| Subiectul anterior :: Subiectul urmator |
| Autor |
Mesaj |
taraczkozi claudia Plunger

Data inscrierii: 18/Mai/2008 Mesaje: 33
|
Trimis: 09/11/2008 18:53 Titlul subiectului: EAST OF EDEN |
|
|
| What do you think about the narrator of this novel?Is he a reliable narrator?why does he speak about his mother as "Olive"? |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
taraczkozi claudia Plunger

Data inscrierii: 18/Mai/2008 Mesaje: 33
|
Trimis: 09/11/2008 19:13 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
what do you think about the narrator's opinion about Cathy?
"It doesn't matter that Cathy was what I have called a monster.Perhaps we can't understand Cathy, but on the other hand we are capable of many things in all directions, of great virtues and great sins.And who in his mind has not probed the black water?" |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
alex.hapca Plunger

Data inscrierii: 05/Mai/2008 Mesaje: 47 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 10/11/2008 12:40 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Well, I think that Cathy was presented by the early beginning as being a person with problems and strange orientations.She is governed by the evil in everything she does, that's why she chooses to become a prostitute and although she marries Adam, she feels the need to return to her primarly habbits,prostitution.Although she was not only a married woman,but also a mother, she shoots her husband, abandons him and her two children.Returned to that brothel she was "working" in, she shoots the former owner and kills her.Cathy was indeed a monster, a greedy person who wanted everything for herself.Another proof that evil may be found in Cathy can be seen in that scene when she decides to photograph a powerful men involved in sadomasochistic sex acts in order to blackmail him after.Refering to the Bible, Cathy represents Eve who brings sin and evil in the world.Maybe her way of being,meaning a woman with sins was because she thought that there was only evil in the world and that's way she "has" to surrender in front of it.In the end, maybe because she could no longer bare the sin and because her son, Aron, rejected her she decided to commit suicide.Interesting is the fact that all her fortune remained to Aron and I think that she did that because in Cal she saw herself, she saw the sin while Aron was the good one.All in all, I consider Cathy as being a symbol of the human evil that will always live among people,generations.The power upon Adam and Cal is lost,this meaning that humans are free to choose between good and evil,they have the free will and the possibility to overcome evil. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
alex.hapca Plunger

Data inscrierii: 05/Mai/2008 Mesaje: 47 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 10/11/2008 14:14 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Taking in account the fact that we didn't mention in the class the possible relation between the novel and the real life, I dare now to ask you if you see any connection between Steibeck's life, the characters&the place were the action occurs?Think about Steinbeck's grandfather,Samuel Hamilton(same name as the character Samuel Hamilton from the novel), the existence of the Salinas Valley in real life about which the autor speaks about, mainly in order to describe it to his two boys.Could this be the reason why the Hamilton family appears as a family(a good one) who appreciated more the moral values,the spiritual gratitude rather than money in comparison with the other family, the Trasks who had a doubtful past?(because of the legacy Cyrus-Adam and Charles' father-left to them, legacy which was full of dirt and the result of corruption).Can you see a distinction between these two families but also between what is right and what is wrong? |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
monica p Diver

Data inscrierii: 08/Mai/2008 Mesaje: 66
|
Trimis: 10/11/2008 18:11 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| talking about the narrator's pozition in the story,I wouldn't say that he is completely reliable as far as he was a descendent of the Hamiltons,he witnessed some of the events while others were just heard from different people.On the other hand it is true that he has the pretention of objectivity and that is why he talks about his mother as Olive giving the impression that he has nothing in common with this character. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
monica p Diver

Data inscrierii: 08/Mai/2008 Mesaje: 66
|
Trimis: 10/11/2008 18:28 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| in what concerns the differeces between the two families it is obvious that the Hamiltons inherited a luggage of spiritual values while the members of Trask family just dispose of a material inheritage.The consequence is that Samuel's children become wise, honorable men who hang together when facing problems while the relationship between the children from Trask family is a conflictual one.Despite this descrepancy I didn't feel that the narrator parts with any of them.I guess he rather tries to say that even those who inherited a vicious nature can overcame it and became equally virtous with those who had an innate predisposition for good. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
monica p Diver

Data inscrierii: 08/Mai/2008 Mesaje: 66
|
Trimis: 10/11/2008 18:35 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| it is known that "East of Eden" has also a naturalistic base. Could you find some elements specific for this current? |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Pomian Codruta Diver

Data inscrierii: 08/Mai/2008 Mesaje: 59 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 10/11/2008 21:24 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| About Cathy...in the book is written at some ocazie that "monsters can born in natural families too...and they are considered as being a visible punishment for hidden sins"...with these words begins the chapter with Cathy...so I think that Cathy is really a monster and these words anticipate this idea. In my opinion I think that a normal person wouldn't do such things, but she isn't like that...she has no regret for any bad thing that she is doing. It's very strange this character...it's a very complex one. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Pomian Codruta Diver

