Pagina de start a forumului EngLit EngLit
Seminar extension for the students in English Literature at CUNBM
 
 FAQFAQ   CautareCautare   MembriMembri   GrupuriGrupuri   InregistrareInregistrare 
 ProfilProfil   Mesaje privateMesaje private   AutentificareAutentificare 

Defoe - Moll Flanders

 
Acest forum este inchis, nu se pot scrie, crea, raspunde sau modifica subiecte   Acest subiect este inchis, nu se pot crea sau raspunde la mesaje    Pagina de start a forumului EngLit -> ARCHIVE '12: LRE-1.1: Narratology
Subiectul anterior :: Subiectul urmator  
Autor Mesaj
Noemi Bartha
Plunger
Plunger


Data inscrierii: 18/Ian/2012
Mesaje: 33
Localitate: Baia Mare

MesajTrimis: 13/01/2013 15:41    Titlul subiectului: Defoe - Moll Flanders Raspunde cu citat (quote)

My true name is so well known in the records or registers at Newgate, and in the Old Bailey, and there are some things of such consequence still depending there, relating to my special conduct, that it is not be expected I should set my name or the account of my family to this work; perhaps, after my death, it may be better known; at present it would not be proper, no not though a general pardon should be issued, even without exceptions and reserve of persons or crimes.

It is enough to tell you, that as some of my worst comrades, who are out of the way of doing me harm(having gone out of the world by the steps and the string, as I often expected to go ), knew me by the name of Moll Flanders, so you may give me leave to speak of myself under that name till I dare own who I have been, as well as who I am.

I have been told that in one of neighbour nations, whether it be in France or where else I know not, they have an order from the king, that when any criminal is condemned, either to die, or to the galleys, or to be transported, if they leave any children, as such are generally unprovided for, by the poverty or forfeiture of their parents, so they are immediately taken into the care of the Government, and put into a hospital called the House of Orphans, where they are bred up, clothed, fed, taught, and when fit to go out, are placed out to trades or to services, so as to be well able to provide for themselves by an honest,industrious behaviour. Had this been the custom in our country, I had not been left a poor desolate girl without friends,without clothes, without help or helper in the world, as was my fate; and by which I was not only exposed to very great distresses, even before I was capable either of understanding my case or how to amend it, but brought into a course of life which was not only scandalous in itself, but which in its ordinary course tended to the swift destruction both of soul and body.But the case was otherwise here. My mother was convicted of felony for a certain petty theft scarceworth naming, viz. having an opportunity of borrowing three pieces of fine holland of a certain draper in Cheapside.

The circumstances are too long to repeat, and I have heard them related so many ways, that I can scarce be certain which is the right account. However it was, this they all agree in, that my mother pleaded her belly, and being found quick with child, she was respited for about seven months; in which time having brought me into the world, and being about again, she was called down, as they term it, to her former judgment, but obtained the favour of being transported to the plantations, and left me about half a year old; and in bad hands, you may be sure.

This is too near the first hours of my life for me to relate anything of myself but by hearsay; it is enough to mention, that as I was born in such an unhappy place, I had no parish to have recourse to for my nourishment in my infancy; nor can I give the least account how I was kept alive, other than that, as I have been told, some relation of my mother's took me away for a while as a nurse, but at whose expense, or by whose direction, I know nothing at all of it.

The first account that I can recollect, or could ever learn of myself, was that I had wandered among a crew of those people they call gypsies, or Egyptians; but I believe it was but a very little while that I had been among them, for I had not had my skin discoloured or blackened, as they do very young to all the children they carry about with them; nor can I tell how I came among them, or how I got from them. It was at Colchester, in Essex, that those people left me; and I have a notion in my head that I left them there (that is, that I hid myself and would not go any farther with them), but I am not able to be particular in that account; only this I remember, that being taken up by some of the parish officers of Colchester, I gave an account that I came into the town with the gypsies, but that I would not go any farther with them, and that so they had left me, but whither they were gone that I knew not, nor could they expect it of me; for though they send round the country to inquire after them, it seems they could not be found.I was now in a way to be provided for; for though I was not a parish charge upon this or that part of the town by law, yet as my case came to be known, and that I was too young to do any work, being not above three years old, compassion moved the magistrates of the town to order some care to be taken of me, and I became one of their own as much as if I had been born in the place. [...]

