 |
EngLit Seminar extension for the students in English Literature at CUNBM
|
| Subiectul anterior :: Subiectul urmator |
| Autor |
Mesaj |
Noemi Bartha Plunger

Data inscrierii: 18/Ian/2012 Mesaje: 33 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 13/01/2013 19:25 Titlul subiectului: Arthur Conan Doyle - The Magic Door |
|
|
I care not how humble your bookshelf may be, nor how lowly the room which it adorns. Close the door of that room behind you, shut off with it all the cares of the outer world, plunge back into the soothing company of the great dead, and then you are through the magic portal into that fair land whither worry and vexation can follow you no more. You have left all that is vulgar and all that is sordid behind you. There stand your noble, silent comrades, waiting in their ranks. Pass your eye down their files. Choose your man. And then you have but to hold up your hand to him and away you go together into dreamland. Surely there would be something eerie about a line of books were it not that familiarity has deadened our sense of it. Each is a mummified soul embalmed in cere-cloth and natron of leather and printer's ink. Each cover of a true book enfolds the concentrated essence of a man. The personalities of the writers have faded into the thinnest shadows, as their bodies into impalpable dust, yet here are their very spirits at your command.
It is our familiarity also which has lessened our perception of the miraculous good fortune which we enjoy. Let us suppose that we were suddenly to learn that Shakespeare had returned to earth, and that he would favour any of us with an hour of his wit and his fancy. How eagerly we would seek him out! And yet we have him---the very best of him---at our elbows from week to week, and hardly trouble ourselves to put out our hands to beckon him down. No matter what mood a man may be in, when once he has passed through the magic door he can summon the world's greatest to sympathize with him in it. If he be thoughtful, here are the kings of thought. If he be dreamy, here are the masters of fancy. Or is it amusement that he lacks? He can signal to any one of the world's great story-tellers, and out comes the dead man and holds him enthralled by the hour. The dead are such good company that one may come to think too little of the living. It is a real and a pressing danger with many of us, that we should never find our own thoughts and our own souls, but be ever obsessed by the dead. Yet second-hand romance and second-hand emotion are surely better than the dull, soul-killing monotony which life brings to most of the human race. But best of all when the dead man's wisdom and strength in the living of our own strenuous days.
Come through the magic door with me, and sit here on the green settee, where you can see the old oak case with its untidy lines of volumes. Smoking is not forbidden. Would you care to hear me talk of them? Well, I ask nothing better, for there is no volume there which is not a dear, personal friend, and what can a man talk of more pleasantly than that? The other books are over yonder, but these are my own favourites ---the ones I care to re-read and to have near my elbow. There is not a tattered cover which does not bring its mellow memories to me. [...]
Reading is made too easy nowadays, with cheap paper editions and free libraries. A man does not appreciate at its full worth the thing that comes to him without effort. Who now ever gets the thrill which Carlyle felt when he hurried home with the six volumes of Gibbon's ``History'' under his arm, his mind just starving for want of food, to devour them at the rate of one a day? A book should be your very own before you can really get the taste of it, and unless you have worked for it, you will never have the true inward pride of possession.[...]
It is a great thing to start life with a small number of really good books which are your very own. You may not appreciate them at first. You may pine for your novel of crude and unadulterated adventure. You may, and will, give it the preference when you can. But the dull days come, and the rainy days come, and always you are driven to fill up the chinks of your reading with the worthy books which wait so patiently for your notice. And then suddenly, on a day which marks an epoch in your life, you understand the difference. You see, like a flash, how the one stands for nothing, and the other for literature. From that day onwards you may return to your crudities, but at least you do so with some standard of comparison in your mind. You can never be the same as you were before. Then gradually the good thing becomes more dear to you; it builds itself up with your growing mind; it becomes a part of your better self, and so, at last, you can look, as I do now, at the old covers and love them for all that they have meant in the past.
[color=indigo]TASKS:
7.1. Which narrative instance is "I/me" and 'our/we'? Give reasons.
7.2. What kind of novel do you think this is? Could it be realistic or rather a fantasy? Or is it rather an essay? |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Berci Mary Rookie

Data inscrierii: 04/Oct/2012 Mesaje: 7 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 19/01/2013 18:34 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
7.2 It might be an essay because it have the structure of an essay(paragraph,developed ideas). The subject can be about books''It is a great thing to start life with a small number of really good books which are your very own''. The writer invites it's readers ''Come through the magic door with me, and sit here on the green settee, where you can see the old oak case with its untidy lines of volumes'' to read,to search for books.
7.1 ''I'' refers to the writer(he started with his opinion or thought the essay:''I care not how humble your bookshelf may be, nor how lowly the room which it adorns'' and ''we'' refers to it's readers. Most essays are written by someone to a certain type of persons. Here is for people who read,are interested in books. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Grebles Lavinia Daniela Dunker

