 |
EngLit Seminar extension for the students in English Literature at CUNBM
|
| Subiectul anterior :: Subiectul urmator |
| Autor |
Mesaj |
Persida-Mara Dunker

Data inscrierii: 26/Noi/2009 Mesaje: 19 Localitate: MM
|
Trimis: 09/06/2011 17:11 Titlul subiectului: 1984 george orwell |
|
|
I didnt't like the fact that children was learn to trade their parents. The dictator controlled everything, the soul of human, no privilege to make iluzions or dreams. The totalitarism characters are sow obvious in this book only because of psychological manipulation, the telescreen which see the behaviour of all people, and sex is only a way to make children for the Party can have new members to the system.
Which is the role of propaganda in this novel? |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Adyna Plunger

Data inscrierii: 10/Dec/2009 Mesaje: 28
|
Trimis: 10/06/2011 13:12 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
Winston is the main character of a novel of negative utopia, so there are so many things that can be said about him. In my opinion, Winston is an intelligent person, even O’Brien admits this when he is trying to cure Winston and ask him why the party rules them and Winston says that human beings are not fit to govern themselves and that’s why. Then O’Brien says that this was a stupid answer and that Winston is too smart to say something like that.
So, if there are any other people that consider Winston was a smart man I want to know their opinion of: why do you think Winston accepted to be cured? Don’t you think he could develop a better way of lying and keep his intelligence untouched? The narrator says: | Citat: | | “in the mind he had surrendered, but he had hoped to keep the inner heart inviolate.” | So, not only that he refused to think but he also refused to feel and he betrays Julia.
What I also find interesting, was the Party’s way of thinking, expressed through O’Brien. He speaks about the world they intend to create, the worst human society imaginable: | Citat: |
“The old civilizations claimed that they were founded on love or justice. Ours is founded upon hatred. In our world there will be no emotions except fear, rage, triumph, and self-abasement…. Already we are breaking down the habits of thought which have survived from before the Revolution. We have cut the links between child and parent, and between man and man, and between man and woman. No one dares trust a wife or a child or a friend any longer. But in the future there will be no wives and no friends. Children will be taken from their mothers at birth, as one takes eggs from a hen….There will be no loyalty, except loyalty towards the Party. There will be no love, except the love of Big Brother. There will be no art, no literature, no science. There will be no curiosity, no enjoyment of the process of life. All competing pleasures will be destroyed. If you want a picture of the future, poză a boot stamping on a human face -- for ever.” |
So, they are trying to make a world of robots, of ‘inhuman humans’, people without souls, intelligence, feelings. And it was really inspired the answer that Winston gave, to O’Brien, that they won’t be able to do this, because is impossible to found a civilization on fear, hatred and cruelty and that people would sooner commit suicide, than to live such a life. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Adyna Plunger

Data inscrierii: 10/Dec/2009 Mesaje: 28
|
Trimis: 10/06/2011 14:10 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
I forgot to mention another interesting fact I found in this book. If you remember the first time Winston went in the above room of the shop, he was attracted by a picture from the wall, a picture of St. Clements’s Church. While watching the picture, the old man told Winston 2 lyrics from a song about that church, saying the he doesn’t remember the rest of the song. During the novel, Winston tried to find out the rest of the lyrics and manages to find them, if I am not wrong, from Julia and O’Brien. What is most interesting in this is that the room was supposed to have no telescreen. And the final lyric of the song was: “Here comes the chopper to chop off your head!”, and after some time he finds out that under the picture it is a telescreen than somehow condemns them to death.
I would also like to found out if you believe in the real existence of the ‘Big Brother’. Honestly, I don’t think that Big Brother really existed; I think that the system only needed to have an imposable, a powerful figure, in order to could impose, to could rule. Big Brother existed through some more influential people from the Party, I think they represented the Party itself.
About Goldstein, or the two minutes of hate, they were just a psychological method in order to check human’s reaction. From that show, people like O’Brien could choose their next victim, because there they could analyze them, could see their emotions and their reaction for the ‘bad’, for Goldstein. I also think that Winston was analyzed by O’Brien at that show. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Titiana Tomoiaga Dunker