This woman had also had a little school, which she kept to teach children to read and to work; and having, as I have said, lived before that in good fashion, she bred up the children she took with a great deal of art, as well as with a great deal of care. [...]

Here I continued till I was between seventeen and eighteen years old, and here I had all the advantages for my education that could be imagined; the lady had masters home to the house to teach her daughters to dance, and to speak French, and to write, and other to teach them music; and I was always with them, I learned as fast as they; and though the masters were not appointed to teach me, yet I learned by imitation and inquiry all that they learned by instruction and direction; so that, in short, I learned to dance and speak French as well as any of them, and to sing much better, for I had a better voice than any of them. I could not so readily come at playing on the harpsichord or spinet, because I had no instrument of my own to practice on, and could only come at theirs in the intervals when they left it,which was uncertain; but yet I learned tolerably well too, and the young ladies at length got two instruments, that is to say, a harpsichord and a spinet too, and then they taught me themselves. But as to dancing, they could hardly help my learning country-dances, because they always wanted me to makeup even number; and, on the other hand, they were as heartily willing to learn me everything that they had been taught themselves, as I could be to take the learning.

TASKS:
1.1. Identify the type of narrator in this fragment. Give argument to support your choice.
1.2. To which narrative instance does the first person pronoun refer? Motivate your choice.
1.3. What type of text is this? Could it be an autobiography? Why/not?
[size=18]
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Grebles Lavinia Daniela
Dunker
Dunker


Data inscrierii: 11/Dec/2012
Mesaje: 10

MesajTrimis: 22/01/2013 00:22    Titlul subiectului: Grebles Lavinia Daniela Raspunde cu citat (quote)

1.1 In my opinion, the narrator is unreliable. From the beginning he makes us to lose our trust in him, we can't trust him totally: ''It is enough to tell you, that as some of my worst comrades, who are out of the way of doing me harm(having gone out of the world by the steps and the string, as I often expected to go ), knew me by the name of Moll Flanders, so you may give me leave to speak of myself under that name till I dare own who I have been, as well as who I am. ''. So, from his own words, he make us to lose the trust. He is also a character in the story:" I was not only exposed to very great distresses". He used the 1st person, because he speak about him.


1.2 The first person pronoun refer to the narrator as a character.; the story is about him; he also speak at the 1st person:" I gave an account that I came into the town with the gypsies, but that I would not go any farther with them, and that so they had left me, but whither they were gone that I knew not, nor could they expect it of me; "

1.3 I don't think that is an autobiography, because we don't have dates, we don't have an account of events. Also, the character speaks about other subject not only his life:"when any criminal is condemned, either to die, or to the galleys, or to be transported, if they leave any children, as such are generally unprovided for, by the poverty or forfeiture of their parents, so they are immediately taken into the care of the Government, and put into a hospital called the House of Orphans, where they are bred up, clothed, fed, taught, and when fit to go out, are placed out to trades or to services, so as to be well able to provide for themselves by an honest,industrious behaviour." He tells us a lot of details that are unnecessary, who don't have any connection with his life. I think is a novel becaus have many idear, doesn't has a clear structure, the author discusses about what he wants. [/list]
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Teacher
Administrator
Administrator


Data inscrierii: 26/Mar/2008
Mesaje: 471

MesajTrimis: 24/01/2013 20:13    Titlul subiectului: Re: Grebles Lavinia Daniela Raspunde cu citat (quote)

Grebles Lavinia Daniela a scris:
1.1 In my opinion, the narrator is unreliable. From the beginning he makes us to lose our trust in him, we can't trust him totally: [...] . So, from his own words, he make us to lose the trust. He is also a character in the story:" I was not only exposed to very great distresses". He used the 1st person, because he speak about him.

