcome his condition because he didn't like neither his social status, nor the place where he lived with his sister and her husband. He was dissatisfied with the life he had and didn’t want to become a poor blacksmith like Joe, his brother-in-law, who is somehow representing the life Pip wanted to escape. If Mr. Jaggers had not been sent by Magwitch to offer Pip an inheritance: the trip to London wouldn’t have took place, the main character would not have become a gentleman, and maybe he would never met Estella again.
3. I think that a factor that made him love her unconditionally even if she behaved horrible and scornful with him is because in his mind the benefactor who offered him the heritage was Miss Havisham. He believed that Miss Havisham has offered that fortune just to help him reach the heart of her ward by aiding him to become a gentleman. This thought gave him the hope that one day he will marry Estella. I can’t deny the fact that her beauty marked him, but her character lacks because she was formed as a puppet of Miss Havisham; Estella couldn’t love (“You must know," said Estella, condescending to me as a brilliant and beautiful woman might, "that I have no heart - if that has anything to do with my memory.” - Chapter 29) and Pip loved too much (“Estella," said I, turning to her now, and trying to command my trembling voice, "you know I love you. You know that I have loved you long and dearly.” / “Out of my thoughts! You are part of my existence, part of myself. You have been in every line I have ever read, since I first came here, the rough common boy whose poor heart you wounded even then. You have been in every prospect I have ever seen since - on the river, on the sails of the ships, on the marshes, in the clouds, in the light, in the darkness, in the wind, in the woods, in the sea, in the streets. You have been the embodiment of every graceful fancy that my mind has ever become acquainted with.” – Chapter 44).
4. After Magwitch's death, Pip remains in London and thanks to his intelligence he becomes Mr. Jaggers's assistant. He earns a lot of money and buys his own home in the capital, where he also brings Joe and Biddy. About a few months later, Pip meets Estella on a street near his house and greets her, but not as enthusiastic as before. At home he realizes that the love he feels for her will never disappear; at the door someone knocks, Pip opens and sees Estella, she asks him to have a discussion. Estella confesses that she realized that her behavior was very malicious, and begs him to forgive her. Pip appreciates her sincerity, and along with her, he makes a trip to Miss Havisham's old house. The place has a great significance for each of them, this being the moment when both of them realize that destiny brought them together, both then (in the childhood) and in that moment. The novel ends with the image of the two standing on a bench, embraced, just after they have forgave each other mistakes and have realized that they are happier together. _________________ Luca Andreea Lorena, CUNBM, LRE III
Ultima modificare efectuata luca.lorena17 la 07/02/2019 10:33, modificat de 4 ori in total |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
arianamateoc Dunker

Data inscrierii: 17/Iun/2018 Mesaje: 17
|
Trimis: 05/01/2019 14:51 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
1. My choice is Estella. We all know that her character is very complex and her personality makes us ask some questions about her and her actions also. She is the adoptive daughter of Miss Havisham and raised by her, but her birthmother is Molly. The text shows us that she doesn't love Pip, but her actions represents the opposite. She doesn't want to break Pip's heart, as she does with the others, like her adoptive mother teached her (to be heartless, arrogant and to break men hearts). Maybe an explanation for this could be the fact that, even though she doesn't disclaim, she is in love with Pip. In my opinion, Estella loves Pip, but she is not able to know and discover her own feelings, because of Miss Havisham and what she teached Estella. Estella only knows what Havisham tells her and what she must do with a man feelings, and she is not told about love and what it feels like.
2. Of course, if this wouldn't happened, the story wouldn't exists, or it would be an unsuccessful one. I think Pip's life would have been unhappy and live a life he didn;t wanted. Also, Pip is a character that wants to evolve and be a better part of him, and, in my opinion, if he hadn't had the opportunity to go to London, he would have find one.
3. I think that Pip, somewhere, felt, even if it was little, that Estella loves him, or cares about him. He knows what Miss Havisham teached Estella, and this may be a reason he didn't gave up. He makes some attempts (pathetical) to awake some feelings in Estella, but that does nothing but make her even more distant. _________________ Ariana Mateoc, LRE III |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Alexandra Noje 17 Plunger


Data inscrierii: 14/Mar/2018 Mesaje: 27 Localitate: Satu Mare
|
Trimis: 06/02/2019 13:54 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
1. My choice is the convict, Abel Magwitch. I have chosen to talk about this character because it is a controversial one. Maybe some of us despise him for his actions, but there are some who actually appreciate him. This character is introduced in the plot by the scene in which he scared little Pip in the cemetery: “Hold your noise! Keep still, you little devil, or I’ll cut your throat!”. Pip does what he is (violently) asked to, and by doing this, he won the gratitude of “The Convict”. In the beginning, this character is presented as a intimidating and harmful man. Many years later, when Pip was in London was visited by him: “I could not recall a single feature, but I knew him! If the wind and the rain had driven away the intervening years, had scattered all the intervening objects, had swept us to the churchyard where we first stood face to face on such different levels, I could not have known my convict more distinctly than I knew him now as he sat in the chair before the fire.” At that moment, Abel justifies his actions: “You acted noble, my boy,” said he. “Noble, Pip! And I have never forgot it!”. Then, he confesses: “Yes, Pip, dear boy, I’ve made a gentleman on you! It’s me wot has done it! I swore that time, sure as ever I earned a guinea, that guinea should go to you. I swore arterwards, sure as ever I spec’lated and got rich, you should get rich. I lived rough, that you should live smooth; I worked hard, that you should be above work. What odds, dear boy? Do I tell it, fur you to feel a obligation? Not a bit. I tell it, fur you to know as that there hunted dunghill dog wot you kep life in, got his head so high that he could make a gentleman—and, Pip, you’re him!” After this confession, I realized that this character is way more than a criminal that is in a constant run to stay alive and not be caught. I think that the fact that he had precarious conditions of life and a heavy childhood determined him to commit such illegalities. I’m not going to try to justify his actions, but in his own way, I really believe that he is a good man. I think that the main reason why he was so attached to Pip is because of his pain of thinking that he lost his own child: “Look’ee here, Pip. I’m your second father. You’re my son—more to me nor any son. I’ve put away money, only for you to spend. “
2&3. “That person is the person from whom you derive your expectations, and the secret is solely held by that person and by me.”, said Mr. Jaggers. At that moment, Pip thought that the “secret benefactor” is Miss Havisham, but it turned out that it wasn’t her. He wanted so much to become a gentleman to impress Estella, and to determine her to love him. I think that if he wouldn’t go to London, we would have had a totally different course of the story. My opinion is that Pip didn’t give up the love he felt for her because he felt that going to London and become a gentleman would be the perfect chance to prove that he is worthy of her.