Data inscrierii: 12/Noi/2009 Mesaje: 17
|
Trimis: 10/06/2011 16:29 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| What I found surprising about this book was the accuracy of his thoughs about the socialism. He managed to predict almost precisely, what the comunist world would become. the fact that people could no longer trust each other, the fact that the quality of life would decrease , the fact that a rule of terror would be imposed, and any liberty of the individual would be negated. As far as we could read, and hear from our parents the communist regime, although at the begining good intentioned by the idealists, it arrived almost as Orwell described it: brain-washing, removing the people who dared to have another opinion than the system, imposing the single leader who would be praised, and feared by anyone this were some of the characteristics the author managed to forecast in his book 1984 and about which I think he was right.[/i] |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Titiana Tomoiaga Dunker

Data inscrierii: 12/Noi/2009 Mesaje: 17
|
Trimis: 10/06/2011 16:49 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| Another interesting thing about Orwell's novels, both1984 and Animal Farm is the fact that the system had found a national enemy, who would be guilty for everything that went wrong even if in reality that enemy wouldn't even exist or he had nothing to do with anything. IN the case of 1984 we have Goldstein. The party, as far as I could see uses Goldstein to release the anger and the frustration people would feel because of they poor life, to divert their anger against someone blamed for anything and to release themselves from the agressivity which otherwise would have been focused on those who were actually guilty for those atrocities. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
alexa_iliescu Plunger

Data inscrierii: 02/Iun/2011 Mesaje: 30 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 10/06/2011 23:51 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
It's really shocking to see how easy humans could be manipulated. I was really astonished by this fact. In general, people think that they are the most powerful, they can't be tricked and they always distinguish between good and bad. But if one reads Orwell's 1984, he will realise that things are not like humans think they are. Human nature is very weak, weaker than one could imagine. During the communist regime, those who instaurated it considered educated people to be an obstacle-because most of them were against the regime, and they had persecuted them. Uneducated people are easier to controll. I'm saying all this things because in the book it is mentioned several times that if there was any hope, it must lie in the proles. And I wondered why didn't they do anything? Why didn't they start a revolution? And I think the answer comes from what I said before. Common people, if they have what they need-especially basic needs, they don't care about the others. Even worse, they do not care even if they don't have what they need. And this fact can be seen even nowadays, because there are people who keep saying that during the communist regime was better just because they had a job and a place to live. But they don't know how many people died and were sent to prison because they fought against the regime. Actually, they don't care very much of that, because they care more for themselves, and this carelessness makes them blind.
I invite you to answer the question I launched, if you have different oppinions. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
alexa_iliescu Plunger

Data inscrierii: 02/Iun/2011 Mesaje: 30 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 11/06/2011 00:11 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| And now I want to answer Adina's question. I also think that Winston was an intelligent man. But he was alone against the whole system - which was sustained by a lot of brain-washed people (and it came to my mind what Alexandru Lapusneanul said: "stupid, but many"). I think Winston realised that he would never be able to to change anything and even if he had developed a better way of lying, as Adina said, it would have been worthless. Finally, he accepted to be part of the mass and to obey, because he wanted to get rid of the burden of not believing in the system and, on the other side, not being able to do anything to escape. If he didn't find a way to get out of there, he chose the opposite way, that of going deeper in that world of lies, the way of resignation and obedience. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Teacher Administrator

Data inscrierii: 26/Mar/2008 Mesaje: 471
|
Trimis: 11/06/2011 08:04 Titlul subiectului: Re: 1984 george orwell |
|
|
| Persida-Mara a scris: | I didnt't like the fact that children was learn to trade their parents. The dictator controlled everything, the soul of human, no privilege to make iluzions or dreams. The totalitarism characters are sow obvious in this book only because of psychological manipulation, the telescreen which see the behaviour of all people, and sex is only a way to make children for the Party can have new members to the system.
Which is the role of propaganda in this novel? |
I'm not sure I understand what you mean. There a few obvious mistakes (of grammar, spelling and lexic) here:
"children was learn to trade"
In these 5 words you made 4 errors!
"children was" -- grammatical disagreement; plural subject with special verb! Correct: "children were"
"was learn" -- two problems here:
1. wrong choice of verb (lexical confusion). "Learn" means just "a invata ceva" but never "a invata pe cineva". For the latter meaning you must use "to teach" = "a invata pe cineva".
2. bad grammatical construction. I suppose you meant to use the passive ("au fost invatati"), but then, just like in Romanian, the verb has to be in the past participle: "teach" >> p.p. "taught"
Therefore the correct construction would be:
"were taught"
"to trade" = lexical confusion. Furkulition. The verb means "a face comert cu," "a vinde". You probably meant "a trada," but in this case, the verb was "to betray"
Please try to identify yourself what was wrong with the other words that I emphasized in red. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Adelinne Diver

