| Subiectul anterior :: Subiectul urmator |
| Autor |
Mesaj |
Morovan Corina Diver

Data inscrierii: 03/Dec/2008 Mesaje: 82
|
Trimis: 10/01/2009 13:49 Titlul subiectului: Animal Farm |
|
|
| Athough it was an easy book to read,my impression after finishing it it was to compare the book with the society we live in.and i do not refer here just to the political aspect of the book,about a comunist society(because we had already discussed this in class) but also the book can be interpreted as the way the human body works,how we can be influenced so easily,about the power of the words.When Napoleon realised that he is smarter than the rest of the animals,found different methods of misleading them and tricking them into doing something not for the benefit of all the animals,but mostly for him.And i think that at the end of the book all the animal that were alive from the begining till the end,realised that things changed,but for them changed in bad not good,but it was a little to late for them to change things.We, humans, are preety much the same,and we let ourselves convinced into doing some things and hope for good,but if we are like animals and don't think for ourselves we are just a mass of people being led by someone who is smart enough to gain enough power over us. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Czap_Eva Diver

Data inscrierii: 09/Oct/2008 Mesaje: 81 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 10/01/2009 17:10 Titlul subiectului: Re: Animal Farm |
|
|
| Morovan Corina a scris: | | We, humans, are pretty much the same,and we let ourselves convinced into doing some things and hope for good,but if we are like animals and don't think for ourselves we are just a mass of people being led by someone who is smart enough to gain enough power over us. |
That's a very good point ...and perhaps there are some who did think, like Benjamin, but nobody did listen to him, because they all thought he was only an old, strange donkey...and Benjamin didn't really tell them what he knew, perhaps he thought he couldn't be able to change them, until Boxer was injured and sold to the slaughterer...in that clipă he realized that the other animals do not see what Napoleon was really doing. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Cristea Maria Mirabela Dunker

Data inscrierii: 02/Ian/2009 Mesaje: 15 Localitate: CAVNIC
|
Trimis: 10/01/2009 18:47 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| "Animal Farm" is one of the novels I like to read, and that is because it doesn't tell you everything from the first pages and the end is absolutely original and unforseen.Once you understand the message you immediately realise the amazing resemblance between the helpless animals and humans - a crowd of struck dumb people. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Larisa Meisaros Plunger

Data inscrierii: 15/Dec/2008 Mesaje: 27 Localitate: Sighetu Marmatiei
|
Trimis: 11/01/2009 16:41 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
After reading `Animal farm` I had the impression that I may easily find similarities between the characters from this novel and some `personalities` from our present society.It is obvious that this will be a story without ending...The novel is full of symbolism...each character has a `quality` of a political personality and of course, the author draws out the most important features of each character,making it possible to understand the real meanings hidden behind the symbols. It was a very interesting experience to read such a book...and moreover it was funny to relate the novel to the cartoons  |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Morovan Corina Diver

Data inscrierii: 03/Dec/2008 Mesaje: 82
|
Trimis: 12/01/2009 07:57 Titlul subiectului: Animal Farm |
|
|
| Although Benjamin was the only that did realise what Napokleon is trying to do with the farm,it helped nobody,because just expressing his opinion to himself didn't make any difference at all,so just knowing that things are not correct,but doing nothing means in a way that he was no better than the rest of the animals who followed Napoleon's orders.Maybe things could have changed at the animal farm if he had talked with the animals and had made them realise that the whole situation was even worse than in the beginning when the farm was led by Mr.Jones. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
cristina balint Rookie

Data inscrierii: 13/Oct/2008 Mesaje: 9
|
Trimis: 14/01/2009 22:07 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| After reading this book and thinking about the characters I remembered something that i was told a while ago: that names attract destiny. Snowball wears such an innocent name, it is a playful one, it is the kind of name that somebody who everybody likes has it. This in opposition to Napoleon, a name that carries weight, Napoleon being a significant person in history. Napoleon does not say much, but does much. Just by hearing this name respect and grandeur comes into my mind, the same respect and grandeur this character managed to impose on the other characters. The naming of the characters is indeed a considerate aspect, it helps the reader to kind of guess the story line. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
ADINA LUTAS Plunger