4. Well, in my mind, another final for this story would be obviously the one in which Pip and Estella would finally get together. As Lorena said, after Magwitch and Miss Havisham’s deaths, I would like Estella to realize how much Pip loves her and, of course, her to begin to have feelings for him. _________________ Alexandra Noje, LRE III, CUNBM |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Emanuela Negru Dunker


Data inscrierii: 26/Mar/2018 Mesaje: 18
|
Trimis: 07/02/2019 00:04 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
1.An interesting character for me is Estella. I think she is more than a cold heart. Miss Havisham had “ great expectation” from this girl. Miss Havisham was left at the altar on her own wedding day. Her tenebrous past influenced her to create a cold heart, a girl who will be her revenge. She hate the man who fake his feelings for her and Estella is her opportunity for revenge. I think the most horrible feeling in the world is the feeling of betrayal. Also, when trachery comes from your fiancé it is painful and hard. After so many years, Miss Havisham can’t pass over that ocazie of her life and she choose to live an isolated life in darkness. She took Estella in her darkness. When she was a little girl , Estella was taught by Miss Havisham to be arrogant, to look with superiority and to have no feelings for men. Miss Havisham wanted to see how Estella is adored by every men and how she will broke their hearts. On the psychological point of view, one of the first and main environment, that the child will experience is his home. Since her birth, the emotional environment she sees and feels around will shape Estella personality. Also, I think the place where you grow up have a big influence in your personality. The love of your mother, the support of your father will make you a person who will have his own dream. I think, Estella didn’t have that kind of maternal love, and also, if someone would ask her “What do you want to do with your life? What is your dream? she didn’t have her own answer, maybe probably will be something like this “ I don’t know! I want what Miss Havisham want! Because she forgot how is to love people and also, how is to have her own path in her life. And this is the sad reality today, children follow their parents idea of life because they are young and they didn’t have life experience. They didn’t have the courage to follow their dream. And also they stop dreaming, they have low expectation from life because of a low mentality. Also when we say environment we refer to conditions that the child grow up. If I think about Estella and her house the first words that come in my mind are darkness, no love and no affection. “From that room, too the daylight was completely excluded, and it had an airless that was oppressive. A fire had ben lately kindled in the damp old-fashioned grate, and it was more disposed to go out than to burn up, and the reluctant smoke which hung in the room seemed colder than the clearer air ..The most prominent object was a long table with a tablecloth spread on it, as if a feast had been In preparation when the house and the clocks all stopped together. An epergne or centrepiece of some kind was in the middle of this cloth: it was so heavily overhung with cobwebs that its form was quite undistinguishable: and, as I looked along the yellow expanse out of which I remember its seeing to grow, like a black fungus, I saw speckled-legged spiders with blotchy bodies running home to it…I heard the mice too..” This is the environment where Estella grow up, in a wilderness house, where the spiders and mice have their own place. In an empty room with no love and friends , until Pip appear. It seems to be a house where time was collapsed, like in “Cartea nuntii” by Geoge Calinescu, in chapter two where the Jimmy’s aunts are like mummies. This scene represent the passive attitude that Miss Havisham have regarded her life. Ok, I understand you were chatted by your fiancé, you need time to rise from the ashes, but you can’t drag someone in your tenebrosity, especially a child. Sometimes, I wandered what would happened with Estella if she grew in a warm family, maybe she would be different, maybe she would have a good personality, and love to give. At some specific point, Miss Havisham said that she is responsible for Estella behaviour “I stole her heart and put ice in its place.” Also, Estella said to Pip “ You must know that I have no heart. Oh! I have a heart to be stabbed in or shot in, I have no doubt and, of course, if it ceased to beat I should cease to be. But you know what I mean. I have no softness there, no-sympathy-sentiment-nonsenses. I am serious, I have bestowed my tenderness anywhere. I have never had any such thing. If I can describe Estella in two words, will be ice queen. She is a cold person because she didn’t know how is feel to be loved, and to grow up in a normal family, not in a house that was forgotten by years. Estella blamed her “mother”, Miss Havisham for being like this, she hated her life because she is unhappy and she said “You should know, said Estella “I am what you have made me. Take all the praise, take all the blame; take all the success, take all the failure; in short take me” In short words, Estella is telling the fact that if she wanted success ,now Miss Havisham can enjoy by her success, but Estella is the price of her actions. She was the sacrificial lamb that help her to get closer to her prize, to see how men are in pain. She put her stamp on her soul but she can’t enjoy by her actions because she saw Estella’s pain. Everyone want revenge, but this is not the only way. You just fell more pain, and you can’t be happy living your life like this. You became an austerely person who hate everyone around you, and in this way you just cast away your life. There is a quote from Bible who make us to see how we have to be in such situation “Do not repay evil with evil or insult with insult. On the contrary, repay evil with blessing, because to this you were called so that you may inherit a blessing.” (1 Peter 3:9) I think you will fell better if you choose kindness and blessing.
