 |
EngLit Seminar extension for the students in English Literature at CUNBM
|
| Subiectul anterior :: Subiectul urmator |
| Autor |
Mesaj |
emperor122986 Dunker

Data inscrierii: 10/Dec/2008 Mesaje: 21
|
Trimis: 11/01/2009 21:40 Titlul subiectului: 1984 |
|
|
The book “1984” is a political satire which “pushes” you to ask some questions about the way the gouvernments act in the world. Written with a lot of sarcasm and lucidity, the book presents an image of the year 1984 as the Apocalypse seen almost a century ago. The author creates a totalitary society where the orders of the Big Brother,a pseudo fascist-nazi, rule evrything. You feel almost like if you were in trance when you begin to read and discover a repellent world where the freedom of speach is forbidden and eveything appears like it came from one’s sick mind.
The author creates new concepts, like “thought crime”, “thought police” which have the purpose to opress the freedom of thinking on your own. This virtual hell is ruled by four ministries. The Minister of Love makes war plans, the Ministry of Plenty makes sure that the goods don’t fall into the hand of the commom human. Love and sex is inconceivable, with one exception,when it comes to procreation after which the children are take by Big Brother. The main charcter stars a love affair with a “ femme fatal ‘ who claims to have had affairs with 60 members of the inner party which controls the intim relations. In this Apocalypse domninated by anarchism, it is presented to us the drgardation of the human spirit, Untill the end of the book, even the main charcter looses his will for life and gives up.
A literary sci-fi which raises a lot of questions and which makes you thank God that the year 1984 wasn’t like that.
By Tulici Robert
Ultima modificare efectuata de catre emperor122986 la 24/01/2009 13:09, modificat de 1 data in total |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Czap_Eva Diver

Data inscrierii: 09/Oct/2008 Mesaje: 81 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 12/01/2009 01:42 Titlul subiectului: Re: 1984 |
|
|
| emperor122986 a scris: | | You feel almost like if you were in trance when you begin to read and discover a repellent world where the freedom of speech is forbidden and everything appears like it came from one’s sick mind. |
I couldn't have said it better myself . I was somehow split into two when reading the book...one side yelled 'it's enough, I cannot read anymore' and the other just kept on reading, passing page after page in the adventure of the only thinking person of the novel.
Another brain-washed society, just as in 'Brave New World' or in 'Animal Farm', another John the Savage in the person of Winston Smith, I think this comparison is something natural. Winston is the only one in 1984 who really wants to change something, who searches for a solution of changing society.
The author just set a excelent scenario for Winston (by placing the telescreen in a rather uncommon position in his apartment) to let him that much space just for himself to start his flow of thoughts, to encourage the free thought. Winston has a corner for himself, where he cannot be seen, and as a result, he allows himself to think about society, history, to commit thought crime.
He buys the diary, because he has this opportunity of not being watched everywhere. I think he starts the diary, just because he is not capable to keep every thought inside, and because he has to react somewhere, before reacting in the wrong place, at a wrong time. He somehow uses the diary as a relief, a place where his thoughts are safe, a thing that will never call the thought police. Although he can put down his thoughts, he is jeopardizing his life, and he is conscious that if caught, he will be vaporized.
Besides the diary, he even starts a romance with a girl, in a society where sex and love are forbidden, he starts a 'relationship' with Julia, a rebellious member of the Party. And as they say, love is blind, Winston is blinded by the feelings he is living, and does not notice, that they are not being careful enough, and in the end, they are caught by the thought police. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Czap_Eva Diver

Data inscrierii: 09/Oct/2008 Mesaje: 81 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 12/01/2009 02:08 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
While reading the novel, the reader can observe the struggle of Winston of finding out something about the past. He searches for the strings between the despotic society, ruled by a Party and an unreal tyrant and the past. He wants to find the answer to the question: 'Was it better before the revolution?'. He is not capable of setting up a proper picture about the past, just as he cannot find a proper personality of his own, just as he cannot see a solution in changing the system.
I'm just trying to imagine, if he would have been capable of finding the pieces of history's puzzle, would've he been capable of waking up the masses, of confronting the people with the truth...We wouldn't be able to answer the question...we only know, that he was not capable of solving the puzzle...I think that's because of Julia, because he became careless...and in the end he was swallowed by the society, denying his beliefs, his ideas, his feelings...
Even so, I don't think everything he was, was for nothing. I like that he had the courage to think, that even in the terror of thought police, he somehow preserved something of his soul, he didn't become the puppet of the Party...like his neighbor, Parsons, the most naive member of the party, who was proud of his children announcing him to the thought police...who in spite of his engagement to the Party was vaporized in the end too...
He impressed me with the long struggle of keeping his identity in the Ministry of Love, despite all pain, he was the person, who showed the most lucidity, who didn't give up in the first second of pain... |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Czap_Eva Diver