Data inscrierii: 11/Oct/2008 Mesaje: 26
|
Trimis: 16/01/2009 19:43 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
In my opinion Old Major is the initiator of the communism in the Manor Farm. He begins always his speech with "Comrades" like Ceausescu did in Romania when he spoke to tha nation begining with"tovarasi".
Old Major is discontented because of the hard working and the little food that they get: "...we are given just so much food as will keep the breath in our bodies...". As well he is the character who teaches the other animals the "Beasts of England" which is also like a national anthem. It was the same in Romania, every person was forced to sing every day the national anthem.
Old Major has alway revolutionary ideas concerning human beings:" I merely repeat, remember always your duty of enmity towards Man and all his ways. Whatever goes upon two legs is an enemy." He is a great orator and influences the animals because all animals on the Farm like to listen to Old Major's stories. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Czap_Eva Diver

Data inscrierii: 09/Oct/2008 Mesaje: 81 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 17/01/2009 13:35 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| ADINA LUTAS a scris: | In my opinion Old Major is the initiator of the communism in the Manor Farm. He begins always his speech with "Comrades" like Ceausescu did in Romania when he spoke to tha nation begining with"tovarasi".
Old Major is discontented because of the hard working and the little food that they get: "...we are given just so much food as will keep the breath in our bodies...". As well he is the character who teaches the other animals the "Beasts of England" which is also like a national anthem. It was the same in Romania, every person was forced to sing every day the national anthem.
Old Major has alway revolutionary ideas concerning human beings:" I merely repeat, remember always your duty of enmity towards Man and all his ways. Whatever goes upon two legs is an enemy." He is a great orator and influences the animals because all animals on the Farm like to listen to Old Major's stories. |
Well, I don't really think that Major wanted things to happen as they did. I think, he was, just as Snowball, a revolutionary thinker, but he didn't support communism. The one who turned everything in a communistic 'society' was Napoleon. I want to think, that Major was really on the side of equality, and the terms 'Comrades' were just terms used at the time Orwell has written the book.
In my opinion, Major was only against human, against the poor and unjust situation they were living in. The spark of controlling and oppressing the other animals popped out of Napoleons sick mind, when he realized, that all the power could be his, because of the passiveness and naivety of the others. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
ADINA LUTAS Plunger

Data inscrierii: 11/Oct/2008 Mesaje: 26
|
Trimis: 17/01/2009 16:42 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
I said that Old Major was the initiator because he had that revolutionary ideas and he had that "famous dream" but I didn't say that Old Major turned Animal Farm in a communistic "society".
And right, he didn't support communism in a direct way but he supported it in an indirect way because his ideas were interpreted by Napoleon changing the initial meaning ,thus, in the end pigs were the real masters of Animal Farm like in "Communism" |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Larisa Meisaros Plunger

Data inscrierii: 15/Dec/2008 Mesaje: 27 Localitate: Sighetu Marmatiei
|
Trimis: 21/01/2009 21:11 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Citat: | | Lee argues that Animal Farm is more than an allegory of twentieth-century Russian politics, and more even than an indictment of revolutions in general: "Orwell is also," claims Lee, "painting a grim picture of the human condition in the political twentieth century, a time which he has come to believe marks the end of the very concepts of human freedom." |
I agree with Lee, it is about politics, human rights and beliefs, social behaviour and society life...the enumeration may continue... |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Czap_Eva Diver

Data inscrierii: 09/Oct/2008 Mesaje: 81 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 22/01/2009 00:10 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Larisa Meisaros a scris: | | I agree with Lee, it is about politics, human rights and beliefs, social behavior and society life...the enumeration may continue... |
The whole book is a metaphor of a deranged society, of course it is about politics and social life.
Do you have a special part that captured your attention?
That made you realize that it is not just a fable for kids, but that it has a more important layer?
Do you have a part that shocked you?
My favorite part was the end, quite shocking and I didn't wait that it will be like this. I loved the innovating picture of men are like pigs and pigs turning into men. I did like the picture of all the animals freezing at the sight of the 'party' inside the house... |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Morovan Corina Diver

Data inscrierii: 03/Dec/2008 Mesaje: 82
|
Trimis: 22/01/2009 15:53 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Larisa Meisaros a scris: | | Citat: | | Lee argues that Animal Farm is more than an allegory of twentieth-century Russian politics, and more even than an indictment of revolutions in general: "Orwell is also," claims Lee, "painting a grim picture of the human condition in the political twentieth century, a time which he has come to believe marks the end of the very concepts of human freedom." |
I agree with Lee, it is about politics, human rights and beliefs, social behaviour and society life...the enumeration may continue... |
I think we have established in class that the novel is all about politics and social behaviour...
What i don't know is who this Lee is??? |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Larisa Meisaros Plunger