2. I think Pip life would have been very different if he wouldn’t go to London. I think he would became Joe’s apprentice. At London he didn’t study very much but the people around him help him to became a sociable person and to large his cognizance. He was part of high society for a time and he met Herbert Pocket and Wemmick and also Mr. Jaggers . I think this book is about discovering the world. After Pip left from his natal village he discovered a new world, and in the end of the book, the most important discovery of all- the truth about himself. The clipă that determined Pip to became a gentlemen was the first meeting with an arrogant girl, Estella. In his childhood he was attached to his uncle, actually his sister’s husband. For him Jos was like a father who learnt him about life. He loved the evening, when Joe told him about his life, about his father and mother and also about his love for his sister. Pip had great expectations from life, he wanted more than he had at his childhood period. His meeting in the churchyard with an inmate, actually his future sponsor, is the moment when Pip’s life will be change for ever. He is conscious the fact that he can’t develop himself being Joe’s apprentice. ‘’What could I become with these surroundings? How could my character fail to be influences by them? It is to be wondered at if my thoughts were dazed, as my eyes were, when I came out into the natural light from the misty yellow rooms?” There is a change in Pip’s behaviour after he is coming home from Miss Havisham. He is starting to compare his small house with the place where Estella grow up. Also he saw Joe in a different way, he saw that he is abashed when he had to talk with Miss Havisham. After a while he can read the people intentions, and their mind, and he can făcute a image about their character, like he made with Mr. Pumblechook. SO, we can say that Pip have two models, in his life, the low social rank and high social rank. Both of them represented by a person who is attached for. For low rank is Joe, and the high society is represented by Estella. The power of love win and he wanted to become a gentlemen for her, as he confess to Biddy “ Biddy, said I, after binding her to secrecy.’ I want to be a gentleman”and the answer that Biddy gave to him is more surprising than we expected “Oh, I wouldn’t if I was you!...You know best Pip; but don’t you think you are happier as you are?” In the night before he had to go to London Pip is thinking about his life, and about his childhood and he wanted to make a change in his life. In conclusion, if Pip wouldn’t go to London he maybe will have a sad life, because he didn’t like his life, he didn’t want to be Joe’s apprentice, he is unhappy live like this. “ Once it had seemed to me that when I should at last rool up my shirt-sleeves and go into the forge, Joe’s prentice, I should be distinguished and happy. Now the reality was in my hold, I only felt upon my daily remembrance to which the anvil was a feather. There have been occasions in my later life when I have felt for a time as if a thick curtain had fallen on all its interest and romance, to shut me out from anything save dull endurance any more” I think Pip is not happy with his life. When he went to London and built a life there, and made new friends, he is still unhappy. Everyone is “a Pip” at some point in life, we are unhappy with our life style, we wanted something more, we have something deeper but we are still unhappy. The usual answer for this question is that Pip will follow the Jos’s path in life and maybe he will married with Biddy and he will be happy. But, honestly, I didn’t think that he will be happy because he hate that style of life and he began to be frustrated when he saw Estella and her style of life…He wanted to became a gentlemen for Estella. So, yes his life would be different but he would be still unhappy and maybe he would be thinking more about “what difference does it make if?”, so he take comfort to the idea that he was at London but he is still unhappy. But he ready to sacrifice his comfort, and life to be more than what he is now. ”The important thing is :to be ready at any moment to sacrifice what you are for what you could become.”
3. Pip loves Estella with all his heart even if he can’t have her. He confess his feelings without any reserbvation “I loved her against reason, against promise, against peace, against hope, against happiness, against all discouragement that could be…I loved her none the less because I knew it. And it had no more influence in restraining me, than if I had devoutly believed her to be a human perfection” I think this is the most beautiful way that a man can love a woman, it’s amazing. I think, there is nothing more deep than love and Estella is lucky to have a man who love her in this way. But he had a cold heart that can’t be warmed by nothing. She is telling him that she have no heart because “ suffering has been stronger than all other teaching, and has taught me to understand what your heart used to be. I have been bent and broken, but I hope into a better shape” . I think it’s amazing how much Pip love her, even if she didn’t respond to his feelings. I think love is love, something abstract, you don’t have to give explanations. I love you because….you are smart, or I don’t know.. Love is love, I love you because I love you, there is no reason that I love you. So, I think Pip love Estella with all his power even if she had a cold heart.
4. Another final to the great expectations for me will be the Pip marriage with Biddy and the Pip gratitude towards Abel Magwitch. I like happy endings so, I will think at Estella like a happy girl with a warm heart and a family around her.
NEGRU EMANUELA, LRE II
Ultima modificare efectuata de catre Emanuela Negru la 10/02/2019 01:44, modificat de 1 data in total |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
PatakiRoxana17 Dunker

Data inscrierii: 22/Mar/2018 Mesaje: 16
|
Trimis: 07/02/2019 09:41 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
1. Even if Pip is the protagonist and he is probabibly mostly debated in every book or class, I truly like this character due to his guiltlessness from the beggining of the novel. I must confess that I would't have acted like him as far as it concerns the meeting with the monster because I wouldn't come back to feed him because he should know that it would expect more and more from him. I don't blame him for the person he became at one time of the novel, becoming ungreatful and snobbish. Why? Because his entire life was like a horror movie. Let's think, firstly, how his sister, Mrs. Joe Gargery treated him. As a result he was surely affected and his personality, too. He was given no importance and everything he said was wrong or blamed, this fact don't allow you to develop personally, but to became introverted and later on to be frustrated by everything surrounding you. He was like abused by his sister. Further in the novel, he meet that scary convinct which made him to confront with its and his sister because he had to bring him the goods his sister had been done. He was so scared because the monster threatened him that "will rip his gut out". He probably got the feeling that he had needed someone to help him, someone to tell about this monster hopefully for a better solution to his situation. When it comes to living his childhood, he was asked to play into a frightening place that touched him...meaning
the Miss Havisham's place who was a totally a creepy lady who was wearing her wedding dress when she was jilted at the altar and her house is covered in moss. One good thing about Miss Havisham is her adopted daughter, Estella. On whom Pip developed a crush which turns to be a mistuitor love for Pip later on...another thing that makes him "crawl in his life". Estella was the child of the richest lady in town while Pip was only a penniless boy.
Actually, Pip's aim was to work with his brother in law, Joe, on the forge and when he reach the right age for working the left his world and childhood behind and went to London in order to become a gentleman where he became a rich man and he forgot where he started. That's why once he got educated, he became inssuportable. Beause of the lack of exeperince he had developed the worst idea about being a gentleman. He thinks that if you look good, you have to be unapproachable, but he will find out that being a gentleman is much more about the partea interioară side, only when he almost lose everything. We see his growing up in the clipă when he addresses to Estella when she is on the point to marry Drummle, sharing his lovefull feelings about her. In the end his full grownup is showed in one beautiful line when he told Estella that " I work pretty hard for a sufficiant living, and therefore-yes, I do wel". We can say that the novel is a "bildungsroman" for Pip because he had grown up during the whole novel.
