| Subiectul anterior :: Subiectul urmator |
| Autor |
Mesaj |
GabrielaF Dunker

Data inscrierii: 16/Ian/2009 Mesaje: 10 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 28/01/2009 12:26 Titlul subiectului: Amanda Barker |
|
|
| Amanda Barker has a very interesting poem, actually I see it like a breif story, a page in a diary, maybe her own diary. It's a sad story , quite terryfing, about her and her husband who wants her death, or maybe she is already dead, as the last line in the poem says "That he slew me to gratify his hatred" and now the story is related from her diary. The poem is easy to read, close to everyday language. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Czap_Eva Diver

Data inscrierii: 09/Oct/2008 Mesaje: 81 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 28/01/2009 13:02 Titlul subiectului: Amanda Barker |
|
|
I remember the teacher telling us, that this poem was a text from a funeral stone, I hope I don't have any problems with my memory .
Amanda, the victim, confesses what her husband has done. She is the only person that knows what has happened. She came back to let us all know, that we were mistaken in her husband, that all we have ever thought about him was a lie. The deed of the husband is one unforgivable, horrible and that's why it must be revealed, even if that means putting the truth in the mouth of an already dead person, a ghost. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Morovan Corina Diver

Data inscrierii: 03/Dec/2008 Mesaje: 82
|
Trimis: 28/01/2009 15:17 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
I am wandering why has this woman accepted to have a child,when she knew that it would kill her?
She blames her husband for this,telling the whole world that he killed her.But isn't it in some way her fault too?Unless he forced her,a thing that is not mentioned,to have sex in order to get pregnant,we can't say that it is all her husband's fault,because she accepted to get pregnant and she knew too that this is going to end in her losing her life.I don't think it is just the fault of her husband... |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Morovan Corina Diver

Data inscrierii: 03/Dec/2008 Mesaje: 82
|
Trimis: 28/01/2009 18:03 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| This woman must have very negative feelings towards her husband,that she would tell the story to the whole village,from the grave,but the fact is that it is just her side of the sory. The people from the village knew that her husband was a good man and loved her and now she's telling everybody that was not true.. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Czap_Eva Diver

Data inscrierii: 09/Oct/2008 Mesaje: 81 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 28/01/2009 18:08 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Morovan Corina a scris: | | This woman must have very negative feelings towards her husband,that she would tell the story to the whole village,from the grave,but the fact is that it is just her side of the story. The people from the village knew that her husband was a good man and loved her and now she's telling everybody that was not true.. |
I think the main idea of Amanda is to open the eyes of the village, of the world. I still see her as a victim, and I don't think she has spoken from the grave just to blame her husband, to take her revenge...but to tell the world the truth, so it will not happen again... |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
ADINA LUTAS Plunger

Data inscrierii: 11/Oct/2008 Mesaje: 26
|
Trimis: 29/01/2009 14:04 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
In my opinoin I think that Amanda blames her husband for her death and she wants everybody to know that she was killed by her husband, but in an indirect way. I know that everybody loves children, maybe her husband loved more children than his own wife, but it is inhuman to do such a thing with a person chiefly when that person is your love.
I agree with Eva and I think she was a victim, maybe she was influenced by her husband to get pregnant. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Czap_Eva Diver

Data inscrierii: 09/Oct/2008 Mesaje: 81 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 29/01/2009 15:11 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| ADINA LUTAS a scris: | | I know that everybody loves children, maybe her husband loved more children than his own wife, but it is inhuman to do such a thing with a person chiefly when that person is your love. |
I think the child was only the pretext for the wife to die...because it seamed for the husband that he could get rid of her without being blamed of murder...but he never thought that his wife's soul would confess from the other side ... but this is just an opinion....
Ultima modificare efectuata de catre Czap_Eva la 30/01/2009 11:06, modificat de 1 data in total |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Andreea_C_LMA3 Rookie

Data inscrierii: 27/Ian/2009 Mesaje: 4 Localitate: Dullsville, Romania
|
Trimis: 29/01/2009 19:40 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
I'm kind of on the fence about it. The poem is pretty short without too many details to be able to make up my mind whether the husband is guilty or "murdering" his wife as she puts it or not.
Was the husband really aware of the fact that she could not give birth, unless she signed her death sentence? Or was that discovered at birth for the first time?
And what were the times when the poem is set? I've recently watched "The other Boleyn girl" movie, actually a screening of a novel itself, where it was clear that women's only use was to give birth. The same idea could possibly apply here.
But then again we only get one point of view here so I couldn't judge. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Larisa Meisaros Plunger

Data inscrierii: 15/Dec/2008 Mesaje: 27 Localitate: Sighetu Marmatiei
|
Trimis: 29/01/2009 20:10 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
It must be a very awful feeling to know that you will die before getting to know your own child. The only one to blame appears to be her husband, the killer of two innocent souls.
The great hatred he felt for her wife killed everything that could have been beautiful. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Czap_Eva Diver

Data inscrierii: 09/Oct/2008 Mesaje: 81 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 29/01/2009 20:24 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Andreea_C_LMA3 a scris: | I'm kind of on the fence about it. The poem is pretty short without too many details to be able to make up my mind whether the husband is guilty or "murdering" his wife as she puts it or not.
Was the husband really aware of the fact that she could not give birth, unless she signed her death sentence? Or was that discovered at birth for the first time?
And what were the times when the poem is set? I've recently watched "The other Boleyn girl" movie, actually a screening of a novel itself, where it was clear that women's only use was to give birth. The same idea could possibly apply here.
But then again we only get one point of view here so I couldn't judge. |
I like this approach...and I think you are right with the 'woman only producing children' thing...But how could have she stopped her husband...it wasn't a very uncommon thing even to rape your wife...at that time... |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Morovan Corina Diver