Data inscrierii: 15/Dec/2008 Mesaje: 27 Localitate: Sighetu Marmatiei
|
Trimis: 22/01/2009 22:18 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
I want to answer Corina`s question
| Citat: | | What i don't know is who this Lee is??? |
Robert E. Lee is best known as Leader of Confederate armies in the Civil War.He was the Confederacy's most famous general in the American Civil War.
He criticised some works related to politics and historical events as he had the oportunity to live such experiences.
So, it is essential to .mention that he also became president of Washington College in Virginia, after the Civil War, a post which he held until his death.He is regarded as one of history's famous steeds. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Morovan Corina Diver

Data inscrierii: 03/Dec/2008 Mesaje: 82
|
Trimis: 23/01/2009 07:08 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
[quote="Larisa Meisaros"]I want to answer Corina`s question
| Citat: | | What i don't know is who this Lee is??? |
Thank you for your response  |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
emperor122986 Dunker

Data inscrierii: 10/Dec/2008 Mesaje: 21
|
Trimis: 25/01/2009 12:20 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Larisa Meisaros a scris: | I want to answer Corina`s question
| Citat: | | What i don't know is who this Lee is??? |
Robert E. Lee is best known as Leader of Confederate armies in the Civil War.He was the Confederacy's most famous general in the American Civil War.
He criticised some works related to politics and historical events as he had the oportunity to live such experiences.
So, it is essential to .mention that he also became president of Washington College in Virginia, after the Civil War, a post which he held until his death.He is regarded as one of history's famous steeds. |
Are we talking here about General Robert E Lee who died in 1870?How could he have read Orwell's book if he died in 1870? Maybe I'm wrong,but didn't the book "Animal Farm" appear in 1945? So...how could a dead general read the book?hmm... and I don't think americans knew about Russia at that time
By Tulici Robert |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Larisa Meisaros Plunger

Data inscrierii: 15/Dec/2008 Mesaje: 27 Localitate: Sighetu Marmatiei
|
Trimis: 25/01/2009 14:22 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
I want to rectify my anteriour answer about Robert E. Lee.
Robert Edward Lee was born Elyria, OH, in 1918. Lee attended Elyria High School and later studied at Northwestern University and Ohio Wesleyan University. After graduation, Lee worked for a time at the New York advertising firm of Young & Rubicam. One of his successes as a producer was the Railroad Hour.
In 1942 Lee was Expert Consultant to the Secretary of War, and later worked for the United States Army Air Force.
Sorry for the confusion  |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Morovan Corina Diver

Data inscrierii: 03/Dec/2008 Mesaje: 82
|
Trimis: 25/01/2009 20:07 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Larisa Meisaros a scris: | I want to rectify my anteriour answer about Robert E. Lee.
Robert Edward Lee was born Elyria, OH, in 1918. Lee attended Elyria High School and later studied at Northwestern University and Ohio Wesleyan University. After graduation, Lee worked for a time at the New York advertising firm of Young & Rubicam. One of his successes as a producer was the Railroad Hour.
In 1942 Lee was Expert Consultant to the Secretary of War, and later worked for the United States Army Air Force.
Sorry for the confusion  |
Still confused about this Lee character.What i found on the internet related to Lee and Orwell's book is the following:"Other critics, such as Robert A. Lee, writing in Orwell's Fiction, hold that it is in fact dangerous to read Animal Farm too strictly as an allegory of a specific set of events, as one may in that way miss a broader applicability of its meaning".
http://www.answers.com/topic/animal-farm-novel-7
Robert A.Lee wrote the book Orwell's fiction in 1968.
"Animal Farm has taken its place alongside Candide and Gulliver's Travels as one of those parables which embody permanent truths: a myth that will long outlast the particular historical events which form its background. Now that it is possible to view the work in context, freed of the emotional circumstances surrounding its publication, we can recognize it for what it is: a dystopia (an anti-utopia, an imaginary picture of the worst possible world), a satirical commentary upon human societies which vividly recalls Swift's...
http://www.pinkmonkey.com/booknotes/barrons/anifarm5.asp
Now,i don't know if it's the same Lee that was mentioned in the comments.... |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Czap_Eva Diver