Data inscrierii: 11/Dec/2012 Mesaje: 10
|
Trimis: 21/01/2013 12:15 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
7.1 I think that "I" is the reader, the person who read the story because, at the beginning he/she tells us his/her opinion about the subject: ''I care not how humble your bookshelf may be, nor how lowly the room which it adorns.''. After than, he gives the reader some instructions: ''Close the door'', '' plunge back into the soothing company of the great dead, and then you are through the magic portal into that fair land whither worry and vexation can follow you no more.''. Those thing maybe must be done by a reader if he/she really want to read. Than, he speaks about a "dreamworld", so, the reader must let away all his/her thoughts and worries, and be capable to enter in the ''dreamworld'': ''And then you have but to hold up your hand to him and away you go together into dreamland.'' He tells the reader that we will go with him in the "dreamworld" maybe to give him trust or to determinate him to do that thing. After than, he speaks on the 2nd person(including him): ''Let us suppose that we were suddenly to learn that Shakespeare had returned to earth, and that he would favour any of us with an hour of his wit and his fancy''. Trough these words, we cand understand that he speaks with "us" in order to determinate the reader to read the things that he recommended him. I think that how he speaks to the reader, gives him trust; it's different when we say "we enjoy" and not "you enjoy" because we can observe here something like an advice who will take us at a good thing. So, "we" reffers to the narrator (as a reader) and the other readers.
7.2 I don't think that this can be a novel. A novel must be longer, and have most complicated and different words. When you write a novel, you must speak with "another" language, have another structure.
I think that could be an essay. In my opinion is an essay from the point of view of a human who read book and invited other to read. Firstly, he tells us his opinion about the subject:"I care not how humble your bookshelf may be, nor how lowly the room which it adorns.". Than, he invite the readers to do some thing that are necessary when you read: "Close the door of that room behind you", "shut off with it all the cares of the outer world, plunge back into the soothing company of the great dead, and then you are through the magic portal into that fair land whither worry and vexation can follow you no more". He invite the readers to go with him: "Come through the magic door with me, and sit here on the green settee, where you can see the old oak case with its untidy lines of volumes." I think that also, the structure tells us that this is an essay. Has many ideas, different ideas, not complicated words and a structure not very hard/complicate. Through this essay. he invite people to read book, he tell us his opinion about this subject and give us advices about what we have to do when we read. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Anna Podina Rookie

Data inscrierii: 04/Oct/2012 Mesaje: 9
|
Trimis: 23/01/2013 00:35 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
[size=18][/size] 7.1."I" is the author, "you" is the reader.
7.2. I think this is an essay about the importance of reading in our lives. the author tries to convince us that a book is more than we see, that in a book is hidden the personality of the author "...the personalities of the writers have faded into the thinnest shadows, as their bodies into impalpable dust, yet here are their very spirits at your command" and that we can enter in author's soul by reading. This "magic door" that the author is talking about is the pleasure of the lecture, and he is trying to make us find it: "come through the magic door with me, and sit here on the green seet where you can see the old oak case with its untidy lines of volumes. Smoking is not forbitten". The author wants to share with the readers the love for books "...you can look, as I do now, at the old covers and love them for all that they have meant in the past"
So "the magic door" is the love for lecture and books. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Teacher Administrator

Data inscrierii: 26/Mar/2008 Mesaje: 471
|
Trimis: 24/01/2013 19:49 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Berci Mary a scris: |
7.1 ''I'' refers to the writer(he started with his opinion or thought the essay:''I care not how humble your bookshelf may be, nor how lowly the room which it adorns'' and ''we'' refers to it's readers. |
OK, but "writer" is an empirical (=unscientific, intuitive) notion, not one acknoweldged by narratologists. We're talking about AUTHOR --of the two sorts, IMPLIED and ACTUAL-- and NARRATOR. Which one is this "I" pointing to?
As for READERS, tha't 50% OK. You need to specify if we're dealing here with IMPLIED READERS or REAL READERS. And by the way, shouldn't we be mentioning the NARATEE here? |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Teacher Administrator

Data inscrierii: 26/Mar/2008 Mesaje: 471
|
Trimis: 24/01/2013 19:59 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Anna Podina a scris: | | I think this is an essay about the importance of reading in our lives. [...] This "magic door" that the author is talking about is the plăcere of the lecture, and he is trying to make us find it: [... ] So "the magic door" is the love for lecture and books. |
This is a good, sensible approach. You have managed to express your thoughts in a well articulated and plastic manner. I do not doubt you can be fairly good at commenting and interpreting motifs and themes.
Narratology, however is a bit more "arid" and "technical." At least, before getting to comment proper, you need to properly identify certain instances and notions in the text. And this you failed to do in your reply to the first question. Your answers are too vague and imprecise.
As for the second question, you seem to be replying that this is an essay. OK, everything in it points to an essay. However, the text already has a title, and that does not sound like the title of an essay. Conan Doyle is reputed as an author of detective fiction. So, are you 100% sure this is a stand-alone essay? Couldn't it be part of a novel though? |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Anna Podina Rookie

Data inscrierii: 04/Oct/2012 Mesaje: 9
|
Trimis: 26/01/2013 02:27 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
7.1. "I/me" is the narrator, and "our/we" is about the narrator and the naratee. "it is our familiarity also which has..." i think the the naratee is someone the narrator knows, "come through the magic door with and sit here on the green setee, wehere you can see the old oak case with its untidy lines of volumes. Smoking is not forbitten" so the naratee is supposed to know this places, the green setee, the old oak case. The narrator seem to know the habits of the naratee, for example that he smokes. This naratee may be also a dead relative of the author "the dead are such good company that one may come to think too little of the living".
7.2. this is a novel, I first tought, frankly that this theme can't fill a whole novel, that is said all about that theme, but I changed my mind because of the title, and because of the presence of the naratee, we should know more detailes about him. This novel is a fantasy, the action is ipotethic although may seem real, credible. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
|
|
Nu puteti crea un subiect nou in acest forum Nu puteti raspunde in subiectele acestui forum Nu puteti modifica mesajele proprii din acest forum Nu puteti sterge mesajele proprii din acest forum Nu puteti vota in chestionarele din acest forum
|
|