Data inscrierii: 03/Dec/2008 Mesaje: 82
|
Trimis: 29/01/2009 20:42 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| But nobody talks there in the poem about a rape or she being forced to have a child....I'm not defending the husband,it's just one opinion,and before making a correct judgement we need to know all the facts....so,i still stick with my opinion that it was not only the husband's fault... |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Czap_Eva Diver

Data inscrierii: 09/Oct/2008 Mesaje: 81 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 29/01/2009 20:47 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Morovan Corina a scris: | | But nobody talks there in the poem about a rape or she being forced to have a child....I'm not defending the husband,it's just one opinion,and before making a correct judgement we need to know all the facts....so,i still stick with my opinion that it was not only the husband's fault... |
But what do you think could have she made to stop him? I mean, in our days you just walk out the door...and nobody judges you...but it was at the beginning of the 20th century...or even earlier...when women had no 'word'...and everybody was horrified of the thought women leaving their husbands.... |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Morovan Corina Diver

Data inscrierii: 03/Dec/2008 Mesaje: 82
|
Trimis: 29/01/2009 20:53 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Czap_Eva a scris: |
But what do you think could have she made to stop him? I mean, in our days you just walk out the door...and nobody judges you...but it was at the beginning of the 20th century...or even earlier...when women had no 'word'...and everybody was horrified of the thought women leaving their husbands.... |
Even back then i think that there were methods of not getting pregnant,without the husband finding out...But anyway,that's not the point of the poem,and is certainly not the theme of the poem,which again is death....A lot of modernist writers seem to write about this in their works... |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Czap_Eva Diver

Data inscrierii: 09/Oct/2008 Mesaje: 81 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 29/01/2009 21:43 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Morovan Corina a scris: | | ...the theme of the poem,which again is death....A lot of modernist writers seem to write about this in their works... |
I think this is because, modernism itself meant the death of pink, over-chewed literature and themes... |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Larisa Meisaros Plunger

Data inscrierii: 15/Dec/2008 Mesaje: 27 Localitate: Sighetu Marmatiei
|
Trimis: 29/01/2009 23:52 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| I believe that the modern elements are obvious in this poem. It is true that modernism involves real life debates and the subject is discussed in a manner which reveals facts of our society, morality, politics, and from a lot of other domains. It is a very interesting way of seeing things through many perspectives and being transposed in a fictional world but in the same time in the real one. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
TOMOIAGA TEODORA Dunker

Data inscrierii: 10/Ian/2009 Mesaje: 17 Localitate: SATU MARE
|
Trimis: 30/01/2009 17:01 Titlul subiectului: Amanda Barker |
|
|
| This is a lirical poem, an epic story, in which Amanda reveals the story of her life. She feels like a prisoner in her own life, she doesn't like the fact that her husband let her with child. Amanda feels like her husband slaid her "to gratify his hatred". |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Lavinia Voinescu Plunger

Data inscrierii: 11/Ian/2009 Mesaje: 36 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 01/02/2009 21:59 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| The poem represents the death and the beginning of a new life,as the woman must die after giving birth.I think that Amanda Barker got married very young: ''In my youth therefore I entered the portals of dust'' and her marriage was a complet failure. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Cristea Maria Mirabela Dunker

Data inscrierii: 02/Ian/2009 Mesaje: 15 Localitate: CAVNIC
|
Trimis: 02/02/2009 08:49 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
This poem is like a message came from the other world to tell everybody that she was killed.But maybe she was not killed by her husband,maybe he didn't forced her to keep that child.The poem is too short and hasn't too many detailes,so I don't know what realy happend.But I still bealive that she could defence somehow. _________________ CRISTEA |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
InceuMihaela Plunger

Data inscrierii: 22/Ian/2009 Mesaje: 28
|
Trimis: 02/02/2009 12:41 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
Well it's hard for me to understand how could she know in those times that bringing forth life would make her lose her own?
And anyway, if she knew and he knew than he can't be the only one to blame. especially that they were married.
In the end she accuses him of hating her but in fact i think that is's quite the opposite. She is the one who hates him more, because she can't rest in peace. And after all what did he do that was so bad? Why is she mad after all? Because he married her and got her pregnant? isn't that the way it's supposed to be? |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
InceuMihaela Plunger

Data inscrierii: 22/Ian/2009 Mesaje: 28
|
Trimis: 02/02/2009 12:41 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
I think that the TRUTH is that she is mad at herself for letting herself seduced by him, and for getting pregnant with him. At the same time, I'm not saying that he was the perfect man, he probably wasn't, maybe he hated her indeed, but She was aware of it and I think that she is just mad she fell for him.
And now she can't rest in peace knowing that people won't ever know the truth about him. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Marinescu Bianca Dunker

Data inscrierii: 29/Oct/2008 Mesaje: 10
|
Trimis: 02/02/2009 15:05 Titlul subiectului: Amanda Parker |
|
|
| I think this is a story,is based of an life story which is writen in a mener of a diary with no ryme and no ridem. Amanda Barker is suffering becouse she knows that her husband gives more importance to the life of their child than for her life. Her soul is dieing in the clipă of the birth of her child. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Morovan Corina Diver

Data inscrierii: 03/Dec/2008 Mesaje: 82
|
Trimis: 02/02/2009 16:15 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Lavinia Voinescu a scris: | | The poem represents the death and the beginning of a new life,as the woman must die after giving birth. |
To me the poem represented just death,Amanda's death....We don't know if she gave birth to the child... |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
|