Data inscrierii: 11/Noi/2009 Mesaje: 62
|
Trimis: 11/06/2011 13:10 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
I think that this book has a connection between communism. Firstly because there was no personal freedom, or very little. Most of the aspects of life was controlled, all our action observed by the agents of security. And if you presented a risk to the communist party, they would lock you up, interrogated you, and you were beaten up. All this are presented is Orwell’s 1984, but in a more exaggerated way. Children were also indoctrinated into the beliefs of the party ( as in performing activities for the party), you had to do what they told you. If you were missing from rehearsals, or from these activities, you became suspicious. There were also regular TV programs or in radios, meant to increase the peoples love for the Party and the leader of the Party. Ceausescu was a Big Brother for Romania, just like a Big Brother in Orwell’s 1984. There was also a fear of intellectuals in communism. We can identify these individuals as the “proles” in 1984. This fear was probably because they bought something new, new ideas, which were usually against the party. People were brainwashed. They were led to know that the communist Party is idyllic, a utopia. You were not allowed to know too much, because they feared that you’ll see the truth. The constant fear of not saying something against the Party. Even now days, people think that communism was idyllic. People were so happy with those extra chocolate, or food rations, like in Orwell’s 1984, that they could not see what is really happening, they acted as if they were blind, brainwashed.
Izabella Strimb |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Alexandra Marchis Dunker

Data inscrierii: 11/Noi/2009 Mesaje: 12
|
Trimis: 11/06/2011 17:18 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
Through this novel Orwell tried to give us a glimpse of what totalitarianism (comunism) means and how dangerous it can be to human society from all p.o.v (social,cultural). First of all, as in Winston case, we would be deprived of what independence and civil rights represents. We would have no liberties, no life. Just the fact that we would be supervised be a telescreen it denotes how fare this "ideal" would get. Revolution always had two types of people: the idealist, who realy believe in their goal and the pragmaticists, who only think about the material gain. It is obvious which is who, and the novel is full of such examplifications. All the actions of the Party were made in their benefit, in the citizens's detriment. Let's take the Ministry of Truth for example. This always took care of what information is given to the citizen, so that no way they get somehow rebellious. They only gave information so that the citizens support the Party's decisions. The fact that they reduced the vocabulary to positive words, proves the fact that there is no interest in community's evolution but in its stagnations and decay. Moreover, not receiving accurate information it is impossible for the citizens to have any grasp of information of the past and present life. It gets such a powerful government that influences even the most private parts of our life. Children should support their parents, be raised with love and harmony, whereas, under this leadership, they are raised to support the Party. It is inconceivable to ask children not to love their parents but the system. This leads to the destruction of the family. Similarly, is the fact that even procreation must be done for the Party. Winston's wife for e.g., didn't like to make love with her husband but, being loyal to the Party, she scheduled time for it, calling it "duty to the Party".
All considered we see that is no sense of personality, individuality, freedom in citizens lives. They operate on a system which gives them nothing but a poor routine. For them to be independent means to be insane. In the end, Winston being forced to cure "his insanity". |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Salageanu Adela Dunker

Data inscrierii: 13/Noi/2009 Mesaje: 23 Localitate: Satu Mare
|
Trimis: 13/06/2011 08:47 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
In this novel it is shown a system which doesn’t allow people to do anything. They can’t say what they are thinking, they can’t have a family without the ‘system’s approval’, they can’t have children without the system knowing about it, they can’t do anything because they are being watched in all their actions.
This book presents many interesting facts about communism, as the girls mentioned above in their posts. It was a period when the system made what it wanted without thinking of others needs and thoughts. People betrayed themselves when they were put in front of their greatest fears (fear was a torture used by the system in order to get what they want), children also betrayed their parents, the brainwashing was in flower in that period. If a person thought differently from the system, that person was insane and s/he needed to be cured. I consider that the system described in the novel was exaggerated, because we, people, can’t grow in a world like that, we need to be free to think what we want, to say our beliefs, not be controlled at every moment (in the novel the Big Brother controls everything). People need to be free to fall in love with whomever they like, not what the system imposes you to. A big dystopia, I might say, presents this book, a world where guilt was put in charge of those who had the courage to think, who wanted to change something, but could not succeed. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Adyna Plunger

