Liliana Stetcu Rookie

Data inscrierii: 14/Mai/2012 Mesaje: 9
|
Trimis: 08/06/2012 17:26 Titlul subiectului: Daniel Defoe vs. Jonathan Swift |
|
|
In Gulliver’s Travels Jonathan Swift’s intended to satirize in part Daniel Defoe’s novel, Robinson Crusoe, which had been published seven years before. Although the two novels revolve around the idea of travelling to isolated island communities and contain significant statements about contemporary society, they are different in their approach. While Defoe is concerned with Robinson’s inner life, Swift is preoccupied with his character’s social one. Both novels are allegories. The first one is an allegory of the author’s own life, a story about the idea of man’s seclusion in the midst of crowds, a spiritual biography. The other is a moral allegory. The various races and societies are used by Swift in order to satirize the frailties and errors that human beings are prone to.
These stories have other points in common: they are very popular, both to adults and (often in a modified form) to children as well. The main characters are the only survivors and they each go to important changes from the beginning of the novels to its end. But, if Gulliver becomes a cynic and a misanthrope person by rejecting the European society, Robinson Crusoe will return from the island back to civilization as if he has never been away.
Literary style of both novels is clear, pointed, precise, simple and fluent. Like Swift, Defoe writes in the first person. The concreteness of detail and the matter-of-fact style give authenticity and an air of sober reality to these works. |
|