2. I think that if Pip wouldn't go to London, he firstly wouldn't have found out how it is to be a "gentleman" in his point of view and he probably wouldn't know how to grow up because everything happens for a reason. He would probably complace himself in the situation of being penniless and he had lived a frustrated life, feeling guilty and dejected day by day. As a result, the leaving in London taught him how to be a true gentleman and that the exterior aspect is not as important as the spiritual development.
3. I think that Pip realised the importance of the true feelings reagarding love. Sometimes, in life, you suddenly feel that you had the right person behind you and you just throw her away. That's why I think Pip didn't give up on Estella. Moreover, I do believe that his leaving in Londra developed him as a man in many ways such as becoming a rich man, then learning that the spiritual side is more important than the material one and later on he learned to be a lover man despite the fact that he had never benefit from affection his entire life and that's why I think he learn to love that beautifully. All in all, the most important gift he got in life was the feelings of true love.
4.Because I said that in the end, Pip experienced the true feelings of love, in my mind, Pip and Estella rediscover each other and live a happy life together despite the childhood they had. After all, they have learned how to behave in every situation just to help each other when they need this. They are living an unpretentious life in London because they learned how to be humble. They show that LOVE defeat every impediment and bring us to life. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Sabadis Andreea Dunker

Data inscrierii: 25/Mar/2018 Mesaje: 17
|
Trimis: 07/02/2019 14:22 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
1.I choose to speak about Pip. He is the main character in Great Expectations by Charles Dickens. We know from the biginning of the novel that he was orphan and he was grew up by his sister and her husband, Joe. It is interesting because although he has never seen his partents, he tried to make a portret of them: ’’ As I never saw my father or my mother, and never saw any likeness of either of them (for their days were long before the days of photographs), my first fancies regarding what they were like, were unreasonably derived from their tombstones. The shape of the letters on my father’s, gave me an odd idea that he was a square, stout, dark man, with curly negru hair. From the character and turn of the inscription, ‘Also Georgiana Wife of the Above,’ I drew a childish conclusion that my mother was freckled and sickly.’’ It is sad to know that some people have such a tragic destiny, moreover they have children and they become orphans. I’m seeing in Pip a nice child who respects other people even they talk badly to him. He never complains about his life, he knows that he have to be respectful, he must obey, and listens to his sister. When he met a fugitive he brought him food even he risked being beaten by his sister. After meeting Estella, he was a gentleman with her, even she did’t deserve it. Pip continued to love her and she spoke ironically to him. Miss. Havisham encouraged him to love Estella. He was honest after he finds that he is rich.He continued to be good friends with Joe: ‘You may be sure, dear Joe,’ I went on, after we had shaken hands, ‘that I shall never forget you.’ Everyone from village respect him, but he was the same Pip. Another episode when Pip shows us his character is when he finds who is his benefactor. He hates Abel Magwitch when he was a child. It was difficult for Pip to know that he depends on the person who he heates the most. However he helped Abel and tried to hide him away from the Police. Pip helped his friend to obtain a job without knowing Herbert. Pip knows whom to take advise. He often visited Wemmick. This gave Pip ideas about how to proceed in a certain situations. For exemple where Pip shelter Abel.Pip was able to choose people who was a good exemple for him.
We know how was Pip seen by other character like Mr. Wopsle: ’‘Gentlemen,’ said Mr. Wopsle, ‘I am proud to see you. I hope, Mr. Pip, you will excuse my sending round. I had the happiness to know you in former times, and the Drama has ever had a claim which has ever been acknowledged, on the noble and the affluent. ’’
In my opinion Pip was a good boy, he knows what meanstobe alone, without parents. However he was lucky to have Joe and Biddy, people who Pip can talk everythink. There are some moments when I don’t like how Pip preceded. When he return home he didn’t go to sleep at Joe’s house, he went to hotel. Maybe he thought that it will be hard to break from Jo and Biddy.
2.In my opinion, if Pip wouldn’t go to London , he contiues to work with Joe in their forge. Pip wouldn’t have another oportunity to go away and he had no chose than to work with Joe.The child was sad when he throught that he will away from Joe: „Somehow, I was not best pleased with Joe’s being so mightily secure of me. I should have liked him to have betrayed emotion, or to have said, ‘It does you credit, Pip,’ or something of that sort. Therefore, I made no remark on Joe’s first head: merely saying as to his second, that the tidings had indeed come suddenly, but that I had always wanted to be a gentleman, and had often and often speculated on what I would do, if I were one.’’However Pip was sad because he didn’t know how is his future, not because he didn’t want to go to London. He wasn’t happy knowing that he will work all his life in the forge so he needed a change. Maybe if Pip wouldn’t go to London he will marry with Biddy. I think he will forgive about Estella and accept the Biddy’s kindness.
3.I think that Pip loved Estella just because she was so different from him. They are like two opposite people who attract ”extreme are attracing’’. In the first line, Pip liked that Estella was a beautiful girl. Yes, she was a cold-hearted girl, but Pip was accustomed to living with such a person in the hause because even his sister was a cold person.Moreover Pip was influented by Mrs Havisham to love Estella. Mrs Havisham wanted to revenge on men through Estella.
4.I would like Pip marry with Biddy in the end of novel. Even Biddy wasn’t so beautiful like Estella, she was a sensitive girl, with a good heart. Biddy is too young for Joe. Estella does not deserve Pip, because she was cruel to him: ‘He calls the knaves, Jacks, this boy!’ said Estella with disdain, before our first game was out. ‘And what coarse hands he has! And what thick boots!’. Biddy teached Pip how to write, how to read, took care of his sister. I think that Biddy would make a absolut pair with Pip and not with Joe. Both Pip and Biddy are young, good-hearted and Joe would find a woman of his age.