Data inscrierii: 10/Dec/2009 Mesaje: 28
|
Trimis: 13/06/2011 14:40 Titlul subiectului: Re: 1984 george orwell |
|
|
"Things" that govern the system in Overall's novel are based on slogans:[War is peace], [Freedom is slavery], [Ignorance is strengh] and they certainly looks deliberatly ambiguous values which directs this system.Because however you thing, natural logic can not understand it and the only way to accept it is that of "doublethink', to accept the false as a true.(when Winston have's to accept that in fact that there are not so much fingers that he sees, but there are as many as sistem says).
what I didn't liked in this novel is the fact that the only tolerated feelings in this society were love to Party, love to "Big Brother" and hate to Oceania's enemies.
Corjuc Romina |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Adyna Plunger

Data inscrierii: 10/Dec/2009 Mesaje: 28
|
Trimis: 13/06/2011 16:00 Titlul subiectului: Re: 1984 george orwell |
|
|
1984 was an interesting book for me beacuse I saw here a system of rules
that I think destroyed the society in which live Winston. The fact that they where let to live without feelings and liberty of choice or thinking was so cruell. This restrictions take them oll the rights that they have and put them in front of the society that used them like a machines. Big Brother forced them to love and respect only the Party,and supposed them to live without consideration for others. Even children were learned to betroy their parents when they make some 'mistakes'.
Grad Florina |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Adyna Plunger

Data inscrierii: 10/Dec/2009 Mesaje: 28
|
Trimis: 13/06/2011 21:29 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
I want to answer Alexandra Iliescu’s question about the proles. I think that the proles would have never been able to change something and this because they weren’t as struggled as people like Winston were. Because they could get married, they weren’t followed every minute by the telescreen, so they had fewer restrictions. On the other hand, they weren’t as well informed as Winston or Julia was. They didn’t know everything that was going on with the social and political system, because they didn’t have access to the interior part of it. So they didn’t know that Oceania was in war with Eurasia or Eustasia. They may have thought that they misunderstood, because they didn’t have the real proof, as Winston had, of the fact that history was changed. So, I don’t think that they could have changed something, alone. If someone from the ‘inside’ as Winston, would have informed, instructed and helped them, maybe they could have changed something.
I want to tell Alexandra Marchis that is truth what she said about Winston’s wife and the children that were learned to love their Party and not their parents. But almost at the end of the book, O’Brien speaks about the world the Party wants to form, and this one of its targets. They wanted to create a world in which Big Brother is supposed to be everything, and supposed to fulfill all humans need, like: love, sex, even the act of thinking |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Unguras Flavia Dunker

Data inscrierii: 13/Noi/2009 Mesaje: 20
|
Trimis: 21/06/2011 18:45 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
This book reminds me of "Fenomenul Piteşti" by Virgil Ierunca, a book that shook me; (the facts happened, unfortunately, in reality).
Referring to 1984 , if we abandon generalizations and focus strictly on doctrine and psychological mechanisms we understand that any totalitarian system has the same triggers of a sick idea.
Winston is an individual without education or a hero, who makes the supreme mistake of thinking against the Party and he stubbornly insisted to understand why the past changes and why apparently only he notifies these gross lies.
The dialogue between him and O'Brien - his torturer, clearly describes all the ins and outs of building power. From the simple observation that power is not a means but a purpose in itself. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Florina Grad Dunker

Data inscrierii: 10/Feb/2010 Mesaje: 20
|
Trimis: 22/06/2011 16:04 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
This book describe a hard way to live. An entire mass of people were controlled from all points of view, even to think was considered a crime against the society.Even trust between the people that formed a family was transformed in incredulity because children were learned to betray their parents if they have done something that contradicted The Big Brother which not appears along the novel only in images with the message: " Big Brother is watching You". In my point of view is very probably that he even not existed and representing just a symbol well thinking by government because in this way all pain and agony were around The Big Brother. It's obvious that manipulation, language and mind control were basic rules for society, existing even an organization of Junior Spies. People arrive at point in that they can't think individual and take decisions regarding to their future. All is in the hands of Party and people are treated like some dolls which haven't feelings and desires. The psychological manipulation is very deep in this novel because people arrived at the stage in which they accept that life like a natural one without trying to fight against the system because the Party controls even their bodies with strong brutality torture. Winston Smith is the protagonist of this novel, hates the Party and keep a diary in which writes all his thoughts. He fall in love with Julia and both had in common hatred of the Party. The Party found about their relationship and punished Winston by a cruel torture so that at one ocazie he wants that all pain to be transferred to Julia despite of their love story. In this way, by physical control appears psychological manipulation so that people affirmed that 2+2=5.
Buzila Ioana
Ultima modificare efectuata de catre Florina Grad la 22/06/2011 17:45, modificat de 1 data in total |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Florina Grad Dunker

