Teacher Administrator

Data inscrierii: 26/Mar/2008 Mesaje: 471
|
Trimis: 10/06/2009 09:51 Titlul subiectului: Giving everyone a chance... |
|
|
As you are about to close this "first cycle" of your higher education, let me jot down a few lines about our experience on the forum.
As you know, I meant the forum to operate as a complement to our seminars, aimed chiefly at the "coy" lovers of literature that might be hiding in the often silent back of the classrooms...
I have let the forum go on its own, trying not to intervene too often, so that I would not sound too "bossy". I let the discussions ignite, grow, stall, halt, take a rest, and eventualy re-start burning, at the free flow of your inspiration and ideas... It was nice to see discussions that seemed to be extinct, or staller, restart anew and take speed at full throttle.
The evaluation of such activity is not an easy thing. The method I used was pretty similar with the one I used in class: I did not bother to count individual posts (even if some of you, thinking probably that this would be way I'd work, split their ideas into a myriad of choppy posts!), but rather I considered the contribution of your whole participation to the discussion. I did it the same way as if we were in class. You got a maximum of 8 posts per thread (that is, per book discussed). Individual posts received a minimum of 0.1 points (for posts that just say "yes", "that's waht I thought" or "I agree with you, Maria!") up to 3 or 4 points, if they brought up new, original ideas. For instance Razvan S's post beginning with "Todd's heart disease may be considered to be one relevant source of his hedonism." got 3 points, and so does Monica's much shorter post starting with "Indeed, through this statement the narrator anticipates one of the theme in the book, death" and the one by Maria Costin following this. So, the whole evaluation was not about the quantity of posts, but about their relevance and insight.
I also enjoyed seeing that some of you (or "youse", as the Irish_English plural of "you" would sound!), who kept a low profile (=aveaţi o prezenţă ştearsă) in class during the seminars and spoke very little, now had an extraordinary gusto for launching questions and discussing! And some of you, like the two Marias, or Roxana, or Claudia S, have become genuine moderators and brainstormers! You were the real stars here! Which confirms my intuition that people are so different, that some will shine in oral combats, others in written confrontations online, and others in the solitary confinement of writing. I tried --and I hope I have succeeded to a certain extent-- to give all of you a chance.
It was a real pleasure reading you. Thanks for the treat! |
|