SABADIS ANDREEA LRE II |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
ani.mihaela2017 Dunker


Data inscrierii: 26/Mar/2018 Mesaje: 16
|
Trimis: 09/02/2019 13:54 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
1.But what are we after all? A hundred, thousands and maybe millions versions of Pip. We were once kids, dreaming with our eyes wide open that one day the world will be ours, but then we grew up and being too preoccupied to make others happy we forget about ourselves. Pip story was like this. A little child oblijed to grow up and act like others told him, that he doesn’t even know if this are his dreams or not. Pip is presented as a boy that became orphan before meeting his parents and took in care by his much older sister, Mrs. Joe. In his sister’s house, Pip lives in poor conditions, from the gains of a blacksmith, as he brother-in-law was, they couldn’t afford another status and kind of life. But for Pip this life was like a dream because the father’s and friend’s love took the shape of Joe. But this dream turned in a nightmare after he met a prisoner in the moors that surrounded the place he lived. It was like a premonitory sign that made him turn again the ones he love, and lie his best friend, Joe. In his heart, Pip was like the worst infractor but he just couldn’t turn time back and change everything
So is a short time his life changed dramatically. He started to be ashamed by his life, he started to dream others dreams and to be a puppet in the big ones’ hands. After he entered in Miss Havisham’s life and house Pip started to forget about the old Pip, that innocent boy from the moors, and became the toy of an old lady. “Heaven knows we need never be ashamed of our tears, for they are rain upon the blinding dust of earth, overlying our hard hearts. I was better after I had cried, than before--more sorry, more aware of my own ingratitude, more gentle.”-Pip. Life in the big socity wasn’t easy but Pip go on with his plans to change his life. After he met Estella, he had a feeling of inferiority, a wish for change , a wish for more so he forget about the promise he made long time ago, to stay next to Joe and follow him to become a blacksmith. But he was not happy, he couldn’t be anymore that boy and choose to leave Joe and follow his own path. He entered the high society, he dressed like a real gentleman, he lived in good conditions by creating a world good enough to share with his lover, Estella. But it seems that this was nothing than another nightmare from wich he had to wake up soon.All his expectations were not real. He always believed that his benefactor is no one but Miss Havisham and he belived that she does this to make from him a good man for Estella. But when he meets Magwitch again all his expectations are ruined...he meets again the man who made from him an infractor, as Pip believed. Magwitch appears in the light of a different man. He tries to addopt the fashion of the days, to make a good impresion in front of Pip but he doesn’t realize a thing, in Pip’s eyes he is just an infractor. We found out that after he met Pip all his life changed because he was helped for the first time, he felt the need to do the same for someone. So he worked hard every day, he put money away and made a fortune to reward Pip for the food he gave him back then.“I looked at the stars, and considered how awful it would be for a man to turn his face up to them as he froze to death, and see no help or pity in all the glittering multitude.” But Pip was not impressed by this. He can’t accept the really that he will never be able to get Estella, but “We changed again, and yet again, and it was now too late and too far to go back, and I went on. And the mists had all solemnly risen now, and the world lay spread before me.” Pip’s life and dreams were lost in a moment. He became now the victim of others expectations, he completed others plans without having his own dreams, and lost all hopes but now it was too late to return to the old Pip and accept the same life as Joe.
So, for me Pip is us. During the whole story we see our evolution, our expectations through Pip’s eyes because in reality we try so hard to confecționate a good life by making happy the others that we lost ourselves somewhere at the middle of the road. Pip was catch in a trap setted by others to revenge for their unhappiness and I wonder who Pip’s life would have evoulate if he never met Magwitch and Miss Havisham.
2. Since he became an orphan and was took by his sister Mrs. Joe, Pip had all life planned. He was destined to became a blacksmith as Joe was. From the naive boy who was, Pip grow up into a man with great expectations. Since he met Miss Havisham and Estella, Pip started to dream to a better life, to unforgetfull moments in the high society. Pip and Joe’s relation was more like a father-son than brothers-in-law as Joe was always there for Pip. After Pip moved to London he deleted everything about his past, he started to forget about the humile house where he lived, about the places where he spend his childhood and about his best friend as it was too unmaniered to be next to him.
Pip was a little child in a big world who ended up living after others ideas which may have been good or not for him. He was so amazed by the power of money that he forget the importance of a family, what love is and what is to be waited by someone. He took of his simple clothes and dresses with new ones and became another spot in level of the middle class. He dressed properly, he learned how to speak in society, how to behave but he forget that behind his expensive clothes will always be that poor boy with great expectations.
3. Miss Havisham made from Estella the impecabil prototype of a cold-hearted woman, loved by everyone but hard to melt. She became the younger version of the woman Miss Havisham regreted she couldn’t be. Everything started when Miss Havisham was left on her wedding day... An old woman, dressed like a bride, and living in the dark sounds like a horror story when you expect this lady to kill you once you close the door. But it’s not like this. For me, Miss Havisham is a victim of her own destiny.Is a woman whose life stopped once her dreams was destroyed, a woman who couldn’t be strong enough to go on because she couldn’t glean all the pieces that felt from her heart. Life is like a puzzle, day by day we add a new piece to complete the picture, but for Miss Havisham some pieces are lost so her puzzle couldn’t be finished anymore“The broken heart. You think you will die, but you just keep living, day after day after terrible day.” –Miss Havisham....This is her story, a relation started with love, settled with lie and ended with agony. So what is she after all? She is a person whose heart can’t be melted anymore because her heart frozened long time ago when everything around her stopped, a proud woman who wanted to look strong but ended destroying hers and others life, because she could’t accept the reality ....So Estella becomes the prototype of beauty created with a scope:to break men’s hearts ’’Love her, love her,love her!If she favours you love her.If she wounds you, love her.If she tears you heart to pieces, love her-and as it gets older and stronger, it will tear deeper –love her, love her, love her! –Miss Havhisham.