Data inscrierii: 09/Oct/2008 Mesaje: 81 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 12/01/2009 02:25 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
I was impressed by the idea of Newspeak...the Party did everything in order to stop thinking. I mean how can one have really thoughts, using just some special words. How could people who didn't know Old English commit thought crime, if the vocabulary used by them was censured by the Party? Could have Winston commit thought crime, if he used only Newspeak...I'm really sure he wouldn't be able of thought crime...a reason why Orwell made a character which didn't like Newspeak, because even if he was working at the Ministry of Truth, and he had to rewrite 'untrue' information, he was not speaking New English.
What about doublethink?! How to believe in two contradictory things at the same time?! It is just because Big Brother had to be always right, he couldn't be mistaken, because the society would have lost his faith in him. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Czap_Eva Diver

Data inscrierii: 09/Oct/2008 Mesaje: 81 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 12/01/2009 02:35 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| He was caught and vaporized, not because he dared to think, but in my opinion, the Party, O'Brien, realized that if he could picture out the past, than he had the intelligence necessary to open the eyes of society, to change something. I think Big Brother, the Party, O'Brien realized he was a sleeping atomic bomb, which could have blown off every second. Even with a not complete personality, identity, he was able to figure out things, others never dreamed of. He became a real danger for the Party, and he had to be killed in order for the Party to maintain its power. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Czap_Eva Diver

Data inscrierii: 09/Oct/2008 Mesaje: 81 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 17/01/2009 14:59 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
I watched the movie 'Brazil', and somehow I started to realize that it has many similarities to Orwell's novel, as if the screenplay writers of the movie had been inspired by '1984'.
I started to compare Sam Lowry with Winston Smith...they both work in a Ministry - Ministry of Information respectively the Ministry of Truth, they have a romance with a rebellious woman - Jill and Julia, both are afraid of getting caught by the police, both of them are tortured in the end. Even the societies they are living in are somehow similar, people are just some information, files hidden in a dark drawer. All are 'trained' by the authorities, all live like cattle in a herd, do the same things, have the same objectives.
Both Sam and Winston are living partially in an imaginary world, the dreams of Sam (he dreams that he is a flying 'Icarus', saving the 'love of his life', defeating and escaping the dreadful society he lives in) are the correspondent of Winston's thoughts and diary (he searches for freedom, for ways of changing the society).
And in the end, both of them switched off, Sam sank into his dreamworld, Winston joined the society of brain-washed people.
Despite the similarities, I think Sam was more active, and more efficient in his struggle, because instead of letting the outside to get into his head, he just closed the doors, and isolated himself from his environment, whereas Winston surrendered in front of the Party, losing his dreams, beliefs.
If the movie wasn't partially inspired from the book, than we may talk about a very strange coincidence . |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Czap_Eva Diver

Data inscrierii: 09/Oct/2008 Mesaje: 81 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 28/01/2009 17:04 Titlul subiectului: 1984 |
|
|
The corruptness of the characters from 1984 is quite a picture. Beginning with nobody else than Big Brother...a poster...but the most powerful poster mankind has ever seen. A picture of a non-existing person, who keeps under it's power a part of the world. And how intelligent is everything built around him. The posters, his face shown on every spare square-millimeter, a face that is burnt in every cell of the people, so that they don't even realize it. The '2 minutes of hate', destroying every thought of hope, which could sprout from the mind of the population; the content of which shows the people an image of a hero, an image of a savior, the deceiving image of Big Brother. The Ministries which make everything necessary in order to keep Big Brother in right; they change history so that they can have an image of a perfect dictator, who is always right, who's never making mistakes. The perfect picture of Big Brother on the outside is a rotten and rusty cog-wheel in the inside.
O'Brian is the picture of torture, but in the same time he is full of politeness. Even if he fouls Winston, and makes him believe in the Brotherhood(what in irony...) in order to make him grow in his dreams and thoughts of freedom, and in the end to sweep away the remainders of a once brilliant brain...
Mr.Charrington the kind, oldish shopkeeper, who wants to help Winston. We think...ooo, a man who has something inside...and yes, he has something, but not compassion, as we thought, but the same immorality and hypocrisy as O'Brian. The kind shopkeeper turns out to be a member of the Thought Police, he is the one who tears off the 'disguise' from Winston...
These characters could compete for the prize of the greatest hypocrite in literature. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Larisa Meisaros Plunger