Data inscrierii: 08/Mai/2008 Mesaje: 59 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 10/11/2008 21:36 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
What about these words written in the book: "a whip is an dispozitiv of virtute..." In this story, whip is an instrument of authority for Cathy's father (and not only for him). What do you think about this kind of 'showing who is the master'? Isn't it to cruel?...because authority you can maintain even with 'strong' words...do you really need a whip?  |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Pomian Codruta Diver

Data inscrierii: 08/Mai/2008 Mesaje: 59 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 10/11/2008 22:09 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| I'm thinking of an idea that I found in this book..."People would have much freedom and they would be happier if they wouldn't be permanently tortured by their sexuality. But this freedom is the only thing that makes us human beings". Well...what do you think? Does these words have anything in common with the action from the book? From my point of view I think that these words are in relation with the text more exactly with that place where were those courtesans...and with the fact that courtesans weren't free. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Pomian Codruta Diver

Data inscrierii: 08/Mai/2008 Mesaje: 59 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 10/11/2008 22:18 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| What do you think about the themes of this novel? I think that here we have a mixture of themes such as: love, self-destruction, greatness, guilt, freedom... what do you think? I also think that these themes are, more or less, in relation with the Book of Genesis- the story of Cain and Abel (Charles and Adam in the novel). |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Pomian Codruta Diver

Data inscrierii: 08/Mai/2008 Mesaje: 59 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 10/11/2008 22:22 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Why do you think that in this novel there are mentioned so many names of places? And a lot of description of a place and of people who lieved in that place? |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Pomian Codruta Diver

Data inscrierii: 08/Mai/2008 Mesaje: 59 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 10/11/2008 22:35 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| When Adam want to help Charles with those woods, Adam told Charles: "two persons can raise a bigger stone than just one person". I totally agree with him! What about you? |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
alex.hapca Plunger

Data inscrierii: 05/Mai/2008 Mesaje: 47 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 10/11/2008 22:38 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
I think that the major theme is the fight between good and evil.The small themes could be the freedom to overcome evil and maybe the pain caused by the paternal rejection(which can be seen both in the case of Cyrus[he prefered Adam and not Charles] and Adam[he prefered Aron and not Cal]).
Regarding the motifs of the novel, I think the story of Cain and Abel is representative and the motif of wealth,too.
The Salinas Valley and the scar of Charles could be seen as symbols.The first one played an important role because it had a major importance in the book.It was, at first, one of Steinbeck's working titles and he marks it like an arena where the struggle(between good and evil)takes place.The author described the valley in such a way that it connected to the place where Adam and Eve lived after their fall from Heaven.The second symbol is similar with Cain's mark.At some point when Charles writes a letter to his brother he says:"I don't know why it bothers me.I got plenty other scars.It just seems like I was marked". |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Pomian Codruta Diver

Data inscrierii: 08/Mai/2008 Mesaje: 59 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 10/11/2008 22:47 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| According to Hamilton and Trask families I was very surprised about the fact that, after all, these 2 families are having something in common. I thought that they have their own lives and they are presented like that..but no, this novel is like a film...a film on this novel would be great. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
taraczkozi claudia Plunger

Data inscrierii: 18/Mai/2008 Mesaje: 33
|
Trimis: 11/11/2008 11:19 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| In this novel there are mentioned so many names of places in order to create a real life.Moreover,these places as well as the people who live in are described in details in order to cerate a world closer to reality. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
taraczkozi claudia Plunger

Data inscrierii: 18/Mai/2008 Mesaje: 33
|
Trimis: 11/11/2008 11:33 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| This novel is based much on the idea of progress;new things are invented and Samuel is known to be a good inventor.From this point of view, we can notice that there are characters who are more conservative than the others.For example,Charles does not want to leave his land.while Adam is more opened to the modern world.In the end the idea of evolution wins against traditionalism as Samuel and his wife choose to move to town and this in spite of the fact that they are old. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
taraczkozi claudia Plunger

Data inscrierii: 18/Mai/2008 Mesaje: 33
|
Trimis: 11/11/2008 11:49 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Of course that two persons can rise a bigger stone than just one person.It is well known that when there are more persons ,the goal is obtained much easily.But they all must have the same aim in order to work as a team.[/quote][/code][/list] |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
taraczkozi claudia Plunger

Data inscrierii: 18/Mai/2008 Mesaje: 33
|
Trimis: 11/11/2008 12:04 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| In that society women had an important role.For example, Liza Hamilton maintained harmony in her family while Kate was the negative character who established the conflict and had a great impact on men as she had a strong power to control them.Moreover,women begun to be more independent as they used to be(for eg. they had their own businesses). |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
monica p Diver