For Pip, Estella was the first and the last love. Since they first met he was amazed by that unique girl, the împlinit beauty, the girl who made him feel everything from love to agony. When he was just a boy he felt for her more like a kind of appreciation than love because his first meeting with a child with a high status was like a door to another world, a chance to a second life. The idea that he could spent hours with someone more educated and rafined made him believe that he is a part of their life, without realizing that he’s just a puppet in Miss Havisham’s hands. In his childhood he loved her because he believed, as Miss Havisham said, that his has to love her, because she is a girl that must be loved by everyone. Even if she was indifferent to his feelings, even if she hurt him, he still loved her because this is how he had to behave. When they met after their separation as Pip left to London, his feelings for her apeared again but this time in a different way. “The unqualified truth is, that when I loved Estella with the love of a man, I loved her simply because I found her irresistible. Once for all; I knew to my sorrow, often and often, if not always, that I loved her against reason, against promise, against peace, against hope, against happiness, against all discouragement that could be. Once for all; I love her none the less because I knew it, and it had no more influence in restraining me, than if I had devoutly believed her to be human perfection.”-Pip. Being a grown up and living away from Miss Havisham’s influence, Pip started to love her as a man, to love her for her beauty, in this way completing Miss Havisham’s plan, to break another heart. Even if she was influenced and taught that all she has to do is to make man fall in love with her without responding to their feelings, Estella couldn’t do the same thing to Pip and tried as much as possible to stay away from him even if at some point we start to think that she shares the same feelings as him. So even if she rejected him and married with another man, Pip still loved her because he saw in Estella all his dreams and expectations. He always believed that with his low status he will never be able to ask for Estella’s hand so he wroked hard to change this, becoming the prototype of man every woman will fall in love with. Even so he wasn’t able to give his heart to another woman, he loved her without reason and hope “I never had one hour's happiness in her society, and yet my mind all round the four-and-twenty hours was harping on the happiness of having her with me unto death.”-Pip. He loved her in the bottom of his heart, she loved him but couldn’t realize that as she never knew what love is, so he waited, he burried his feeling in his heart and she locked her feelings in the attic of her mind because Miss Havisham’s hate will never have allowed them to be happy.
4. Estella grow up, she became a beautiful woman courted by a lot of men so she made Miss Havisham wish come true, she broke their hearts. But she is not happy, she doesn’t know what love is, she takes wrong decissions and ends up ruining her life. She realizes she was just a tool, her childhood and life were a lie and decides to leave Miss Havisham, the one who considered to be like a mother for her. She is unhappy, she is alone and after Miss Havisham’s death and the fire at the house she doen’t think for a second chance to repair her past and realizate her own kind of life. When she was in the garden looking at the ashes of the house were all her fake dreams come true, Pip reappears.
Both of them alone, without an expectation from their lives have now a chance to be happy. ’’I took her hand in mine, and we went out of the ruined place; and, as the morning mists had risen long ago when I first left the forge, so, the evening mists were rising now, and in all the broad expanse of tranquil light they showed to me, I saw no shadow of another parting from her.”-Pip
The end of the novel is opened so the reader can go on with his own story as we don’t know if Pip expectations to get Estella’s heart have a happy ending or not. In my own story, Estella learnt what true love is after she met Pip. She doesn’t sees him as an inferior boy anymore, but as a man that can make her happy. With their past’s ashes spread in the wind, Pip take her hand and goes far away with her to show her how love feels. She is now able to open the door of her attic so she discovers her feelings and share her love and ideas with the man, next to him she feels alive. Time stopped in Miss Havisham's house at 8:40 a.m. but now I hear a clock’s sound under the ruins of the house as time starts to pass again and sings the happy Tic-tac song.
*quotes from ''Great expectations'' by Charles Dickens
Ani Mihaela, LRE II |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
ioanaosan2017 Dunker

Data inscrierii: 22/Mar/2018 Mesaje: 15 Localitate: Mocira
|
Trimis: 09/02/2019 15:27 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
1. Miss Havisham is a lady who, in my opinion, did not have a happy story, so I chose to talk about her. She was left on the wedding day by the person she loved. Her wedding day was horrible, everything was prepared: the guests' table, the wedding cake, the bride, everything was adorned, obviously until the letter that ruined the day was received. For Miss. Havisham the time stopped at twenty minutes to nine, all the clocks in her home were fixed at the same time. Probably her feelings have been transposed into her life, because everything around her has changed into black. From that day on in her house, light has not passed. And she became a cold and hard person. Miss Havisham adopted Estella because she wanted to have children, and Estella made her a little better. Estella is a very beautiful girl and Miss Havisham loves her from the first moment. Mss. Havisham uses Estella to make Pip suffer. In fact, in her vision all men should suffer. But Miss Havisham does not teach her to love, no, she teaches her to adopt an ice heart. Probably Miss Havisham wants to turn everything to her own destroyed soul. I think Miss Havisham's icebreaker is due to this story. And I still think that under this ice heart there is a warm heart, but who only aspires to nothing.
2. Probably Pip would have remained a blacksmith with Joe. He'd have a common blacksmith's life. But somehow I think he would have been ambitious and made himself a gentle man. Pip did not bother it, but he wanted to become a gentleman because he liked to learn things, although he had no idea what to mean being a gentleman. Probably he thought to be a gentleman means to be smart, mannered, and work for money. But also to marry a high ranking lady.
3. Love is the following, she has no rank, age, height, beauty, kindness, wickedness, and just comes unexpectedly. The heart of the ice that Estella has created was Miss Havisham. Estella probably had the impression she was doing well, because she was taught so. If Estella had been taught to love everything that surrounded her and had no prejudices, she might not have had a cold heart. One thing for sure, she loves Pip and she has new feelings she did not understand. As I said above, love is not limited, love can transfigure anything. Love can melt an ice heart, and Pip helps her, he does not give up on it. He shows that for love it is worth fighting and not giving up. Try to convince her that what she feels is not wrong.
4. Indeed, the end is unexpected. Estella recognizes her feelings for Pip, and they will live happily. Probably. The end can be interpreted in many ways. Their love can have the destiny of Miss Havisham, or they will live happily ever after. Love may sometimes be deceptive, but I suppose it will not happen and they will keep loving eachother. _________________ Osan Ioana Paula, CUNBM Litere LRE III |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Marius Mesaros Dunker

Data inscrierii: 16/Mar/2018 Mesaje: 19
|
Trimis: 09/02/2019 22:16 Titlul subiectului: Great Expectations |
|
|
1. Pip is a misfortunate boy, who does not really believe in himself, his low self esteem being constantly fed by his abusing sister and the others around him, Joe, the blacksmith, being the only one who encourage Pip. This entourage makes of Pip a very passive and timid child, inclined to a dreamy state. When he enters the Satis House, he is dazzled by the fairy-tale atmosphere but most of all, he is mesmerized by the encounter with princess like, Estella. Also, the things that he sees in the house, wealth, beauty, polish, will făurite an intense impression, buried in his mind, making him pursue them later in his quest for a noble life. Noble for him meaning becoming a gentleman, the opposite of what he actually is. So this two obsessions, having Estella and becoming a gentleman mark his quest of overcoming his condition. These obsessions are blended to the point of confusion, several times. Pep is the symbol of several themes, like obsession, desire, guilt, wealth, greed, ambition.