Data inscrierii: 09/Oct/2008 Mesaje: 81 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 25/01/2009 21:02 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Morovan Corina a scris: | | Still confused about this Lee character. |
Ok...I searched for the quote Larisa gave...and I found the whole paragraph, which is, actually, a combination of Larisa's and Corina's quote :
| Citat: | | Other critics, such as Robert A. Lee, writing in Orwell's Fiction, hold that it is in fact dangerous to read Animal Farm too strictly as an allegory of a specific set of events, as one may in that way miss a broader applicability of its meaning. Lee argues that Animal Farm is more than an allegory of twentieth-century Russian politics, and more even than an indictment of revolutions in general: "Orwell is also," claims Lee, "painting a grim picture of the human condition in the political twentieth century, a time which he has come to believe marks the end of the very concepts of human freedom." |
[url]http://www.answers.com/topic/animal-farm-novel-7[/url] - actually the same Corina found...but it is the whole quote....so one can see that it is the combination of their quotes...
So I think it is like Corina said about the author of 'Orwell's Fiction' Robert A. Lee and not Robert E. Lee...but I didn't find any other information about him,only that the book was published 1969...
And Mr.:
| Citat: | Robert Edward Lee was born Elyria, OH, in 1918. Lee attended Elyria High School and later studied at Northwestern University and Ohio Wesleyan University. After graduation, Lee worked for a time at the New York advertising firm of Young & Rubicam. One of his successes as a producer was the Railroad Hour.
In 1942 Lee was Expert Consultant to the Secretary of War, and later worked for the United States Army Air Force. |
[url]http://www.allmovie.com/cg/avg.dll?p=avg&sql=B99169[/url]
mentioned by Larisa was a successful screenwriter...so I don't think he is the man we're searching for... |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Larisa Meisaros Plunger

Data inscrierii: 15/Dec/2008 Mesaje: 27 Localitate: Sighetu Marmatiei
|
Trimis: 26/01/2009 16:41 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| It is true that Robert Lee was a famous screenwriter but he also was a comedy writer so he may have written about other works...but I think this is not relevant. This was meant to point out ideas about Animal Farm and George Orwell and not to find more about who crtiticised his work. It was only a point of view. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Czap_Eva Diver

Data inscrierii: 09/Oct/2008 Mesaje: 81 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 27/01/2009 18:59 Titlul subiectului: Animal Farm |
|
|
I was just wandering what do you think, would have Napoleon gain the power if Squealer haven't had manipulated the animals? What do you think is Squealer's position in the story?
Ultima modificare efectuata de catre Czap_Eva la 27/01/2009 19:43, modificat de 1 data in total |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Morovan Corina Diver

Data inscrierii: 03/Dec/2008 Mesaje: 82
|
Trimis: 27/01/2009 19:35 Titlul subiectului: Re: Animal Farm |
|
|
| Czap_Eva a scris: | | I was just wandering what do you think, would have Napoleon gain the power if Squealer hadn't had manipulated the animals? What do you think is Squealer's position in the story? |
I think Squealer played an important role regarding Napoleon's power but somehow i think that Napoleon's power didn't depend so much on him,i think that if it weren't Squealer,it would have been somebody else.
Squealer was in some way,Napoleon's spokesperson,he was in charge of talking to the animals,of having to convince and persuade them that everything was in their benefit,of brainwashing them in a way.He was not clever enough in order to become the ruler of the farm,so he prefered to obbey Napoleon and to be the person Napoleon could trust,to be his right hand,because he got all the benefits he could get from being on Napoleon's side.
I also think that if the story were different,and Snowball returned and regained the power,it is very possible that Squealer would go on the side where the power was and would have left Napoleon.He was similar with a person that always does things just for their own benefit. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Morovan Corina Diver

Data inscrierii: 03/Dec/2008 Mesaje: 82
|
Trimis: 28/01/2009 17:44 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
Is there a character you would blame in the book for what had happened at Animal Farm?
I would say,no...Yes,it's true Napoleon did everything he could to trick them to work in the benefit of the pigs,in order so they would reach a higher level,higher than Mr.Jones was at the begining of the book(for he was a human being,so this gives him superiority in front of the animals) but the rest of the animals always obeyed his orders.Not even Benjamin,who might have had an ideea that something is wrong,didn't say a word.Throughout the whole book there was no sign from the animals showing active signs of protest against the regime...Not even at the end of the book,when they saw the pigs with the men,and they couldn't distinguish one from another,they just stood there....and still,didn't put the blame on nobody....
Ultima modificare efectuata de catre Morovan Corina la 04/02/2009 16:09, modificat de 1 data in total |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Czap_Eva Diver