Data inscrierii: 08/Mai/2008 Mesaje: 66
|
Trimis: 11/11/2008 18:27 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| In order to answer Codruta's question about places in this novel I would say that the author insists on this aspect because topos is here in connection with the characters, they tell something about their inhabitants.Just take the example of Tom Hamilton or of Charles Trask who are ready to renounce at everything just to stay close to their native place.Moreover the names and the full description of these geographical places give much more verosimility. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Florina Chira Plunger

Data inscrierii: 08/Mai/2008 Mesaje: 25
|
Trimis: 12/11/2008 15:40 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| I don't agree with the idea od violence. And especialy with this kind of "showing who is the master".In my opinion nobody has the right to be the master of a person. And I don't think that with the "whip" you can make something good. Almost all the time strong words hurt more than one slap. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Florina Chira Plunger

Data inscrierii: 08/Mai/2008 Mesaje: 25
|
Trimis: 12/11/2008 15:43 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
I agree with Codruta that two hands make more than one. All the time two people make more things than one, and maybe more interesting things. Always is good one hand of help.  |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Florina Chira Plunger

Data inscrierii: 08/Mai/2008 Mesaje: 25
|
Trimis: 12/11/2008 15:48 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Like Claudia says, I also think that the author described in detail the places and the people. There is a connection between places and people because every place on earth has its own traditions and culture. The author tried to help us to understand better this world and his people, to understand maybe why are they doing some things.And he tried to realized, as Claudia said also, real world with real people. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
maria costin Plunger

Data inscrierii: 23/Apr/2008 Mesaje: 35 Localitate: baia mare
|
Trimis: 12/11/2008 17:28 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
How would you comment the following lines?
”And this I believe: that the free, exploring mind of the individual human is the most valuable thing in the world. And this I would fight for: the freedom of the mind to take any direction it wishes, undirected”(Chapter 13) |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Pomian Codruta Diver

Data inscrierii: 08/Mai/2008 Mesaje: 59 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 12/11/2008 19:20 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| According to Maria's quote...I also agree the fact that it's very important to have "the freedom of the mind to take any direction it wishes"...and moreover to have the freedom to think what we want and what we feel it's right and true. We are lucky because nowadays we have the right of opinion...and with this advantage we have the chance to change some unjusted things. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Pomian Codruta Diver

Data inscrierii: 08/Mai/2008 Mesaje: 59 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 12/11/2008 19:32 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| What do you think about what Cathy's parents told her: "to be a teacher is a dignified, a respectable and and opened career for a girl who belongs to a good family". Don't you think that's a bit strange? because everybody has the right to learn, but in the book is told that to be a teacher is very difficult because a teacher has to deal with everybody even with strange and dangerous persons... |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Florina Chira Plunger

Data inscrierii: 08/Mai/2008 Mesaje: 25
|
Trimis: 12/11/2008 23:35 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| I agree with Codruta that we have the freedom of mind. Nobody can control our thoughts. Even if we give the impression that we do what other people told us to do, and make them think that they control us, we can think whatever we want. In my opinion, if our body can be controled, our mind will always have freedom. Nobody can "enter" in our thoughts and in our soul. These two things are maybe the only parts that we can entirely control only us. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Florina Chira Plunger

Data inscrierii: 08/Mai/2008 Mesaje: 25
|
Trimis: 12/11/2008 23:42 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| In those times, like is written in the book, to be a teacher is a respectable job for a girl.Indeed, it's very difficult because you have to deal a lot of people and learn them something, and before that you have to learn very much from different domains. The children are not so dangerous as adults could be, so I personally think that this career was not a dangerous one for Cathy. Most children are innocent and for a girl was very good to be a teacher, was a respectful job. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
POP CRISTINA Diver

Data inscrierii: 12/Mai/2008 Mesaje: 79 Localitate: BAIA MARE
|
Trimis: 17/11/2008 18:19 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Regarding your discution about the contrast between good and evil in the novel I consider that each character struggle with this choice but I don't think that we should look out in the novel only the story of Abel and Cain. I agree that there are many similarities and indeed the story is more or less the same but I'm sure that each individual reenact the same ancient story generation after generation and wrestle with the problem of evil. I don't remember of any religious discussion exept Lee's about the freedom of choice. No one ever goes to church and there is no priest to guide them. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
dana_achim Plunger

Data inscrierii: 11/Apr/2008 Mesaje: 26
|
Trimis: 05/12/2008 13:50 Titlul subiectului: about Cathy's character |
|
|
| I believe that here is an obvious connection between the characters from the Bible and the characters present in the book, but they are described totally different. We can see how diabolic Cathy is presented but the author still has mercy on closing up her character (her end was not so hard). She is like forgiven and was not let to leave her miserable life. For her would be much more difficult to live than to die. Cathy, considering the way she was during her life, would deserve a worse end, don’t you think? |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
|