I think of Pip as being a character that could not really choose to act in a very different way than he does, because of his education that has rooted deep in him. If I where to put myself in his place, I am pretty sure that I would acted exactly the same as he did, being blinded of pursuing obsessions.
2. Well, I think that Pip`s life would have been much duller, less colourful if he had chose to don`t follow his dreams, that is his love for Estella and to become a gentleman. We can see his life without this obsessions, in the episode when he returns. In this episode, he is an ordinary man, yes, honest to himself, and hadn`t become a silly snob, but if he had chose to stay and simply accept his condition, he would be at the same time dishonest to his dreams, and probably doomed to live a life of regret at the thought of ‘ but if?’…
Pip represents at the same time the idea that is best to pursue your dreams and go for what you think you want, to escape your condition, even if you can`t really do it. But this exercise of courage and truthfulness to what you feel, could be the necessary step in order to know yourself.
3.Estella is for Pip, a love at first sight. Love or obsession, the two concepts are somehow if not the same, they sure are complementary, so in this meaning Pip really loves her. Being thunder struck by her princess appearance, cold but beautiful, she is the perfect piece from the fantasy world in which Pip finds comfort from the harsh conditions in which he lives. You can`t give up a love for somebody, because love comes not by choice, but by accident, so you can`t control it. You don`t do something in order to love so you can not do something in order not to love.
Estella, like Pip, is an orphan and a victim, and both are used by their families. In this concern, despite the big differences, both children are linked by this lack of family love and domestic warmth. They are both solitary children, and their encounter is the clipă they make a friend for each other. She is franc and tells to Pip that she will do what she was thought to do, which is to toy every man in her life, but him. This kind of confession has the effect of binding them more to each other. Even though Pip is loosing himself in the mirage of power and wealth, he never truly cease his love-obsession, Estella, and in time, Pip becomes kind of an obsession for her too.
4. For the complex episodes in it, the end of the story seems too mellow, too fairy tale like. This kind of “and they lived happily ever after” seems to be forced, brought from another story or wrote for the public`s commodity.
My imagined end for the two of them would be probably a life separated one from each other, but with the inability to forget their mutual obsession.
Marius Mesaros - LRE II
Ultima modificare efectuata Marius Mesaros la 10/02/2019 16:01, modificat de 2 ori in total |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Cristina.Ilcas17 Dunker

Data inscrierii: 16/Mar/2018 Mesaje: 18
|
Trimis: 10/02/2019 01:07 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
1. Estella is a character whose actions are best justified in the book. She was raised by Miss Havisham so that says a lot about her upbringing. Miss Havisham has experienced something that left her unstable: she was dump at the altar; and from that day she sworn to herself no to trust man anymore because they bring nothing better in the world. Miss Havisham saw in Estella the impecabil weapon to take revenge. She raised Estella to break men's heart. This is why she is could hearted, being unable to love, to create a strong bond with someone. I believe she is well-aware of this method of upbringing. When Miss Havisham acused her of not showing a bit of love to her, and for being cold she just bursted out : "Do you reproach me for being cold? You? […] I am what you have made me. Take all the praise, take all the blame […] All I possess is freely yours. All that you have given me, is at your command to have again. Beyond that, I have nothing. And if you ask me to give you, what you never gave me, my gratitude and duty cannot do impossibilities" I just do not get why (if she realizes that her spiritual education was wrong) she doesn't want to let Pip in her heart and see for herself if really love can be that cruel. But I also think that not having an example in this matter she chose a man that is a reflection of her own behavior, of her own self; Drummle being a man that will show her nothing close to the idea of love- but maybe this is what she wants after all, maybe her mind can't be change from one day to another. ""I have not bestowed my tenderness anywhere. I have never had any such thing."
2. I think Pip's life wouldn't have been too bright if he stayed home. Why? Because this was an experience that shaped him. Did he not go, he would not climb the social classes he wanted to. But also, after he became a gentleman he started to behave coldly because he thought that a gentleman has no feelings and should be indifferent to those around him.
Another ocazie that helped him realizes how life is, would be when he comes back home and he realizes that social status won't bring him the thing he wanted the most : Estella.
3.When do you want something the most? When you know you can't have it.
I think Pip didn't give up on her because he had expectations both from him, and from her. He wanted to make Estella understand that his feelings are completely honest and that there is love on earth, there is a sparkling coming from his side. Also, Pip was blinded by her beauty "The unqualified truth is, that when I loved Estella with the love of a man, I loved her simply because I found her irresistible. Once for all; I knew to my sorrow, often and often, if not always, that I loved her against reason, against promise, against peace, against hope, against happiness, against all discouragement that could be. Once for all; I loved her nonetheless because I knew it, and it had no more influence in restraining me, than if I had devoutly believed her to be human perfection".
"The stones of which the strongest London buildings are made, are not more real, or more impossible to be displaced by your hands, than your presence and influence have been to me, there and everywhere, and will be." - here Pip makes a comparison with the stones, I think the stones represent all the obstacles that exist between him and Estella, and a major one would be the love that is only coming from one side. _________________ Ilcaș Cristina, LRE III |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Marius Mesaros Dunker

Data inscrierii: 16/Mar/2018 Mesaje: 19
|
Trimis: 10/02/2019 03:57 Titlul subiectului: Great Expectations - Ionut Chereji`s answer |
|
|
Ionut Chereji`s answers for Great Expectations
1. Pip is my choice, because i like to think that i have an ambition like him. He was an orhan boy who lives at country with Mrs. Joe,his sister and Mr.Joe Gargery, her husband. The world where Pip lives is not at all perfect, he does not know his parents at all, the sister who adopted him does not love him and she is the most real tyrant, and his only friend is Joe. Through the novel, Pip will grow physically and morally. He will know the pleasures of the life at the city, people who will become devoted friends.
2. Well Pip had money, Joe doesn`t. But he still wasn't a gentleman. When Pip arrived in London, he had no idea what to expect. He wanted to be good enought for Estella, all he wanted was to be a good match for her and that could be possible just by becoming a gentleman. His first impressions about London were no so good ..🙂 but soon he got used. If he didn't follow his dreams and heart, he would regret this decision and not to forget Estella, his love.