[...] the story is about him; he also speak at the 1st person


Before any comment on your intervention, just one note on the gender (sex) of the character. You keep calling this character him (I underlined the instances in your quoted text above).

Now, have you never heard of the name Moll or Molly? This is the name that the character uses. Is Moll(y) a male name?

Besides, you seem to have read the text in a rather careless manner. Haven't you noticed these lines in the text:

"I had not been left a poor desolate girl without friends,without clothes, without help or helper in the world, as was my fate;"

Or what about this:

the lady had masters home to the house to teach her daughters to dance, and to speak French, and to write, and other to teach them music; and I was always with them, I learned as fast as they;

Do you think the teaching of young ladies was made in the presence of boys (as you consider this Moll)?

Or this one:

I could not so readily come at playing on the harpsichord or spinet, because I had no dispozitiv of my own to practice on [...] but yet I learned tolerably well too, and the young ladies at length got two instruments, that is to say, a harpsichord and a spinet too,

Were these two instruments, the harpsichord and the spinet, typical for male or female use? Did women or men play these? Whose instruction was considered deficient without the command of these instruments: the boys' or the girls'?[/b]
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Teacher
Administrator
Administrator


Data inscrierii: 26/Mar/2008
Mesaje: 471

MesajTrimis: 24/01/2013 20:24    Titlul subiectului: Re: Grebles Lavinia Daniela Raspunde cu citat (quote)

Grebles Lavinia Daniela a scris:
1.3 I don't think that is an autobiography, because we don't have dates, we don't have an account of events. Also, the character speaks about other subject not only his life:"when any criminal is condemned, either to die, or to the galleys, or to be transported, [...] He tells us a lot of details that are unnecessary, who don't have any connection with his life. I think is a novel becaus have many idear, doesn't has a clear structure, the author discusses about what he wants.


Well, I think you should reread your course on the first-person novel, and try to apply these notions.

You reject the idea that this is an autobiography --I assume you mean an authentic (real) autobiography. That happens to be correct, but the reasons you give here are too vague, too imponderable...

"We don't have dates," you say. But are precise date really necessary? Does Ioan Creanga give you riguros dates? It's true, most real autobiographies (like Primo Levi's, you discussed with Ms Bartha in class) tend to be more precise thant the fictional autobiographies. But this is not an absolute rule. You might omit them if you want to protect people in your life or if your memory is failing...

"We don't have an account of events", you say. But an autobiography might also be about the spiritual transformations or the intellectual progress of a person. And those aren't events, at least superficially...

"a lot of details that are unnecessary", you say. But, sorry, when your grandfather or some other relative, start telling stories from their war years, or their army years, aren't they too offerring a lot of unnecessary details? Unnecessary for whom? For you maybe. But not to them!

You are right, this is a novel... But is it completely unrelated to the autobiographical genre?

There are better and more precise indicators to assess that wrtitings' fictionality! Have you thought comparing the name of the actual author and that of the narrator? Maybe you'll tell us what you have found!
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Afiseaza mesajele pentru a le previzualiza:   
Acest forum este inchis, nu se pot scrie, crea, raspunde sau modifica subiecte   Acest subiect este inchis, nu se pot crea sau raspunde la mesaje    Pagina de start a forumului EngLit -> ARCHIVE '12: LRE-1.1: Narratology Ora este GMT + 2 ore
Pagina 1 din 1

 
Mergi direct la:  
Nu puteti crea un subiect nou in acest forum
Nu puteti raspunde in subiectele acestui forum
Nu puteti modifica mesajele proprii din acest forum
Nu puteti sterge mesajele proprii din acest forum
Nu puteti vota in chestionarele din acest forum


Powered by phpBB © 2001 phpBB Group
trevorj :: theme by ~// TreVoR \\~
Fa-ti si tu propriul forum GRATUIT, pe www.myforum.ro