Pagina de start a forumului EngLit EngLit
Seminar extension for the students in English Literature at CUNBM
 
 FAQFAQ   CautareCautare   MembriMembri   GrupuriGrupuri   InregistrareInregistrare 
 ProfilProfil   Mesaje privateMesaje private   AutentificareAutentificare 

C. ”The Proposal” by A.P. Chekhov

 
Acest forum este inchis, nu se pot scrie, crea, raspunde sau modifica subiecte   Acest subiect este inchis, nu se pot crea sau raspunde la mesaje    Pagina de start a forumului EngLit -> 1.1; Narratology
Subiectul anterior :: Subiectul urmator  
Autor Mesaj
16.timea.szilagyi
Rookie
Rookie


Data inscrierii: 07/Noi/2016
Mesaje: 6
Localitate: Baia Sprie

MesajTrimis: 14/12/2016 22:48    Titlul subiectului: Responses Raspunde cu citat (quote)

C1. I think Tchekhov is a man in his 40 (when he wrote the book), white, tall, slender, russian maybe, or somwhere near Russia.

C2. He was in his 20's when he wrote the book, I didn't imagine him with a moustache and beard Smile. And yes, he's russian, no doubt.

C3. He wrote the books for feminine readers, but not only. That is actually an implied reader, not a real one. He makes a mention of his intended reader in the last sentence: "The feminine reader, who expected a melodramatic ending, may relax. "

C4. I think the author imagined us to be dreamy women, who want to read melodramatic texts, or people in love, who like to read about love stories: "How sad, dear reader, that you have never met the Princess. She is a gentle and enchanting* creature with soft heavenly-blue eyes and hair like a silken* wave. ".

C5. I expected this text to be a novel about a love story.

C6. It is actually a satyrical play. He creates his characters with irony, and talks to the implied readers with irony: "Only an insensitive nincompoop* could resist her smile or the soft charms of her very small and perfectly formed bust. Only a blockhead could fail to register feelings of absolute joy when she speaks or smiles or shows her dazzling* white teeth. "; the characters have exagerrated features: Valentin is very shy, and although he seems to be in love with the princess, he decides to propose her using his profitable proposal, trying to convince her to accept, as she would be able to make lots of money by selling poods of tallow. Princess Vera, although she is a princess and she is beyond imagination beautiful, she accepts, because the idea of profit suits her needs.
I think the author wanted to fool us, making the reader a victim of his trick.

C7. Again like in the text before, the author keeps some kind of distance from his characters, given by the irony he treats the whole story. I don't think he sympathizes his characters, but he wants us to sympathize them, that's why he presents the princess as being incredibly beautiful, and that's why he says he's sad for us because we never met her.
_________________
Timea Szilagyi
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Alexandra Covaciu 16
Plunger
Plunger


Data inscrierii: 14/Dec/2016
Mesaje: 32

MesajTrimis: 18/12/2016 17:21    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

C1. The Implied Author is a russian gentleman, romantic, for 30-40 year, stylish.
C2. It's as I've imagined, a little younger when he wrote the story.
C3. The intended Reader for this short story are especially women who dreams or who are in love. We call that reader an implied reader and the author mention of his intended reader in the final:"The feminine reader, who expected a melodramatic ending, may relax. "
C4. I think the author fotografie the reader as some people floating on a cloud, for which love is everything.
C5. A love story, with happy final.
C6. I think he would keep us in suspense and for this reason he didn't make a classical love story. I like that, because, honestly, I hate love stories! :-D
C7. Maybe he feel symphaty for both, because they are his creation, but, as I said earlier, is more distant to fulfill order.
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
raluca.borlan(16)
Rookie
Rookie


Data inscrierii: 07/Noi/2016
Mesaje: 4

MesajTrimis: 15/01/2017 00:24    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

C1. Russian man, 40 - 50 years old

C2. He was younger when he wrote the book.

C3. Probably womans. Implied reader. He mentoned at the end : "The feminine reader, who expected a melodramatic ending, may relax. "

C4 .I don't think the Author had a high opinion of his intended Readers. Probably he expected us to be woman and I don't think he had a very good opinions about womans.

C5. A love story.

C6. No, my expectation wasn't fulfilled, I think it's an effect he meant to create, and we can realize this from the final sentence : "The feminine reader, who expected a melodramatic ending, may relax. "

C7. I don't think he feels some kind of special sympathy for his characters.
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
ofelia oprea
Rookie
Rookie


Data inscrierii: 14/Noi/2016
Mesaje: 7

MesajTrimis: 19/01/2017 09:14    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

C1. I think is a man 35 -40 years , not very tall ,russian and he has beard I think.

C2. Not realy he had 28 years when he wrote the Proposal but he is a russian , man of course and with beard .

C3.Anyone can read this short story I think .Actual reader .No

C4 .Yes he thinked at feminine readers because the title sugest a love story .

C5.I thought that is love story .

C6 .No because at the beging of the story I thought that is love one and than I was a little bit sad when I readed all.No I do not believe that author made a mistake, I think that he just played a little with readers imagination .

C7.Maybe for the princess because she probably expected to be a mariage prosposal and than she find that it was a bussines one .
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Teacher
Administrator
Administrator


Data inscrierii: 26/Mar/2008
Mesaje: 471

MesajTrimis: 19/01/2017 19:18    Titlul subiectului: Raspunde cu citat (quote)

Some very serious answers about a text which was so ironic and funny!...
Here we go.

C1. Since the implied reader is your mental image of the writer, (almost) anything will do.
TSz +, AC +, RB +, OO +

C2.
TSz +, AC +, RB *, OO * (checkyour grammar Ofelia!)

C3. "The feminine reader, who expected a melodramatic ending, may relax. " Melodrama-inclined female readers.
TSz. ++, AC +, RB * (womans — no such plural!), OO —

C4. Probably condescending such readers...
TSz +, AC +, RB +* (again womans), OO — (a non-answer; plus „he thinked ” is wrong form for „he thought”)

C5. Sentimental novel.
TSz +, AC +, RB +, OO +

C6. Our expectations are frustrated deliberately (or, as Timea said, „the author wanted to fool us”).
TSz ++, AC *, RB +, OO + (but wrong grammar again: he readed — please learn your irregular verbs!)

C7. Distance of irony.
TSz ++, AC — (not clear at all), RB * (no argument), OO — (not really...)

TOTAL points:
TSz 10 ; AC 5.5 ; RB 6 ; OO 3.5 .
Sus
Vezi profilul utilizatorului Trimite mesaj privat
Afiseaza mesajele pentru a le previzualiza:   
Acest forum este inchis, nu se pot scrie, crea, raspunde sau modifica subiecte   Acest subiect este inchis, nu se pot crea sau raspunde la mesaje    Pagina de start a forumului EngLit -> 1.1; Narratology Ora este GMT + 2 ore
Pagina 1 din 1

 
Mergi direct la:  
Nu puteti crea un subiect nou in acest forum
Nu puteti raspunde in subiectele acestui forum
Nu puteti modifica mesajele proprii din acest forum
Nu puteti sterge mesajele proprii din acest forum
Nu puteti vota in chestionarele din acest forum


Powered by phpBB © 2001 phpBB Group
trevorj :: theme by ~// TreVoR \\~
Fa-ti si tu propriul forum GRATUIT, pe www.myforum.ro