3. He says, “I loved her simply because I found her irresistible.”
Honestly we have to admit, Estella is a beautiful girl with a lot of money..😏 Like what men could not fall in love with her...despite her cold behavior 😁
But not to forget that ocazie when Estella loses that fight and Pip wins a kiss on the cheek, that moment of play, starts him hoping for a little bit more despite she said he didn't enjoy it much because he felt it was given as a sort of payment for winning the fight. Pip wanted to surpass ownself, like starting to reading or writing, to become a gentleman. In my opinion this was the main purpose of him, then after the marriage with a girl like Estella, because she was from another social class.
4. In my opinion the perfect ending wouldn't be that Pip and Estella get finally together because Ms. Havisham raised up Estella in a way that could affect Pip much later (deserted on the wedding day and broke his heart).
He finds another women and he fall in love with her, of course this time she did the same, a women with a good heart because a pretty face gest old, a nice body will change, but a good woman will always be a good woman.
Ionut Chereji LRE II
Ultima modificare efectuata de catre Marius Mesaros la 10/02/2019 15:54, modificat de 1 data in total |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Alexandra Noje 17 Plunger


Data inscrierii: 14/Mar/2018 Mesaje: 27 Localitate: Satu Mare
|
Trimis: 10/02/2019 08:41 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
Answers from DANCIU ALEXANDRA-NICOLETA, LRE II:
1) My choice is the main character of book because I consider that he reflects the main theme in “Great Expectations”. The novel begins with a description or better said with an explanation of his name given by Pip himself and this scene took place in a cemetery at his parents’ tombstones: “My father’s family name being Pirrip, and my Christian name Philip, my infant tongue could make of both names nothing longer or more explicit than Pip. So, I called myself Pip, and came to be called Pip.” I think this scene is very important because it let us know the position of this child whose only property was his name. Pip was an orphan who was grown up by his sister, Mrs. Joe Gargery. The fact that he spent so much time looking at his parents’ tombstones shows his need of love and affection. In his family made up of his sister and her husband wasn’t the right atmosphere for raising a child. In his heart was inculcated the feeling that he is a burden to his sister: “If it warn’t for me you’d have been to the churchyard long ago, and stayed there. Who brought you up by hand?” Mr. Joe Gargery, her sister’s husband represented, somehow, “the father figure” for Pip, even if they were more like brothers. I saw him as a bad example of the adult man because he was the image of submission. In the relationship between Joe and his wife he was the one who took her bad and abusive behavior lying down while Mrs. Gargery was “the head of the family”. Even though Joe wasn’t the best embodiment of masculinity, Pip could learn from him how to be fair, devoted, good-natured and trustworthy. Without the attention of a loving family, Pip grew up in a world too unfriendly for a child. The encounter with the two convicts made him commit the first acts of injustice that made him even less sure of his human quality. Pip was a naive and innocent child who had no one to teach him how to behave, how to think. There was no one to shape Pip in his process of becoming an adult for the real life. Even his playground was an inappropriate place for a child. When he first arrived at Mrs. Havisham's manor, Satis House, he saw another world. He met there Estella, a beautiful girl who became his crush and made Pip being ashamed of himself: “I had never thought of being ashamed of my hands before; but I began to consider them a very indifferent pair. Her contempt for me was so strong, that it became infectious, and I caught it.” His visits at Satis House represent the period when Pip became aware of his position, he was only a penniless boy. The fact that over the night a benefactor appeared and decided to change Pip's life made him aspire to more. He didn’t have the notion of the right path to follow in life and this was the real problem of Pip. He moved to London in order to become a gentleman but he didn’t know how to improve himself. He thought that money was the key of his becoming a gentleman, but money made him only rich. Even if he got educated, he forgot about the only symbol of inner nobility he had - Joe. Believing that his benefactor was Mrs. Havisham, Pip visited her more often than he visited his “dear fellow” Joe. When he found out who the real benefactor was, Pip was shocked, he was rude and ungrateful. Pip had a life with ups and downs whose main aim was to become a gentleman, but he lost almost everything because of the lack of experience. I can’t blame Pip for his choices because I don’t think his expectations were wrong, but the means to reach them. Considering his start in life, he is absolved of any sin, for my part.
2) I think that moving to London didn’t bring much benefits to Pip, but I don’t think that if he would have stayed home he were on top. He would have become a frustrated man feeling like in a cage. He would have worked with Joe on the forge and he would have been eternally curious about how gentleman's life is. Moving to London and taking his life in his own hands, Pip managed to become a gentleman and learn a very precious lesson: that the inner nobility is the main feature of a gentleman.
3) Even if Estella was cold-hearted, Pip was the one who could warm her heart. The fact that he didn’t give up on her was the guarantee he learned his lesson about the importance of the true feelings. Estella was the first who awoke this noble feeling in his heart. If for other important things he never had a landmark in his life, Estella offered him a landmark for love. Through her superiority, Estella determined Pip to increase, to improve himself, to want more than he already had had. He fixed Estella as a target for his level of development. I think another reason for his steadiness was finding out Estella's life story, which seemed to resemble somehow his story. Pip didn't judge Estella for her behavior because he didn't consider her responsible for it altogether. He didn't take a jaundiced view of Estella's behavior neither when she chose to adopt a superior position and put him down nor when she rejected him to marry Drummle. This is the proof that in his heart the noble feelings for Estella were above all things. In my opinion, not giving up on her was one of the best decisions of Pip.
4) In my mind, another final for “Great Expectations” would mean another beginning for a relationship between Pip and Estella. I think that in the final of the novel, both of them have learned their lessons and have won the right to be happy together. Moreover, there are no more impediments for their relationship as Magwitch and Mrs. Havisham had died. I would like their love to reborn from ashes and about their happiness to be written at least on the last page of the novel enough to assure us it would last forever. _________________ Alexandra Noje, LRE III, CUNBM |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
|
|
Nu puteti crea un subiect nou in acest forum Nu puteti raspunde in subiectele acestui forum Nu puteti modifica mesajele proprii din acest forum Nu puteti sterge mesajele proprii din acest forum Nu puteti vota in chestionarele din acest forum
|
|