Data inscrierii: 15/Dec/2008 Mesaje: 27 Localitate: Sighetu Marmatiei
|
Trimis: 30/01/2009 01:38 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| In 1984 George Orwell is warning us of the dangers that man could create for himself in his quest for a utopian society. He wants to warn that people might believe that everyone must become slaves to the government in order to have an orderly society, but the expense of the freedom of the people. I had the impression that everything is very descriptive and informative. He created terrifying images and horrifying truths in a calm voice that contrasts effectively with the true horrors of his message. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Czap_Eva Diver

Data inscrierii: 09/Oct/2008 Mesaje: 81 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 30/01/2009 10:15 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Yes, I think it is right with the horrifying pictures...there are lots of horrifying pictures in the novel...My favorite one was the part when they take Winston into Room 101...and just poză the rats and everything they have done with him if not confessing...terrible...quite a powerful image... |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
InceuMihaela Plunger

Data inscrierii: 22/Ian/2009 Mesaje: 28
|
Trimis: 02/02/2009 23:10 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
i liked it right from the beginning even if it was sinister, dark and tragic, and i felt like I wanted it to stay that way until the end, so i was kind of dissapointed about the introduction of Goldstein as a positive character, as the ray of light, a hope for change. The fact that he might have still been alive somewhere preparing to come back and " save the day".
I am not on the side of the evil forces, I just didn't wanted it to turn into a cheap, predictable, "happy end" story. I think that if Orwell was American, that's waht he would've given us- a boring happy ending. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
InceuMihaela Plunger

Data inscrierii: 22/Ian/2009 Mesaje: 28
|
Trimis: 02/02/2009 23:25 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
I think that the author really manages to capture all our attention and to make us enter the world he created.
He describes the world very well-the means by which people are controled, checked and manipulated and he really wants us to fully understand how it it feels to live such a life. That's why he always mentions the position of the telescreen as from where Winston is placed, the banners and posters of big brother, this way we can cross the border into the world he created. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
InceuMihaela Plunger

Data inscrierii: 22/Ian/2009 Mesaje: 28
|
Trimis: 02/02/2009 23:38 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
The worst part is that what the book presents is not even that far from nowdays situation and it's not far from becoming reality.
It is well known that similar authorities existed during the comunist regime in our country or during Hitler's rule.
And I think the world today is growing into something similar to the world Orwell presents here, just that at another level, in a more subtle way. We don't realize it but we are being manipulated by Tv just like by telescreens. the politicians who appear on Tv are the ones who really rule the world, they are just an image, like the image of big brother, that we need to see.
WE ARE BEING MANIPULATED in every way possible, it's just that we don't realize it. And Orwell's prophecy will come true one way or another. Some of the tings he mentions have alredy happened anyway. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
InceuMihaela Plunger

Data inscrierii: 22/Ian/2009 Mesaje: 28
|
Trimis: 02/02/2009 23:54 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
The people in this novel might appear to be very stupid by acepting/believing every information that they are given, like in the cafeteria, when the telescreen makes an announcement stating that production output is higher than ever, and that people have been engaging in spontaneous demonstrations all over the state to show their gratitude to Big Brother. Then it says that many demonstrations were made to thank Big Brother for raising the chocolate ration to twenty grams a week. Winston remembers that only the day before, the telescreen announced that the ration was being reduced to twenty grams from thirty. Everyone else in the cafeteria swallows this information.
If you think about it, nowdays situation is not that different. how many of us question the information we get on tv? not many. We believe it for the simple fact that "it was on tv". |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
InceuMihaela Plunger

Data inscrierii: 22/Ian/2009 Mesaje: 28
|
Trimis: 03/02/2009 00:01 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| i was surprised that Julia wasn't undercover too. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
|
|
Nu puteti crea un subiect nou in acest forum Nu puteti raspunde in subiectele acestui forum Nu puteti modifica mesajele proprii din acest forum Nu puteti sterge mesajele proprii din acest forum Nu puteti vota in chestionarele din acest forum
|
|