Data inscrierii: 09/Oct/2008 Mesaje: 81 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 28/01/2009 18:02 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Morovan Corina a scris: | | Is there a character you would blame in the book for what had happened at Animal Farm? |
You're right, all of them had their part of fault. They were just too blind to do everything, and the ship just sank with all of them on board, because they didn't care for the boats. They had no perspective...and that's why all of them made the Farm collapse in a dictatorship. We could blame Napoleon, but in my eyes Benjamin is the first to blame, because he realized what was happening, but said nothing, done nothing. And the animals themselves because they just fell to their naivety, and didn't even question once what the real picture. Yes, Napoleon saw the stupidity of the other animals and used the situation for his benefit... But wouldn't 90% of the people do the same thing?! |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Morovan Corina Diver

Data inscrierii: 03/Dec/2008 Mesaje: 82
|
Trimis: 28/01/2009 18:12 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Czap_Eva a scris: | | [But wouldn't 90% of the people do the same thing?! |
Yes,they would....And in fact,why shouldn't they?When you see that somebody is stupid enough,and believes everything he is told,how can you not act in your own benefit?That is exactly what Napoleon did.The story ended well for him,too bad for the rest of the animals,but if they weren't intelligent enough to see the signs,Napoleon for sure didn't help them.
With people it is the same,if you can't see what's going on with your own eyes you just have to accept the consequences of your actions. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Czap_Eva Diver

Data inscrierii: 09/Oct/2008 Mesaje: 81 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 28/01/2009 18:25 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Morovan Corina a scris: | | And in fact,why shouldn't they?When you see that somebody is stupid enough,and believes everything he is told,how can you not act in your own benefit? |
Sometimes not everything is about a benefit...but about pride, identity, dignity and backbone... |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
ADINA LUTAS Plunger

Data inscrierii: 11/Oct/2008 Mesaje: 26
|
Trimis: 29/01/2009 18:20 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| What is your favorite character in the novel? Why? |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
ADINA LUTAS Plunger

Data inscrierii: 11/Oct/2008 Mesaje: 26
|
Trimis: 29/01/2009 18:43 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
My favorite character in the novel is Boxer.
"Boxer an enormous beast, nearly eighteen hands high, and as strong as any two ordinary horses put together"
On the one hand Boxer is a big, strong also patient and decent but on the other hand he is not too clever.
He is like a worker in a factory because he hasn't much to say when it comes about the farm but his goal is to work harder and harder for the windmill. Even if he is not a leader kind, he is a good animal.
In the end he collapses because of the age and because of the hard work. The sad part is that he was sold to a horse slaughterer and all the other animals knew that he was in the hospital. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Morovan Corina Diver

Data inscrierii: 03/Dec/2008 Mesaje: 82
|
Trimis: 29/01/2009 18:45 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| ADINA LUTAS a scris: | | What is your favorite character in the novel? Why? |
I would say it was Boxer,for me....Leaving aside the fact that he was just a stupid animal,without intelligence he was the most hard working animal from the farm, he wasn't selfish at all,he would do what was hardest in the work,and letting others do less,he never questioned Napoleon's authority,and most important he had faith in him,he would always say that Napoleon was right...And i saw in him,a quality of a human being,he was kind and nice,and never wanted things to be better just for him,he was the last person to think about himself...he died trying to assure,through his work, the rest of the animals a better life...unfortunately he couldn't... |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Andreea_C_LMA3 Rookie

Data inscrierii: 27/Ian/2009 Mesaje: 4 Localitate: Dullsville, Romania
|
Trimis: 29/01/2009 19:21 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
I'm glad I re-read Animal Farm. I had read it as a kind but I didn't get it's hidden meaning back when I was 10. It was mostly just about a bunch of talking animals back then. Now I finally get what it's all about, a great portrayal of dictatorship, great because it describes everything to much great detail and even has a hint of sarcasm in it.
As for the question, my favorite character would be Benjamin, just because I can relate to it, because he's quiet but very observant. He is one of the few animals who can read though he sees no use for it until the very end when it still didn't serve for much because Boxer couldn't be saved. And I think he knew all along that Napoleon would turn out to be an even worse version of Mr. Jones but he keeps to himself. He is probably one of the most constant characters throughout the stories because he doesn't change. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Morovan Corina Diver

Data inscrierii: 03/Dec/2008 Mesaje: 82
|
Trimis: 29/01/2009 19:37 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Andreea_C_LMA3 a scris: |
And I think he knew all along that Napoleon would turn out to be an even worse version of Mr. Jones but he keeps to himself. He is probably one of the most constant characters throughout the stories because he doesn't change. |
And what good did it to do him or to the rest of the animals that he knew and kept it to himself?That's not the right attitude if somebody wants to change things in better.The problem with Benjamin was that he was old,and tired from the days when Mr Jones was in charge so that he couldn't care less about what will happen,for him all was the same,nothing has changed. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
|