Data inscrierii: 10/Feb/2010 Mesaje: 20
|
Trimis: 22/06/2011 16:38 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
In the above I forgot to mention that Winston even at first wasn't agree with all that treatments finally accepted to live in that world because he was one against more.
Buzila Ioana |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Unguras Flavia Dunker

Data inscrierii: 13/Noi/2009 Mesaje: 20
|
Trimis: 22/06/2011 17:03 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
O'Brien explains Winston that consciousness of a man by his own may fail, can be deceived, and absolute truth is owned by the collective consciousness of the Party who is never wrong.
The most fine and stronger visual expression from the exposure of the torturer it's the same like when you want a suggestive image of the future then you must imagine a huge boot pressing on a human face forever - this would be the best definition of Totalitarianism: forced by any means the individual to undergo a mindset dictated by a supreme leader - either one in the flesh or only an indoctrinated picture of leaders in power. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Ticala Ioana Diver

Data inscrierii: 11/Noi/2009 Mesaje: 56
|
Trimis: 22/06/2011 17:19 Titlul subiectului: 1984 by George Orwell |
|
|
1984 is a book who is speaking about a totalitarian state who controls evreything.This state is named Oceania and is conduced by a group named The Party,the dictator is Big Brother.This story is about a man called Winston Smith who hates the Party in secret and he will decide to revolt by writing a letter when he will write his thoughts.Because he had keeped that letter he will be discovered by the Thought Police and he will be killed.So what do you think Why people had so less freedom in those times?
Ultima modificare efectuata de catre Ticala Ioana la 24/06/2011 19:55, modificat de 1 data in total |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
larisapop Plunger

Data inscrierii: 09/Noi/2009 Mesaje: 36 Localitate: Baia Mare
|
Trimis: 22/06/2011 18:31 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
When I started to read this book I was amazed to see in how many ways the political power controls people. When I saw that Winston begins to have a relationship with Julia, something told me that things in the society will change in a good way. Even when they were both imprisoned I still had that hope that good will win. I was very dissapointed to see that after so many struggles of both of them to remain against Big Brother, the political power won. It is like when wings start to grow, someone comes and cuts them off cruelly. I found myself very interested in this book because I considered that I would do the same as Winston in a society like that, meaning that I would try to fight against all the mesures taken in order to turn people into robots. I wonder why George Orwell cut Winston's wings?... Could it be that people like him would have no chance to stand in front of a power like the one presented in this novel? _________________ You don't write because you want to say something, you write because you've got something to say. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
Nicolae Roxana Rookie

Data inscrierii: 10/Iun/2011 Mesaje: 6
|
Trimis: 23/06/2011 20:02 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| The science fiction novel by George Orwell “1984” shows how the writer thought the world would be in 1984. Most of the predicted things were right on the mark but nevertheless there were some that weren’t. I believe that the vision Orwell had about the future in the collective society is closer then some may want to admit to reality. The term “Big Brother” is known today mainly because of this book because Orwell wrote it in a higher position than others in the British government. This book is one that makes you use brain power since it’s composed by several themes beneath the main one. I believe this is one of the things that represent Orwell's style of writing. This can also be noticed in his other work “Animal Farm”. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
anastasia Plunger

Data inscrierii: 17/Noi/2009 Mesaje: 27
|
Trimis: 26/06/2011 12:41 Titlul subiectului: |
|
|
| In "1984" Orwell represents a world future society as a totalitarian hierarchical system based on physical and spiritual slavery. System, based on general fear and hatred, where the inhabitants do not live, but survive under the constant observation of the "Big Brother". This system is incredible close to the communism’s ideas and, I can say it’s relevant nowadays, when the same totalitarian system based on manipulation, lies, mass control is hidden behind democracy. |
|
| Sus |
|
 |
|
|
Nu puteti crea un subiect nou in acest forum Nu puteti raspunde in subiectele acestui forum Nu puteti modifica mesajele proprii din acest forum Nu puteti sterge mesajele proprii din acest forum Nu puteti vota in chestionarele din acest forum
|
|